Paul Pogba | Undergoing Medical | Helping out the Laundry Ladies

Do you want Pogba for £100 million?


  • Total voters
    1,968
Yes yes. Essien, Sneijder and Lampard were all world class when they joined Mourinho's teams. They didn't improve Mourinho at all. Nope, not a chance.
Lampard wasnt signed by Jose and had a great debut chelsea season under Ranieri

Sneijder was a real madrid player before Jose signed him

I would give him some credit for essien
 
Narrowly viewed, you can draw many outlandish conclusions. No one doubted Messi being a great talent pre-Pep, but he became a different player with him. There isn't a midfielder who transformed and became a special talent under Mou that wasn't or hadn't been already
Odd thing to say, but do you have any theory as to why, if you really think it's true? Do you admit he's improved centre backs, keepers, full backs, wingers and strikers? Just not midfielders? What does that say about him exactly as a coach?
 
Lampard wasnt signed by Jose and had a great debut chelsea season under Ranieri

Sneijder was a real madrid player before Jose signed him

I would give him some credit for essien

Sneijder and Lampard both turned into Ballon'd or nominees under Mourinho.
 
Do Madrid ever do silent transfers of this magnitude? When they went for Ronaldo, Bale, James, Kaka and even their pursuit of De Gea, it was all over the papers. They like to make a huge fuss of things and get it out there that they're signing this big name.

Plus lets be fair, they're up against United and after the whole De Gea incident and the backwards and forwards accusations over who's to blame, Real would most definitely want to get one over on us. I bet they'd have it known to everyone they were back in for Pogba and would do whatever it took to secure him. Real just don't do big transfers on the silent do they?
 
Transfers are so complicated these days, remember watching a programme in the 90's where one chairman would pick up the phone and make an offer for a player, if they accepted they then gave players permission to talk with the club, done and dusted in days, really cant stand agents in the game, there is potentially 20m going straight out the game of football, imagine what they could do in the grassroots of football, things like this need capped, its embarrassing for the sport and needs looked at.

Transfers are not complicated. Not this complicated and detailed anyway. Its the plethora of mind-numbing, imaginary stories peddled by BS merchants in media (often aided by some parties involved in transfer) two weeks before and after the day something concrete happens that make the transfer duration seem like an eternity and the transfer process like rocket science. Agents, Club directors, Players are all at the mercy of these articles for they chose anyone to be the villain or the hero to justify their own narrative. For this one they went with Riola demanding money rather than Woodward being incompetent or unwilling to play two million pounds more to seal the deal. The positive side is it saves our media-trusting fans a lot of Woodward bashing. Poor Riola though :lol:.
 
Sneijder and Lampard both turned into Ballon'd or nominees under Mourinho.
both were headed that way with or without Jose

Ranieri deserves huge credit for Lampard

Sneijder had just been named in the team of the tournament in Euro 2008 and was unfortunate to be dumped by Real Madrid
 
Lampard wasnt signed by Jose and had a great debut chelsea season under Ranieri

Sneijder was a real madrid player before Jose signed him

I would give him some credit for essien
The original comment was that Mourinho hadn't made any midfielder better, had nothing to do with signing midfielders. I definitely disagree. Lampard and Sneijder definitely became better under Mourinho. Hell, even Makelele became the very influential player he was under Mourinho. Then going back, players like Deco. Lots of midfielders have become better under Mourinho.

To be honest, I'm struggling to think of many midfielders who became worse under him.
 
The original comment was that Mourinho hadn't made any midfielder better, had nothing to do with signing midfielders. I definitely disagree. Lampard and Sneijder definitely became better under Mourinho. Hell, even Makelele became the very influential player he was under Mourinho. Then going back, players like Deco. Lots of midfielders have become better under Mourinho.

To be honest, I'm struggling to think of many midfielders who became worse under him.
:lol: Makelele was one of Reals most important players. It was a disgrace he was sold
 
The original comment was that Mourinho hadn't made any midfielder better, had nothing to do with signing midfielders. I definitely disagree. Lampard and Sneijder definitely became better under Mourinho. Hell, even Makelele became the very influential player he was under Mourinho. Then going back, players like Deco. Lots of midfielders have become better under Mourinho.

To be honest, I'm struggling to think of many midfielders who became worse under him.

Ay, can't think of many. Oscar maybe? Then again, maybe he never really was very good.
 
Now Mou is getting credit for Sneijder? Lyon made Essien a sought after star and a Chelsea fan will remind you that Lamps' ascendency as a player began before Mou's arrval. Some imaginitive player development but then many think Pogba was formed at United too

Busquets joined Barca when he was 17, Puyol when he 17, Pedro when he was 17. You consider then as graduated or formed at famed La Masia but Pogba who joined United when he was 16 is not ManUtd academy player. Weird logic.
 
All based on the assumption that the following information is correct.

1/ Raiola + Juventus have a contract stating that Juventus have obligation to pay a 20% fee of any future transfer of Pogba.
2/ After preliminary agreement on fee between Man Utd and Juve, Juve then insist Man Utd pay agents fee

This is how it should be done.

1/ Man Utd in coordination with Raiola should have a legal binding document between themselves stating that both parties are in acknowledgement that Juve are essentially blackmailing Man Utd by attempting to invalidate the contract between Raiola and Juve re 20% fee.
2/ Man Utd should pay the agreed fee to Juventus and Raiola's 20% fee
3/ Use the legally binding document made between Man Utd + Raiola to sue the feck out of Juventus.
4/ Make sure that the legal case is dragged out in the public domain using ALL means neccessary to make it clear what type of underhanded club Juventus are and in the process destroying all notion of the 'romance' that the name Juventus once had.
5/ After winning the legal case against Juventus make it clear that Man Utd stand for freedom, honesty and integrity

And finally

Feck Juventus

** EDIT **
Oh and please have pity on a fellow n00b muppet, redcafe member and help me to the realms of manhood

You my friend are a genius..
:devil:
 
What I'm lost on - why has raiola gone to Miami to speak to Pogba if the hold up is to do with his fees with Man Utd?
 
Busquets joined Barca when he was 17, Puyol when he 17, Pedro when he was 17. You consider then as graduated or formed at famed La Masia but Pogba who joined United when he was 16 is not ManUtd academy player. Weird logic.

I didn't claim Busquets is a cantera product, just that Pep made him the player he is - Puyol & him are Catalan and play the Barcelona way.

Anyway, we'll see if RM are interested in Pogba for real in the coming days because I suspect the player would prefer that move too - but just a hunch
 
Can anyone fill me with optimism.Looks like we are about to lose out on another player to Madrid.

Absolutely mental. Kindly cut-out this Chicken Licken hysterical nonsense. You have zero basis to make such assertions and and your paranoia is doing nothing but spoiling the enjoyment of others.
 
I didn't claim Busquets is a cantera product, just that Pep made him the player he is - Puyol & him are Catalan and play the Barcelona way.

Jose has improved midfielders and other positions. We would just have to ask the players and they would say yes. A simple way to look at it. There's truths and then there are things we think. It would be natural for players that have been managed by him - midfielders in this case - would say they have improved and who are we to say they're lying? Even if it's only improving their mentality in some instances.
 
I think we have to get pogba this time whatever the cost...

if we look at midfield we buy the last 3 year (fellaini, depay, mata, schneiderlin, herrera, schweni) have cost us more than 120 million pounds and all of them are flop so far... buy pogba for 120 million and don't buy any midfield for the next 5 year..

we also need to get rid of that surplus midfielder to cut our wage for pogba so I hope at least 3 of them is gone now or next season...
 
What I'm lost on - why has raiola gone to Miami to speak to Pogba if the hold up is to do with his fees with Man Utd?

It BS, Di Marzio is a fraud and just posts click bait every night around 10 and people lap it up.

Got Gomes embarrassingly wrong.

Why would an agent need to fly to see a his client, it's laughable. Sign contract? Yeah sure, Pogba would fly to the UK for that.

Discuss details? Would just use the phone.
 
Busquets joined Barca when he was 17, Puyol when he 17, Pedro when he was 17. You consider then as graduated or formed at famed La Masia but Pogba who joined United when he was 16 is not ManUtd academy player. Weird logic.
1st round k.o. right there...
 
if we look at midfield we buy the last 3 year (fellaini, depay, mata, schneiderlin, herrera, schweni) have cost us more than 120 million pounds and all of them are flop so far... buy pogba for 120 million and don't buy any midfield for the next 5 year..

Mata is more an attacker, I'd say, but I get your point...all those players have been average/poor.
Bastian hardly ever plays a full game. Morgan was decent in some games but anonymous in most.
Fellaini had his uses (Plan B) and was good for that.
Herrera has been a bench warmer most of the time, so in LVG's opinion was not good enough.

But I do agree that after spending so much money, it seems like we have ended up with players who are not good enough to feature in a title winning team, either due to injury or just not being good enough.
 
Raiola was the agent for Nedved too? Bloody hell he's a worm.
 
Right, seen this all before, he's Madrid's. It's almost literally the same as every other failed transfer, and it's all pointing towards us missing out now.

Shame - I'd just in the last day or so started to believe we had this in the bag. Just to rub salt in the wounds I was getting referendum flashbacks last night, as all the confidence and optimism suddenly got hit about 11pm by the Gomes news and the quote from Mourinho.

Ah well, hope whoever else we've got lined up proves to be just as good at half the price!
Wow:lol:
You sir need a snickers!
 
Not more marketable. Just NEW. DiMaria had already sold all the shirts he was gonna sell, and now all he wanted was a contract extension and higher wages for extraordinary performances. Rodriguez couldn´t demand such high wages due to the high transfer fee and his overall standing. In retrospect United should have been more thorough with their process. DiMaria never wanted to play in England. I think to a lesser extent there is a similar danger with Pogba and Mkhitaryan. I don´t think Pogba would have considered this move, if not for his agent pushing it. He seemed genuinely happy at Juventus. On the other hand I think Pogba is the type of player that says "whatever, tell me where and when, and I play".

The reports I read said Mkhitaryan was desperate to sign. Plus nobody forced Di Maria he came for the cash (that's the reason behind most things in life). Pogba you're speculating as we don't know where he wants to go.
 
It BS, Di Marzio is a fraud and just posts click bait every night around 10 and people lap it up.

Got Gomes embarrassingly wrong.

Why would an agent need to fly to see a his client, it's laughable. Sign contract? Yeah sure, Pogba would fly to the UK for that.

Discuss details? Would just use the phone.

Agree with this, journalists in general know feck all unless being briefed by clubs/agents.

It doesn't make sense for him to fly around the world to speak to Pogba, we have things called telephones and computers with cameras which can connect people instantly.
 
Juv really are colossus feck squabbling over the fee.

I know people are saying we should just pay it ourselves or up the bid so it is covered, but its principle, the fee was agreed, Juv knew they had to pay the fee. We would look incredibly weak, we already get walked over enough in negotiations.
 
If Real Madrid baulked at the initial price why would they get involved after we become irritated by excessive demands from Juventus? makes no sense whatsoever.

At this stage, I really can't see any other outcome than him signing for us.
 
So Juve promised Raiola 20% of any transfer fee that they recieved so that he would persuade Pogba to sign for them, and now they've decided to go back on their word? If that's true then they shouldn't be surprised if agents act like arseholes to them from now on.
 
I honestly had no idea how emotionally scarred the members of this board were until now. The fear and worry about Real off the back of a few tweets is unbelievable.
 
Why would an agent need to fly to see a his client, it's laughable. Sign contract? Yeah sure, Pogba would fly to the UK for that.

Discuss details? Would just use the phone.

Logically, you are correct.
But logically, why would we still rely on faxes?
 
Hold on, they should act in good faith because we didn't make an illegal approach to the players agent earlier in the Summer?

The thing about Evra is insane too, we obviously thought he wasn't worth the wage he was on anymore, we weren't doing Juve a favour.
Yep thats exactly what I meant....

I'm saying Real have done it twice with us and despite the fees involved in bringing him in, we didn't, but instead offered them a more than generous transfer fee. We could have been cnuts, but weren't. The stumbling block seems to be their agreement with the agent which, judging by reports, they now insist we should be paying. That is taking the piss.

Re Evra- Missed the point again. I had little issue with the sale, but we sold them a player who had a lot of football left in him for 3m. He was the starter at LB for France this summer. You obviously didn't read Devilish's post, but for a all Juve's talk of being a supposed big club, they are penny pinching cnuts which seems to be showing again.
 
So Juve promised Raiola 20% of any transfer fee that they recieved so that he would persuade Pogba to sign for them, and now they've decided to go back on their word? If that's true then they shouldn't be surprised if agents act like arseholes to them from now on.
It would almost certainly rule out a contract renewal in the very least.