SAF: Mourinho has done a great job

top1whoisman

Meet the press(conference)
Scout
Joined
May 18, 2016
Messages
21,055
Location
Helsinki
Manchester United are making progress under Jose Mourinho and are "unlucky" not to be challenging Chelsea, says their former boss Sir Alex Ferguson.

Ferguson, 75, stepped down in 2013 but retains close ties to Old Trafford and attends most games.

"I think he has done a great job," said the Scot in an exclusive interview with BBC Sport.

Ferguson also explained why he thinks Wayne Rooney's United goalscoring record will never be broken.


'Without those draws, they'd be challenging Chelsea’

Jose Mourinho became Manchester United's third manager since Ferguson retired when he replaced Louis van Gaal in May.

Although he won his opening three games in charge, Mourinho's team collected just six points from their next seven Premier League matches.

They have been sixth after every round of matches since the end of October and stayed in that position after the 1-1 draw at Stoke on 21 January, when Rooney scored an injury-time equaliser to become United's record goalscorer, with 250.

Nevertheless, Ferguson can see signs of progress under the Portuguese.

"You can see he has got to grips with the club," he said.

"The team is playing really well and he has been very unlucky. He has had six 1-1 draws and in every game he has battered the opposition.

"If they hadn't had all these draws, they would be there challenging Chelsea. That is the unfortunate part but he is going to have to live with that."


'The team is mirroring its manager’

Mourinho has been sent to the stands twice this season, against Burnley and West Ham, as his side struggled to overcome supposedly inferior opposition at Old Trafford.

The former Chelsea and Real Madrid manager seems far more relaxed now though.

United go to Hull on Thursday for the second leg of their EFL Cup semi-final unbeaten in 17 games. That run encompassed nine successive wins, including a 2-0 triumph in the first leg at Old Trafford, their longest-winning sequence since Ferguson called time on his illustrious career.

Ferguson said: "I was a little bit different from Jose in the respect that I wanted to build the football club and wanted young players to be part of that.

"Nonetheless, the first team weren't doing great and you have to find solutions to correct that. I think Jose is finding solutions now. There was a period earlier in the season when he wasn't getting the decisions and his emotions boiled over. You see him now - he is calm and in control.

"That is the obvious observation I am making of the team now. The team is mirroring its manager.

"On Saturday at Stoke, they played to the last kick of the ball. They never gave in and got their rewards to take something from the game with that great Rooney goal.

"And did you see what he did? Ran to the halfway line. No celebration. Pointed to the ball as if to say 'get it, we are going to win this'. That is exactly the spirit Jose has created."


Goal record 'a very big target to hit’

Sir Bobby Charlton's club record of 249 Manchester United goals had stood for 44 years until Rooney went past it at the Britannia Stadium.

Charlton amassed his tally in 758 appearances for the club. Rooney, 31, has gone one better in 546 games since moving from Everton for £27m as an 18-year-old in 2014.

With the chance to score even more this season and a contract that runs to 2018 if the Liverpool-born player remains at Old Trafford until its conclusion, Rooney has set a record that is unlikely ever to be beaten, according to Ferguson.

"In the present-day game, it is difficult to see any club having players who can stay with them for 10 years.

"Jose has mentioned Marcus Rashford and there is an opportunity for that young lad, if he stays at United, and develops his potential the way that Wayne has. But it is a very big target to hit.

"Bobby Charlton's record was quite substantial. I couldn't think anybody would beat that. It is an achievement par excellence.”

//

"And did you see what he did? Ran to the halfway line. No celebration. Pointed to the ball as if to say 'get it, we are going to win this'. That is exactly the spirit Jose has created."

This is what struck me with Rooney’s celebrations. It would’ve been quite natural for him to react in an emotional way, but that lasted 0.1 seconds after which the whole team sprinted towards the halfway line. Compare that to Giroud’s stupid celebrations or Firmino when they equalised 2-2 at home vs Swansea.

http://www.bbc.com/sport/football/38735437
 
Last edited:
Re: The celebrations…

Giroud



Firmino



Rooney



Very good post showing the difference. Pogba didn't even celebrate, went to get the ball straight.

While I don't think we have been good enough to get into top 4, if we do it is this attitude that gets us in there. SAF is spot on about what Jose has done with regards to that.
 
a255f63a-410c-4cc5-81fe-2b51c8633945
CAR3egW.png
 
Very good post showing the difference. Pogba didn't even celebrate, went to get the ball straight.

While I don't think we have been good enough to get into top 4, if we do it is this attitude that gets us in there. SAF is spot on about what Jose has done with regards to that.

Our finishing mainly has cost us, otherwise we’ve played well since the start of December and haven’t lost a game since Nov 3rd. It is true, that this (current position) is not enough, but I love how we reacted to the goal on Saturday, even though there was only what, less than a minute to go. Not saying Firmino’s celebration was in any way decisive, I just got a bit amazed watching it live, the first thing after such shitty 69 minutes at home against the worst team in the league should be scoring the winner. Feck it, I’m derailing my own thread, the celebrations just symboled the nature of those 3 players, not the 3 clubs in question.
 
Great pick out that.
 
He's probably been a 7/10 thus far.

Positives:

  • Our general injury record has improved
  • Jones and Rojo are far more reliable now than a year ago
  • His ability to attract high profile signings
  • Reducing Rooney to a squad role
Negatives:

  • A complete disregard for youth (Tuanzebe and Fosu-Mensah have barely been involved in the cups)
  • The man management of Martial is bizarre
  • We don't score enough goals
 
You'd have to be mad to not see the progress made in the last 12 months.

Exactly. Of course SAF is going to use superlatives, but I also think that he can, as he has pointed out in the interview, see behind all those frustrating draws.
 
This does indeed sound like a man who really did not want Mourinho for the job and tried to keep him away from it at any cost.
 
6th place after spending £150m is a great job?


That's the negative way of looking at it :lol:

But compare the style of football and how we've been dominating pretty much every game, with Moyes' 7th and looking absolute sh!te, and you see the truth.
 
6th place after spending £150m is a great job?
this is such a narrow view focusing on money

I think after Van Gaal he had to take a number of steps back, changing a mindset in the players that had been drummed into them over 2 years.....I think there's been very good progress.

  • 4 top signings
  • made us attractive to players
  • hard to beat and a great run
  • better going forward and creating many more opportunities
  • despite all those draws we've the same amount of points as this time last year in 4 less games
  • improved the fitness record
  • handled difficult political decisions (had to give Rooney enough rope to hang himself before dropping him)
there have been issues (strange subs at times, rumours of management style and handling of players) but all in all you have to feel much more positive.

spending £150 million is no guarantee of success.....he's already shed 50/55 million of wastage in Memphis and Schneiderlein and I think we could see players like Rooney, Schweinsteiger, Young and Darmian eased out and replaced. Our transfer business seems so much more professional, less desperate/random and if we continue to reinvest in the squad we will compete for the league next year.
 
He's probably been a 7/10 thus far.

Positives:

  • Our general injury record has improved
  • Jones and Rojo are far more reliable now than a year ago
  • His ability to attract high profile signings
  • Reducing Rooney to a squad role
Negatives:

  • A complete disregard for youth (Tuanzebe and Fosu-Mensah have barely been involved in the cups)
  • The man management of Martial is bizarre
  • We don't score enough goals
And Shaw.
 
zlMMkSu.png
iayLFTj.png

Aside from playing terms, where the improvement is so obvious that it doesn't merit conversation, there has been an improvement in every other area relative to last season. The only difference is that the top six is performing as expected this season.

Our form this season would probably constitute title winning form last season. Difference being that there was no Chelsea last season, and the top four to six were wildly inconsistent.
 
He's probably been a 7/10 thus far.

Positives:

  • Our general injury record has improved
  • Jones and Rojo are far more reliable now than a year ago
  • His ability to attract high profile signings
  • Reducing Rooney to a squad role
Negatives:

  • A complete disregard for youth (Tuanzebe and Fosu-Mensah have barely been involved in the cups)
  • The man management of Martial is bizarre
  • We don't score enough goals
3rd negative point isn't a valid one. The team creates a bunch of chances. Can't fault a manager for players messing up chances just like you can't fault a manager for fluke goals conceded or a single player messing it up on his own.
 
He's probably been a 7/10 thus far.

Positives:

  • Our general injury record has improved
  • Jones and Rojo are far more reliable now than a year ago
  • His ability to attract high profile signings
  • Reducing Rooney to a squad role
Negatives:

  • A complete disregard for youth (Tuanzebe and Fosu-Mensah have barely been involved in the cups)
  • The man management of Martial is bizarre
  • We don't score enough goals
I don't agree with your criticism of using youth. He's used the cups as an opportunity to play his starting XI into form, and by and large it's worked. Getting back to winning ways is our priority, not blooding youngsters. That'll come once we've established ourselves as a force in the league again.
 
He is right about the draws. It is so frustrating to think how we have been so close to winning most of those games and could easily be 10 points better off. While Arsenal are scoring jammy late goals for fun this season and would probably be mid table without them.

I guess we used to do it every year under Fergie though so I can't really complain.
 
"since moving from Everton for £27m as an 18-year-old in 2014."

So Rooney is only 21? Fek rashford, play this Rooney kid.
 
When we played City at OT and Liverpool at Anfield I was dreading it. Don't dread any opposition now, I relish it, even though I'm not necessarily confident of a win. That's the change for me.
 
Last edited:
Going from a Reliant Robin to an Audi TT is a great progress indeed but it's hardly F1 material given the money he has spent. What else is Fergie meant to say? He wanted us to stand behind Moyes as we did with him too.

It's progress but it will not be good enough if we don't finish in the top 4 at least.
 
3rd negative point isn't a valid one. The team creates a bunch of chances. Can't fault a manager for players messing up chances just like you can't fault a manager for fluke goals conceded or a single player messing it up on his own.

Fellaini messed up vs Everton and that was Mourinho's fault