Great post, especially the final paragraph. Lockdown was awesome from my point of view.
SARS CoV-2 coronavirus / Covid-19 (No tin foil hat silliness please)
- Thread starter Don't Kill Bill
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
I think it might be because they have relatively few cases and the possibility of eliminating the virus from the everyday community which in turn. leads to back to normal life. Also its one state thats locked down and largely focussed on one big city.
Was at a petrol station yesterday with the missus and it had a massive sign up before you go into the store basically saying no mask, no service
Most people were great apart from 3 or 4 I saw in a 15 minute window. Just marching in with a look on their face spoiling for a fight if anyone mentions masks to them
UK 2948 cases, 3 deaths
Italy 1,108 cases and 12 deaths. It's not shooting up as I thought it might, which is good news.
Other news on quarantine for travellers entering England (BBC):
Other news on quarantine for travellers entering England (BBC):
He only does videos but he was very good at tracking the pandemic back in January/early February and explaining things in simple English before we all became virus ‘experts‘
His video today is on a randomised trial in a Spanish hospital showing very good results using vitamin D combined with standard treatment. It’s something he’s been talking about for months and could possibly explain why certain groups are more vulnerable. Like a lot of these studies though the sample size is small.
Like I say he certainly isn’t a good news merchant. He said this was bad from the start and he’s been very critical of the WHO, the US, the publishing of poor clinical studies in previously respected journals and in particular the UK in dealing with the pandemic.
2 local schools in the last half hour in my town have announced years having to isolate for 14 days after 1 day of opening.
Yeah, our youngest went back on Thursday and today the school have 2 classes that were sent home because of a case.
Wow, off your rockers over there.
It's just the way the school has set things up. The year groups are each split into two for "bubbles", they have outdoor breaks together and have the same entrance/exits, so there will have been some interactions between the two classes.
Caerphilly?
Bridgend. Caerphilly are on a near lockdown as of tonight - nobody in or out unless essential.
I don't think they have to isolate unless they/their child shows symptoms.
Sounds bizarre. Nonsensical
They should.
My kids went back to school last week, and within two days my daughter was sent home with a sore throat and temperature. She got tested on Saturday, and result came through negative this morning, but it meant the whole household had to isolate until that came through.
That was what the text from the school said anyway, I would hope people would self isolate and I know we will in that situation.
I think the school and class should remain open and parents of the infected kid should isolate.
If anyone else gets symptoms, isolate.
Sending entire classes home for two weeks is a recipe for another utterly fecked semester.
Do we know roughly how many are asymptomatic?
I currently work in a school and have been wondering whether it makes sense to just send home close contacts until tested or you need to send classes home. If most people are asymptomatic it might not be good enough to wait for symptoms in terms of controlling spread.
We haven't had any cases I know of yet but it'll probably happen at some point.
What age are we talking about?
I'm mainly dealing with the 6-10 year olds but we have pupils up to 15 or so.
I'm just imagining a situation where one kid or teacher is tested positive and we take too few people out of the school. And so it spreads to the next kid or teacher, rinse and repeat.
But that hasn’t been happening in Europe in those age groups, why would it here?
Schools of young kids don’t seem to be an issue, not sure why the UK is desperate to make them one.
I don't know. It just seems like something that could spiral, it's good it hasn't happened and doesn't seem to though, obviously.
The UK just seem to be making way too big a deal out of it, the science and data so far doesn’t appear to make it any big issue.
Schools will never get going if you’re gonna shut it down for 14 days everytime someone catches this virus. For kids they are appear way more likely to catch it at home from parents and don’t look like any significant driver in the spread.
I received an invite to have one of those at home antibody tests the government are doing for their research. Has anyone else done one of those?
I agree with that. And I do think schools should be kept open as much as possible.
Although I'm sure we'll see entire classes send home around Denmark with intermittent online teaching as people wait for their test results.
My partner got one today. Quiet looking forward to finding out if we’ve had it or not, weirdly!
Have you seen the gatherings outside uk schools? No, thought not
Like all viruses schools will be major drivers especially in winter. That very young kids have far fewer symptoms (and thus get tested less so we underestimate infection rates as well) isn't really that relevant as they have older siblings, parents and grandparents.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/aug/14/school-reopenings-covid-19-coronavirus-us
Of course you want schools open but to do it safely you need very low overall infection rates and be prepared to close and deep clean individual schools very quickly combined with very speedy track and trace.
I have as well from UCL, waiting for the test to come in the post.
I believe it's only Melbourne in Australia who is taking lockdown seriously. The rest of the states who have really low or no cases are simply stopping anyone from coming in but everything else there is pretty much normal. Also, Melbourne's Premier Dan Andrews is being portrayed as left wing looney in the media but I don't know whether that is true considering most of the sites that pop up in my news feed are right leaning for some reason.
I had one about a month ago that came back negative it's a fingerprick blood test, you get the results within ten minutes.
The link you sent has already been seriously questioned by Pogue, as some states classify kids up to 24. Nor does the report focus on schools and transmission within them, it’s just a report on kids which have been shown to be much more likely to get Covid from a parent than in school.
The “yellow” (0-14) incidence on the report just adds weight to the European findings.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/20...rus-outbreaks-exception-not-norm-first-major/
They aren’t a major driver. Don’t take my word for it, here’s the ECDC:
The ECDC concluded that the evidence shows that “transmission within schools is not a major driver of COVID-19 incidence”.
There’s no point making a sweeping statement like, “like with all viruses” when plenty of evidence to the contrary is already in and we know without any doubt that this virus is special with kids, the flu is much more deadly to them. Hell, for the vast vast majority of young kids, the common cold is a worse experience.
Last edited:
True, sars cov 2 isn't going anywhere though.
All scientific research points to it essentially being new flu, too mild and mutable for vaccination to ever get rid of it.
We can take these actions and have lockdowns. There will be no end though, they'll continue forever.
I have an eviseral hatred of the mail, so excuse this link below:
It's written by Sir John Bell though, who is highly involved with our vaccine development at Oxford university.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/...live-terror-cut-world-Britain-open-again.html
My view is they've already realised any vaccine will be non sterilising and like the yearly flu vaccine best case scenario. So we must get back to normal life asap. No other choice.
Yes, but pinning people down, physically or economically is not an ethical way to convince them!
In Lombardy it has dropped right off again the last couple of days which gives a little hope that now all the August travel has stopped it will get back under control.
Ten minutes!? Mental. Looking forward to it then.
You’re in Bridgend? One of my worst customers comes from there. Eugh