You're getting confused between defensive and attacking handballs, which are judged differently.
In this case any contact with the hand, even accidental, sees the goal disallowed.
Premier League Gameweek 26
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
You're getting confused between defensive and attacking handballs, which are judged differently.
In this case any contact with the hand, even accidental, sees the goal disallowed.
I literally quoted the correct laws to you by drawing attention to @JakeC 's reply and you went out of your way to find the wrong ones.
Again:
If an attacking player accidentally touches the ball with their hand or arm and then scores a goal, or the ball goes to another attacking player and they immediately score, this is a handball offence.
I've made it helpfully bold, too.
It's a dumb as feck rule, and I hate that it is one, but it is and there's absolutely nothing the referee can do there but rule the goal out. Anything else is, unfortunately, the wrong decision.
Yeah, IFAB's decision to become interventionist has been very poorly thought though and when the inevitable consequences of their own stupid changes have been seen, they've been scrambling to clean up the mess. The rationale for this change ('football expects that a goal will never be scored with a hand' or words to that effect) seems shaky to me and we've seen it has caused more problems than its solved.
I think that goal should count, too, but unfortunately as things stand the referee has made a correct (and relatively easy) decision.
I hate watching football matches hoping for a draw, but here we are again Liverpool/Chelsea and needing a draw.
What is it about that side of that goal at Craven Cottage that messes with the eyes? I was convinced that was in, same as when Bailly nearly turned into his own net when we played Fulham.
Fulham playing better football than anything we've mustered the past few games
Spurs have been shocking. Nothing has changed with them
Mitrovic is only on the pitch, and he's the one moving the least. Shocking.
Imagine standing on the far post on a long throw.
Spurs tactic of scoring early then playing for a 1-0 is really quite something to behold
Get the feck in. Absolute garbage tonight and Gomes did his best to lose us the game but that's another 3 points on the board. Excellent.
It beats setting your team up for 0-0s though.
Fulham played really well. We were shit in second half but great result
Crazy how much debate and outrage there is from fans when it comes to clear cut rules.
Probably scarier how little actual players know of the rules from time to time, but people spend a lot of time getting wound up over the rules vs actual bad decisions
Probably scarier how little actual players know of the rules from time to time, but people spend a lot of time getting wound up over the rules vs actual bad decisions
I do remember some plain stupid decisions last season, like the Moura one when he was falling. Thought they made it more lenient but apparently not. Absolutely awful decision, albeit not the refs fault.
This is possibly the stupidest rule in football.
We fecking need a draw here.
How did Bale do?
I think the change you're remembering is they tightened up the amount of time allowed between an accidental touch and the goal. In this instance, it was the touch immediately before it fell to Maja so, unfortunately, it's well within the remits of the law. I really wish they'd just scrap it entirely.
I can’t say that either of Everton or Spurs concern me. They both played badly for lack of a better word and survived through correct by the law but lucky VAR decisions (Everton less so as Diagne was a yard off). We’re obviously awful at the moment so if both grind out results, they’ll overtake us, but neither look great themselves.
Yeah you’re correct. Absolutely ridiculous law. Great goal by a really good striker ruled out for no good reason. Spurs can claim they should have had a pen, but that Maja call was 10x worse.
Who would have thought in September that come the 27th game of the season a Chelsea v Liverpool game would be between 6th and 7th in the table and both 20+ points away from 1st?
Fulham look the most competent of any of the teams scrapping down there. Usually when you watch a relegation candidate there’s more than the odd clogger, but they all look really good on the ball and seem unlucky to drop points whenever I see them.
We are now only 3 points and 1 win away from our total from last season with 12 games left. Huge improvement.
Ashley Cole talks like he’s just done 3 fat lines of ketamine.
Christensen in these type of games scares me.
Looking at the table and who teams around us are playing, last night was just another in an annoyingly long list of feck ups this year. A win would have been the sort of breathing space we needed, just infuriating.
Are you confident you will finish above that other team?
Bloody hell, Allison’s first game back and just before it kicks off he has to partake in a minutes applause for Ian St John. That’s got to be tough mentally when he’s trying to keep a clear head and focus on the game.
Never tried it, is it good?
Easy win for Liverpool this. 3-0
Dull 0-0.
I didn't think it was possible to talk on that stuff.
First time I had it was the worst night of my life. Subsequent escapades with it were an absolute riot
Some hopeless free kick attempts from miles out.
Will keep it in mind should the need to storm some shit arise.First time I had it was the worst night of my life. Subsequent escapades with it were an absolute riot
It's definitely quite hard not to quite cruelly think "this guy is thick as sh!te".
They're unfortunately the Northern Tottenham, so they'll probably give themselves a chance then lose 2 in a row to pony.
Mane finally stats on his feet. He could have went down and got a penalty there.
No, but I am happy with competing for the European spots considering where we have been in prior seasons. A EL spot would be an excellent season for us.
Not the first time, he stayed on his feet for a possible pen in the Sheffield or Everton game I think. Still get called a diver though.