I dont watch Serie A - to be honest I havent watched anything of him on YouTube either. Im going on a very limited amount of first hand evidence and a lot on reports / reputation.
The thing with Pogba for me is he represents my burning desire for a really top quality player in the middle of the park. I dont know how long Ive been yearning for such a signing to be honest, it goes back years. I remember many threads about our non-existent midfield back in the olden days, the kinds of threads that speculated about whether Anderson would come back from injury and be like a new signing. For many years we didnt get anyone in that position at all, in recent years we have signed quite a few but none of them have been quite as satisfying as I was really looking for. Like trudging through the desert with no water, on the verge of dying, and then finding a few leaves with some condensation on them: enough to stave off death for a few hours, but not the litre of cool water I had been dreaming of.
I do hope, and still have some confidence, that Schneiderlin will kick on and have a better season next year than he did this year, in which case I will upgrade him from leaf with condensation on it to small glass of old, sun-warmed water with dust and some sand floating in it. Probably same with Herrera - I havent given up hope him being a lot better for us under a new manager. Maybe if both of these things happened next season my midfielder cravings will die down.
In a way you can trace this all the way back to the retirement of Keane, and the search for that absolutely top drawer, battling, leader and all-action midfielder to replace him. I love the idea of a midfield general and Pogba, as I understand it, has the capacity to be that player.
But as I said I havent actually seen much of him and it may be that there are other alternatives who could play that role for us too. I think I posted something similar to this in the Vidal thread a few years ago. I dont think Pogba is going to come but whenever we are linked to a central midfielder of this ilk I will always be excited.