Chris H
Video Posting God
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2008
- Messages
- 6,579
Sammsky, I apologize for my many errors, and I bow to your obvious wealth of knowledge about the region of South Asia. No, I'm not kidding. As you noted, somewhat sarcastically, I am but an amateur historian when it comes to this part of the world. I admit this.
But although I got many crucial facts absolutely wrong, and made an exaggeration or two... I stick to my central argument. Which is that one cannot look at the unbelievable brutality of 1971 and blame it all on Mountbatten, the British, and their desire to soq dissent amongst the nations of the world, the better to rule them. But I feel your arguments did just that, and take any blame for the events of the last sixty years away from those who have committed crimes against their neighbors. Peaceloving, good-hearted people do not turn into savages in two and a half decades just because someone drew lines on a map - Pakistan should never be allowed to point back to 1947 and say that the injustice of Partition was the cause, and must take the blame for what they did 24 years later. I feel like your attitude toward Partition, and also toward Palestine, takes all responsibility for their actions away from those who have suffered any injustice, and I don't accept that.
But although I got many crucial facts absolutely wrong, and made an exaggeration or two... I stick to my central argument. Which is that one cannot look at the unbelievable brutality of 1971 and blame it all on Mountbatten, the British, and their desire to soq dissent amongst the nations of the world, the better to rule them. But I feel your arguments did just that, and take any blame for the events of the last sixty years away from those who have committed crimes against their neighbors. Peaceloving, good-hearted people do not turn into savages in two and a half decades just because someone drew lines on a map - Pakistan should never be allowed to point back to 1947 and say that the injustice of Partition was the cause, and must take the blame for what they did 24 years later. I feel like your attitude toward Partition, and also toward Palestine, takes all responsibility for their actions away from those who have suffered any injustice, and I don't accept that.