Championship level player though according to some.
Lingard to join West Ham on loan
- Thread starter VeevaVee
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
Then where did the 45m come from? You created an imaginary scenario that wasn't part of the discussion.
Jesus christ what have we done.
There's no planet where Lingard is worth £50m. Come on mate you're getting carried away.
He's approaching 30, 1 year left on his contract in a post Covid transfer market, he's always been wildly inconsistent over the years and will be looking a club to give him something approaching the £100k+ he currently gets.
No clubs paying £50m for Lingard, if we get £20-25m off the back of his recent good form. It would be a fantastic bit of business as going off his last two years of form we would have been lucky to get £10-15m for him.
There's 3 players who can play in his position, Bruno, VDB and Mata, with Mejbri needing some first team outings as well.
Would be good to start a bit of a bidding situation with that calibre of team. West ham, everton, arsenal??
Ideal situation for us is a swap deal with villa for grealish. 60 mil plus lingard with him in this form? can't see them turning that down if jack wants to move
Ideal situation for us is a swap deal with villa for grealish. 60 mil plus lingard with him in this form? can't see them turning that down if jack wants to move
And for reference, Robin van fecking Persie cost less with 1 year on his contract.
What’s your point? Outside of not understanding how transfer fees work.
When it comes to football, I'm almost always right, and I say that with no shame 
He is a joy to watch when he is at full flow.Revived a player's career? This loan was the best thing we've ever done for him. The question now is whether or not he's still hungry to succeed here.
Get him back!
He's a man possessed!
Lingard having a great game but Wolves are making him look like Maradona.
This
Either way it's brilliant though
Lingard might be the best player in the league right now
He said £50 million minimum in a different post. So I chose the next incremental value down from that.
Look for context before you go round looking to criticise.
He has literally turned into a carbon copy of Messi, he gets the ball, turns, dribbles past about three players and then either sets someone up or gets a good shot off.
He's done this countless times in every game he's played since joining them
, he even did it against City.
He's done this countless times in every game he's played since joining them
, he even did it against City.You can bet that if he comes back he’ll be crap again, but I bet if he’s sold even then he wont be much cop once he’s playing for his new club.
Personally I’d sell him for the decent fee we can command. There’s a chance he could come back and be great but I think there’s a bigger chance he’d revert back to his very patchy form.
I’d take Jesse over Mata
Should be asking for at least 40m for him, he's English in his prime and basically Messi. West Ham aren't poor.
Lingard might be the best player in the league right now
What rubbish
You obviously meant the world!
You're using a transfer fee from 10 years ago and you're gonna question my knowledge of how fees work?
He just ran from his own half unchallenged to score, what the feck are Wolves doing when they dont play us?
Definitely, take the 25 mill that his new found form with easily guarantee us and let him continue to flourish at West Ham next season.
We would have been lucky to get 10 mill before the loan and he will be crap if he came back here, we already know that.
Sir Alex loved/loves him, nuff said.
Funny I was about to say the same to you.. you often don't look at or simply ignore the context of the conversation when you butt in, and create an entirely different scenario. If you wanted to ask a specific question out of context, try bolding the sentence you are referring to.
A lot of the games we play in, the opposition pack the defence, and totally nullify Lingard's strengths. It's similar a lot with Dan James.
West Ham is a different proposition.
They hopefully have to go bigger to buy him than any of us thought would happen though.
Cue a 10m fee
West Ham is a different proposition.
They hopefully have to go bigger to buy him than any of us thought would happen though.
Cue a 10m fee
Quite literally no player in the league better than him statistically since his West Ham debut. We were holding him back this whole time!
Same as you mate. Unfortunately Mata isn't going anywhere considering the rumours he's signing a year extension.
Glad he’s doing well.
But anybody who thinks he comes back here to sit on the bench (which he will) and then replicate what he’s doing at West Ham is off their rocker.
He is doing well there because he’s full of confidence and playing every week. Coming back to United to play in a squad role and be put under huge pressure when asked to fill in for the first team will put him right back to square one. @Sandikan makes a good point about the lack of space United get in comparison, too.
Less of the revisionism, folks. Put this down as a great move for all parties and let him go for an acceptable fee.
But anybody who thinks he comes back here to sit on the bench (which he will) and then replicate what he’s doing at West Ham is off their rocker.
He is doing well there because he’s full of confidence and playing every week. Coming back to United to play in a squad role and be put under huge pressure when asked to fill in for the first team will put him right back to square one. @Sandikan makes a good point about the lack of space United get in comparison, too.
Less of the revisionism, folks. Put this down as a great move for all parties and let him go for an acceptable fee.
Yeah it’s nuts. We have an opportunity to add one of the best PL attacking players this season to our squad for nothing and everyone is wondering how much money we can sell him for which we may or may not spend on a new signing who may or may not thrive in the Premier League.
Jesse has always been a decent squad option for us who struggled for form when the whole team was struggling for form then had one genuinely terrible season while dealing with horrendous personal issues. Which he has put behind him and worked incredibly hard to be as fit as possible. The player we’re watching for West Ham is clearly good enough to merit a place in our squad.
agreed in total.
You surely understand that players perform very differently in different team and team stature set ups.
If we started Lingard every week, he wouldn't get the space and role he has at West Ham.
The smart thing to do would be to sell when his profile is so high. We know that he can't perform to the level that a club the size of United needs.
I just don't know if we're that smart.
I just don't know if we're that smart.
He's just benefitting from the fact that teams don't throw 10 players behind the ball when they play against West Ham. If wolves set up like this against us it'd be 9-0
He’s coped fine with being a squad player in the past. What has hasn’t coped well with were life circumstances that had nothing to do with football, then being completely frozen out this season.
Bidding war. Step up step up clubs
Lingard's play is a big reason why Bruno was a need.
He'll fund us Sancho and Haaland at this rate