I wouldn't take any of them, honestly. De Gea because he doesn't fit Pep's system, Shaw because he's coming back from the leg-break, and Pogba because as good as he is, I feel a rush of gratitude that I'm not a United fan every time I see him do that awful dabbing thing.
Everywhere else we have better players. Ibrahimovic is maybe on par with Aguero but only for a year longer at best. Blind better than Otamendi or Stones? Pull the other one. Valencia is nothing too special. Nobody's heard of Herrera. Fellaini is a dickhead, and United may be fine with that but City have a bit more class. Rooney is inconsistent at the best of times, Mkhitaryan needs time to 'get used to the Premier League' (bullshit- Nolito managed it just fine), Martial goes missing more often than not. I still laugh out loud when someone suggests that Rashford is better than Iheanacho.
More to the point, we have much more quality outside of our starting XI than they do outside their. Lingard is far too old to be considered promising anymore and now he's just average. They didn't want Juanazaj. Smalling seems to have crumbled. Mata is famously not liked by Mourinho. Schweinsteigger and Schneiderlin are both underused.
A