It's not like it was intentional, surely that's not the rule?
Premier League Gameweek 37
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
- Status
Idk he's dirty alright, but Costa is level above IMO.
I never get how footballers slip while kicking a dead ball.
What has happened?
Credit to the ref for that one TBH.
Bizarre that you don't get to retake that. Not as if he did it in purpose
Fair play to the ref that was a good spot.
Still tho, Madley is a man on a mission.
This is an absurd game
Should a pen be retaken if the player slips and misses?
pen incident - Mahrez fecks it up
Ahhhh! Got it 
Why is it not a retake? All other scenarios end up with retakes
Costa is dirty in the sense of play-acting and drama, but he rarely ever injures anyone. Fernandinho deserves a red every second match because he just kicks the living shit out of the opposition.
He slipped as he took it and got two touches so disallowed
I really don't like this rule. You can't pass to yourself which I imagine is intended to stop players fooling the ref (edit: meant keeper) in some way, but this is purely accidental. But them's the rules I guess, so the ref did well here. I always though an infringement of the team taking the penalty resulted in a retake in case of a converted penalty however. Should look that up, but it seems unlikely the ref would miss that.
Nope, not in the rules.
well they do retake them if the goalie moves early or if the players move in the box too fast
Nope, if it's a stop from the taker it's the same thing but with a yellow for the taker too. Madley has done well there, no complaints, it's Mahrez who's shit.
Lol!
That was in reply to people calling him stupid/an idiot.
The rule is dumb though. Punishing an accidental effectively.
Watch that be in FIFA 18 next year
Didn't Griezmann have a double touch when taking a pen in the week against Madrid?
Huh? That's hardly Mahrez' fault.
Well obviously not. It's a completely different thing. The two touch rule is to stop a player dribbling it off the penalty spot. I think the rule should allow a retake
Just look those 2 games against West Ham and Watford at the beginning of the season where he almost broken Adrian's leg.
But that's when an opposition player does something wrong. A penalty is never retaken when the taker cocks it up.
I don't see how it's a particularly noteworthy bit of refereeing, it was pretty obvious as most of the players immediately protested!
Penalty rules are different for different outcomes. Encroachment by an attacker for example, if the penalty is scored there's a retake. If the penalty is missed it's an indirect free kick to the opposing team.
Don't see why that should be different myself.
If the ref is that picky why not pull the goalkeeper for being off his line?
Dman that midget Aguero so quick on his feet.
If his first touch is still in contact with the ball, could it not be judged as one touch,even when it touches the other boot?
Zabaleta looks like the late Robin Gibb.
The pitch could be a factor.
Makes you think... The home team should just mess up the area around the penalty spot in the second half for the opposition.
Griezmanns penalty has count against Real.
You can slip everytime, i think retake the penalty is the better option.
You can slip everytime, i think retake the penalty is the better option.
You had no problem spotting that but missed the elbow and the offside goal you fat twat.
Planting your foot with force on a surface that's likely soaked and soft.
Whose fault is it, do you think?
Remember the prices that were tossed around for Mahrez?
So glad we didn't take a punt. Been hugely underwhelming this season.
So glad we didn't take a punt. Been hugely underwhelming this season.
- Status