They left out 'pig', 'communist' and 'porn star' from that.
Politics at Westminster | BREAKING: UKIP
- Thread starter Team Brian GB
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
There is a certain element of UKIP being a victim of its own success i think, certainly the demand for candidates seems to be outstripping the party's ability to vet them properly. And Farage could feasibly run as an independent one day if he despair of his rank and file sufficiently.
Last edited:
We have to draw the line somewhere Steve, bacon and porn stars are all well and proper but Bolsheviks?
Good choices, chief. 
It's interesting that the Daily Mail are pulling no punches when it comes to UKIP, given that the party has such support from their readership. You can actually pinpoint the moment when the paper abruptly went from cautiously rooting for UKIP to undermining them daily. It was around the time when it became clear that UKIP had gone from being a mere cheerleader for the conservatives of little-England on the sidleines of mainstream politics to being a serious electoral threat to the Tory Party.
Eyes glazed over the rest of it.
That 32 to 31 is going to translate to a big lead for Labour because of our stupid voting system.
QT a bit more interesting than usual. Chukka trips up Farage and Lucas elegantly stomps on him with her high heels
Tories don't want to put up Shapps, fly weight
I'm not watching. Is that Caroline Lucas? I usually try and catch it, if she's on (my MP). Will iPlayer the thing, later, if so.
Yep, she's great I should vote Green but old habits die hard. Farage was demolished, not least by some guy from the audience
You're in Brighton? I'm just outside unfortunately so can't vote for her, and the Greens don't even bother wasting their deposit here. Really hope she keeps her seat next year.
I'm not sure I've ever heard Grant Shapps say anything that he thought of himself, he's always straight into whatever talking point the party have been pushing of late. You get them in every party of course, but I'm not sure I've seen anyone else so dedicated to the craft.
Yeah, been here a year. Makes a change from living in the West Midlands where I got more BNP candidates than Lib Dems, let alone Greens.
http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/may/08/jeremy-hunt-homeopathy-studies-chief-medical-officer
Jeremy Hunt sent homeopathy studies to chief medical officer
Letter to Tory MP reveals health secretary asked Sally Davies to initiate reviews of already dismissed studies by French firm
Chief medical officer Sally Davies has said publicly she believes homeopathy is 'rubbish'. Photograph: Ben Stansall/AFP/Getty Images
The health secretary, Jeremy Hunt, asked the chief medical officer to commission expert reviews of three homeopathic remedy studies carried out by a commercial French company – in spite of the CMO's publicly expressed belief that homeopathy is "rubbish".
Dame Sally Davies, the CMO, has categorically dismissed homeopathy as a waste of time and money. "I am perpetually surprised that homeopathy is available on the NHS," she told the Commons science and technology committee in January 2013.
Yet Hunt, who expressed support for homeopathy in 2007 before he joined the Department of Health, asked Davies to initiate reviews of three studies carried out by the French company Boiron, which have already been dismissed by scientific critics.
Boiron has run into legal difficulties in the US in recent years. In 2012, it set aside $5m to refund consumers who bought certain homeopathic products. Expert witnesses argued that the "active ingredients" were neither active nor ingredients.
Homeopathic remedies are dilutions of substances to such a high degree that the original ingredient is undetectable.
Hunt's action followed lobbying from the strongly pro-homeopathy Tory MP David Tredinnick. The health secretary's intervention was revealed through a Freedom of Information request by the website BuzzFeed.
In a letter to Tredinnick, Hunt thanked the MP for drawing his attention to the studies and said: "It is important we do not discount different methods of treatment if they prove to be effective and I asked the CMO to have them reviewed. The studies have now been assessed by two senior researchers with expertise in research design and experience of research in complementary therapies."
The letter, drafted for Hunt, showed that the researchers found the studies did not offer evidence of the efficacy of homeopathy. Two of the studies were "well-designed, with robust results" but were essentially descriptive studies, that is, that they did not test one remedy against another or against a placebo, as would happen in a clinical trial.
The third study compared two group of patients with musculoskeletal disorders, such as back strains and sprains. One group was treated by GPs using homeopathy and the other by GPs using conventional means. "Drawing any firm conclusions is difficult because of the relatively low response rate at 12 months and in particular the lack of randomisation, which means that the results may have been produced by differences between patient groups that have not been taken into account," the reviewers had found.
Hunt, however, said he was willing to carry on the discussion. "I am of course happy to put any counterpoints or further studies you may have to the reviewers for further consideration," he told Tredinnick in his letter.
Hunt signed an early day motion welcoming the availability of homeopathy on the NHS in 2007, but a source close to the health secretary said on Thursday: "Jeremy is not a supporter of homeopathy and is not persuaded that there is any scientific evidence that it works."
Jamie Reed, a shadow health minister, said patients and medics would be dismayed but not surprised to learn that Hunt had "wasted time and money" on investigating studies into homeopathy.
He added: "The government's own NHS Choices website states that the evidence for homeopathy is 'scientifically implausible' but this doesn't appear to be enough for the error-prone health secretary. As his policies continue to damage the NHS, I hope he hasn't ordered an investigation into the use of leeches."
Edzard Ernst, emeritus professor at Exeter University and a critic of homeopathy, said there was already evidence in the public domain relating to Boiron's studies. "I have repeatedly commented on the dismal quality and misleading conclusions of Boiron-sponsored research on my blog," he said. "We have to ask why someone in a position like Hunt ignores all these facts and takes such extraordinary action."
The study comparing patients treated by GPs with different methodsfound less medication in the homeopathy group. It was, Ernst said, "a self-fulfilling prophecy, like finding that a lot of people in Macdonalds eat meat".
He said he was amazed that Hunt had offered to refer any further evidence from Tredinnick back to the reviewers. "He is actually offering further assistance; he therefore is much more than a 'conduit'. [That's] quite unbelievable – officially, he had renounced his enthusiasm for homeopathy."
The campaign group Sense About Science said Tredinnick had already raised the studies with them, at a hearing of the science and technology committee in May last year. "He already knows about the limitations of these studies," said the campaigns director, Sile Lane. "It is a disingenuous request. This is single-study campaigning – if the pharmaceutical industry did this, people's reaction would be, rightly, indignant."
Our secretary of state for health everyone. Excellent.
Jeremy Hunt sent homeopathy studies to chief medical officer
Letter to Tory MP reveals health secretary asked Sally Davies to initiate reviews of already dismissed studies by French firm
Chief medical officer Sally Davies has said publicly she believes homeopathy is 'rubbish'. Photograph: Ben Stansall/AFP/Getty Images
The health secretary, Jeremy Hunt, asked the chief medical officer to commission expert reviews of three homeopathic remedy studies carried out by a commercial French company – in spite of the CMO's publicly expressed belief that homeopathy is "rubbish".
Dame Sally Davies, the CMO, has categorically dismissed homeopathy as a waste of time and money. "I am perpetually surprised that homeopathy is available on the NHS," she told the Commons science and technology committee in January 2013.
Yet Hunt, who expressed support for homeopathy in 2007 before he joined the Department of Health, asked Davies to initiate reviews of three studies carried out by the French company Boiron, which have already been dismissed by scientific critics.
Boiron has run into legal difficulties in the US in recent years. In 2012, it set aside $5m to refund consumers who bought certain homeopathic products. Expert witnesses argued that the "active ingredients" were neither active nor ingredients.
Homeopathic remedies are dilutions of substances to such a high degree that the original ingredient is undetectable.
Hunt's action followed lobbying from the strongly pro-homeopathy Tory MP David Tredinnick. The health secretary's intervention was revealed through a Freedom of Information request by the website BuzzFeed.
In a letter to Tredinnick, Hunt thanked the MP for drawing his attention to the studies and said: "It is important we do not discount different methods of treatment if they prove to be effective and I asked the CMO to have them reviewed. The studies have now been assessed by two senior researchers with expertise in research design and experience of research in complementary therapies."
The letter, drafted for Hunt, showed that the researchers found the studies did not offer evidence of the efficacy of homeopathy. Two of the studies were "well-designed, with robust results" but were essentially descriptive studies, that is, that they did not test one remedy against another or against a placebo, as would happen in a clinical trial.
The third study compared two group of patients with musculoskeletal disorders, such as back strains and sprains. One group was treated by GPs using homeopathy and the other by GPs using conventional means. "Drawing any firm conclusions is difficult because of the relatively low response rate at 12 months and in particular the lack of randomisation, which means that the results may have been produced by differences between patient groups that have not been taken into account," the reviewers had found.
Hunt, however, said he was willing to carry on the discussion. "I am of course happy to put any counterpoints or further studies you may have to the reviewers for further consideration," he told Tredinnick in his letter.
Hunt signed an early day motion welcoming the availability of homeopathy on the NHS in 2007, but a source close to the health secretary said on Thursday: "Jeremy is not a supporter of homeopathy and is not persuaded that there is any scientific evidence that it works."
Jamie Reed, a shadow health minister, said patients and medics would be dismayed but not surprised to learn that Hunt had "wasted time and money" on investigating studies into homeopathy.
He added: "The government's own NHS Choices website states that the evidence for homeopathy is 'scientifically implausible' but this doesn't appear to be enough for the error-prone health secretary. As his policies continue to damage the NHS, I hope he hasn't ordered an investigation into the use of leeches."
Edzard Ernst, emeritus professor at Exeter University and a critic of homeopathy, said there was already evidence in the public domain relating to Boiron's studies. "I have repeatedly commented on the dismal quality and misleading conclusions of Boiron-sponsored research on my blog," he said. "We have to ask why someone in a position like Hunt ignores all these facts and takes such extraordinary action."
The study comparing patients treated by GPs with different methodsfound less medication in the homeopathy group. It was, Ernst said, "a self-fulfilling prophecy, like finding that a lot of people in Macdonalds eat meat".
He said he was amazed that Hunt had offered to refer any further evidence from Tredinnick back to the reviewers. "He is actually offering further assistance; he therefore is much more than a 'conduit'. [That's] quite unbelievable – officially, he had renounced his enthusiasm for homeopathy."
The campaign group Sense About Science said Tredinnick had already raised the studies with them, at a hearing of the science and technology committee in May last year. "He already knows about the limitations of these studies," said the campaigns director, Sile Lane. "It is a disingenuous request. This is single-study campaigning – if the pharmaceutical industry did this, people's reaction would be, rightly, indignant."
Our secretary of state for health everyone. Excellent.
Nigel Farage getting absolutely owned, quite a bit of a car crashed really
When the interviewer who does a fantastic job asks him why he is in effect a bit of a racist, Farage's reaction to it was "why don't you come and meet the black and ethnic members of UKIP". Completely shows him up
Last edited:
"I'm just an ordinary person, I don't understand how these financial institutions work"
Great quote there!And they've still got a pretty great chance of being the top party at next week's election. Amazing.
O'Brien gave him a good kicking, even better then the more middle-class one he got on QT.
The liberal agenda is in full flow against Farage now, the main parties gunning for him as well.
Farage got carved up, but as much as he did - I still found the host just as irritating. Not as if he's trying to run the country though in fairness.
Farage got owned.
Will still perform well in Euro Elections
Will still perform well in Euro Elections
Farage really did get owned, he tried as best to cover up his clear xenophobia
I haven't been keeping up with politics lately, 'cuz well none of the party leaders particularly appeal to me.
Can someone give me a run down on what UKIP is proposing?
I haven't been keeping up with politics lately, 'cuz well none of the party leaders particularly appeal to me.
Can someone give me a run down on what UKIP is proposing?
Been watching HIGNFY, on iPlayer. I think I might actually like Jacob Rees-Mogg.
I wouldn't dream of ever voting for the guy but he has an unashamed "this is what I believe and if you want to know why I'll tell you" feel about him. On a personal level, I find that quite appealing. I guess as it's such a change from Ed Milliband, who is meant to vaguely represent my views but is happy to immigrant bash if it suits. Or Boris Johnson who largely sees the world similarly to Rees-Mogg but hides behind the floppy haired 'lovable' rascal act.
It's quite an uncomfortable feeling, liking him. If anyone has some evidence to cure me of it, that isn't based purely on ideological differences (as that doesn't seem to be working), that would be helpful.
I wouldn't dream of ever voting for the guy but he has an unashamed "this is what I believe and if you want to know why I'll tell you" feel about him. On a personal level, I find that quite appealing. I guess as it's such a change from Ed Milliband, who is meant to vaguely represent my views but is happy to immigrant bash if it suits. Or Boris Johnson who largely sees the world similarly to Rees-Mogg but hides behind the floppy haired 'lovable' rascal act.
It's quite an uncomfortable feeling, liking him. If anyone has some evidence to cure me of it, that isn't based purely on ideological differences (as that doesn't seem to be working), that would be helpful.
Even Stephen Fry likes him, and he's no Tory either. I don't like him that much, myself though.
So have we all voted?
I went for a Conservative Council and also in Europe.
I went for a Conservative Council and also in Europe.
Yes, and i can report that the European election ballot paper is about three pages of A4 long. If such is any indication of the required deposit we could probably put forward the RedCafe party next time.
Of my four votes the majority went to the Greens.
Of my four votes the majority went to the Greens.
Love the Green party. It's such a shame(but no surprise) that UKIP got all sudden attention and the fact some people claimed to have used them as a form of protest vote(I find hard to believe). If your getting to have a protest vote then the very least you should do is not give your vote to a absolute cnut of a man.
I hope you put your cross next to the animal welfare party.
The list was memorable for the number of parties one wouldn't choose to vote for, from the mainstream types to the "what the hell are they doing there?" variety. Indeed i couldn't say that there are any for whom i would feel entirely comfortable in backing.
Voted UKIP.
Don't tell me, you were taking a stand against the establishment (by voting for a public school educated ex stock-broker)?
No, he's voting for a clunt.
Me too. Now fire away with calling me a racist or whatever.
UKIP are a rubbish party, they're run by a bunch of morons and idiots and what they promise is offered by virtually every other party on a far more constructive and broad platform.
I'm not going to call people that vote for them racist, but I struggle to think how anyone thats bothered to inform themself could come to the conclusion that they're actually a sensible choice in this election. They're an odious party, and it strikes of ignorance or apathy that people vote for them.
Idiot probably covers it.
I want the UK out of the European Union, I'm not sure where else I get that.
Why though, its more beneficial for the economy and politically to be in there than out.
It's simply impractical as support for staying indicates since it ranges from the CBI to the TUC.
Certainly not voting for a bunch of jobsworth knobheads to go and sit and do nothing in Brussels.
For all their rhetoric, UKIP MEPs no matter how many they get, can't do that for you.
Ironically, the one party that can the Tories after the next election, are the one party that UKIP are taking the most votes from.