Manchester United vs. QPR

Status
Not open for further replies.
Right - so the list of problems with that decision are thus:

1) it was offside
2)it wasn't a penalty
3)Young wasn't booked for diving
4)it wasn't a red card given he was never getting to the ball.

Just as well I want QPR to go down.


if it was offside the rest does not apply. or do you not understand the rules yet?


I agree it was offside.
 
The media are going to basically make this out like we couldn't beat QPR at home without that decision.
 
Good we're one up but this has ruined the game for me. What a horrible decision.

An absolute cretin of a ref.
 
how the linesman didnt give an offside makes no sense, he had a perfect view, conspiracy!!!!

We don't need a penalty or a red card to win this game anyway. The linesman missed it because he's only human. But City and all ABUs would have you believed otherwise.
 
Yes, whilst I am clearly happy we're winning, there is a voice in me wishing that hadn't happened. I think we'd still have beaten them with their full XI but that was embarrassing from Young and just gives people further excuse to say we don't deserve it when the officiating is that bad.
 
Rooney not booked.
Young offside not give leading to the goal and a red for them.

Shocker so far from the officials.
 
Penalty was soft but the real shocker was the offside call. I know Young goes down easy but I don't think this one was as bad as first looked, the push was enough to put him off balance but not go to ground in the way he did.
 
Is it my impression or was Young being booed over there?
 
:lol: Rawk & Bluemoon will explode. Harsh, offside as feck. Looked a dive as well.

Don't like seeing Young dive, but it's going to be funny to see the conspiracy theories

Two home games in a row they have been handed wins. Don't tell me this league isn't bent.

How did the ref help us against Fulham?
 
Shocking decision. We could have won that game fair and square, and now all we'll hear about is the ref and contentious decisions?
 
Its always a bad news in england when the technically decent team manage to outwit the underdog who can only bring passion to the table.

yes. if this was against liverpool, i'd be delighted and laughing like maniac, but against a much lesser team like QPR seems unfair to us

this will give every ABU in the world to claim we won over a bad ref call whilst completely disregarding that we deserve largely to win
 
I am actually embarrassed by that a bit. Not feeling a great deal of pleasure from getting that goal oddly. As weird as that sounds.
 
Thats just shocking. Couldn't even celebrate that goal.
How can you not see thats offside. There's clear daylight nobody blocking the way.
Shocking stuff.
 
De Gea could have been embarrassed by that deflected shot
 
feck that shit, we are winning and we should take it any way possible. Do you think city fans would not take your hand off for a similar call later today?

Some feeling unhappy after this maybe reading too much into those idiots who think we are corrupt
 
We don't need a penalty or a red card to win this game anyway. The linesman missed it because he's only human. But City and all ABUs would have you believed otherwise.

The linesman was also possibly under instructions from Howard Webb to ensure that we got off on the right foot today.
 
Still baffled about the offside decision that led to the penalty, yet alone mention the bit about Young going down that easily.
 
We were going to win regardless, but now the ref has given everyone ammo against us. I'm actually annoyed at the refs decision.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.