Because we're stuck with the nearly $200 million worth of shite he brought upon us?
Solskjaer's legacy and his future
- Thread starter Skills
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
Because we're stuck with the nearly $200 million worth of shite he brought upon us?
It’s illogical to pull Ole into the conversation for recent failures. Yes he was bad and rightly sacked months ago but Ralf had many players sent on loan and some really good backup options to use but he didn’t was his problem not Ole’s.
For example, Dalot and Matic could’ve done a decent performance but not started.
For example, Dalot and Matic could’ve done a decent performance but not started.
Ole's major targets were Maguire, Rice, Haaland, Bellingham. The club instead wasted 50m on Diallo and Pellistri. Had they not signed DVB and just paid for one of these lads (Belligham should have been simple) and things are a lot different for Ole and this club.
Every Maguire disasterclass, like the one today, is going to remind us that Olé spend 80M on him and made him captain.
Two of the worst managerial decisions in the club’s recent history.
Two of the worst managerial decisions in the club’s recent history.
Pundits never gave ole stick. Even now rangnick has received more stick from the pundits in a dozen games than ole did in 3 seasons.
And yes the players were never coached. Even ole himself said he didn't coach the players and neither did the assistant manager, which means carrick was coaching the players while learning on the job.
Mate, fecking Watford dicked us 4-1 in Solskjaer’s last game in charge, not the current champions and one of the finest teams in the world.
The one real legacy remaining is that he still has people defending him which is beyond hilarious.
VDB has said clearly in an interview Ole pleaded him to join. Convinced him. Pellistri and Diallo are 100% ole signings.
Yes Ole had those as "major" targets because they are bang obvious most valued players of the time. Unfortunately this is not football manger and we are not galacticos. We don't have the luxury to spunk nearly $200 on targets like Maguire, Bruno and AWB only for them to turn out to be just okay or a bad fit.
Ole was a complete disaster. He didn't have a single bargain signing that he could judge on his own. Even likes of Mourinho had Liindelof and Dalot at least as shrewd signings. Oh, Ole had Igahlo on 300k p/w loan as a shrewd signing
Everyone in our squad was supposedly shite because they had no coaching. Plenty of instances of “if Klopp or Pep had X player then it would be different ..” and “if there was a system then the players would be better..”
Who spent £450m over six transfer windows and ended up with these players then?
Manchester United?
The foundations weren’t there that’s the problem, Ole was a short term manager, he made a huge mess but people fell for all the cliches and finishing second in a poor league. We were miles behind City when Ole joined, we’re miles behind them now, all Ole did was waste loads of time and money.
Klop and pep did not turn the players they inherited into world beaters. They gutted the team and brought in new players.
Even they know turd cannot be polished. Our players are shit.
Ah okay so the manager doesn't decide which players to sign. Got it.
Yes, De Gea wearing the captains armband today would have made so much difference.
Nice intentional misunderstanding of the point that's being made.
What's the alternative understanding? Who is the transformative captain choice he should have made instead?
Sad to say it, but this is true.
Love Ole as an ex player. But as a manager he set us back years.
Woodward allowing a temporary managerial appointment to stay for 3 years and then not having a replacement ready so signing another interim manager is also comical. The blame lies with the Glazers and their puppet, Woodward. I fear for the culture and structure in our senior management positions.
Cultural reboot? He's left us with the most spineless, non-Manchester United squad I can remember. And he's an ex player that knows what's required here! The guy is a clown of a manager.
6 of the team werent Ole signings.
The implication from what I can tell is that Maguire's status as record defensive signing and club captain makes him nigh on undroppable for any manager as long as Maguire is at the club, despite poor performances, which has reportedly been questioned internally by the players. An interim manager's hardly going to come in during the middle of the season and change the captain. I do agree with the point you're making about us having no proper captain material in the squad though. If it were me, I'd give it to de Gea or Bruno and not necessarily because they have any inherent leadership qualities that are obvious even if I think Bruno does lead by example and puts a lot of effort in, but because they are likely to be mainstays in the starting XI over the next year or two.
I apologise if I came off as overly confrontational
It's going to take years to fix the mess of a squad that Ole left behind. The next manager is going to have to put out fires everywhere, from defence, to midfield, to the attack.
Damn, some people still defend that fraud. Person who wasted 3 years, over 400 mil euros and had zero dignity. Man, who is so called United legend and "loves the club", rather waited for sack instead resigning when it was obvious that things are broken beyond repair.
Fixed that for you
is it people defending ole bumping this thread every time ralf gets embarrassed haha
We overpaid but this place has become so obsessed with blaming everything on him its ridiculous. Paying £40m for Varane (probably £300k a week) and him barely being available is just as big a waste of money.
He can easily be dropped if anyone else was pulling up trees with their performances. As it is the defence is so exposed by a lack of midfield it doesn't matter who we play there they look poor.
I don't agree on Bruno, it's not captain material for me the amount of moaning and histrionics he produces during games. His performances are just as poor as anyone else, masked by the odd goal.
I stopped reading at your username.
I don't even blame Ole. The fact that we centred a multi-year rebuild around him is a symptom of the problem rather than the cause.
There’s plenty of information about a cross-functional transfer committee in place at the club. There’s no information which states that Ole solely dictates who we sign and for how much. But yeah, I appreciate this doesn’t fit with what you tell yourself.
People just simply have really short memories and talked so much shit about Ole. The squad Ole left is not a mess if CR7 was not added. Ralf is simply not good at all for short term fix. He probably will do a lot better for long term. But, he won’t be the one in the summer apparently.
Nice legacy he left us with. An 80 million CB that can't control a football and seems to find himself in the wrong position in crucial moments every time. A 50 million right back that is not a footballer. A duo of CFs of a combined age of more than 70. No CM able to pass a football apart from Pogba who will leave.
heres a thought experiment - if the squad is so terrible (oles fault) should we bring him back as he obviously did an incredible job with a squad that isn't top 4 worthy? bring him back but give him no say over transfers (as he build such a terrible squad). with better recruitment he should logically do better and might win the league or at least go one step further and win some trophies
I think It's pretty obvious that Maguire and Wan Bissaka were Solskjaer (and Phelan) signings and didn't have much to do with the scouting/recruitment department. Mourinho wanted Maguire the summer prior but scouting/recruitment reported back that he wasn't worth the asking price so we didn't sign him initially. His and Wan Bissaka's last game vs utd as opposition were both eye catching games (Maguire particularly at the end of the game looking dangerous in the air chasing an equaliser) which seemed to heavily influence Solskjaer's choice, along with Phelan's praise after being his captain for Hull City. The scouting/recruitment department signings came the summer after with Van de Beek, Amad and Pellestri, who Solskjaer froze out completely because he didn't get who he wanted (Sancho or Grealish).
Not a mess, really?! We have a gk who is not suited to a modern system. At cb we have 80 million flop Maguire and Varane who can't stay fit, both on huge wages. More problems at full back with Shaw who is notoriously inconsistent and AWB who's another big flop. The midfield of McFred is not even top 10 prem quality, mid table clubs have better midfielders than them. We have nothing in the 9 position with Cavani leaving and Ronaldo finished. RW position also remains unfixed. But sure, it's not a mess
He bought Maguire, AWB and they have failed. He bought Bruno who was very good in the first season. He bought dvb and never played him.
In the overall outlook he was nothing but a huge failure as he won nothing but spent a lot of money.
In the overall outlook he was nothing but a huge failure as he won nothing but spent a lot of money.
Ole has repeatedly claimed to have the final say on who comes and goes. In that final say I'd argue that it's relevant to judge how much of the transfer budget will remain after signing player X.
We all knew what Maguire and AWB would cost before the transfers were completed, for example. So if I were the manager, with a self-proclaimed final say on comings and goings, and I wanted to overhaul the squad, I might not have gone for the most expensive centre half and the most expensive RB that we could've gone for if I wanted to sign five or six players in a transfer window.
Whys it weird? Do you think the club has been set up nicely for the next manager after 3 years and 400m+ spent? Legacy is far from, "well he did get us 2 top 4 finishes." bullshit argument.
because we have a good enough squad to be beating the worst teams in the league. the only reason the bump today was so funny is because of oles incredible record away to city. this is one of ralfs first actually difficult games, up until now we have been performing poorly during an extremely easy league run, and the response each time was to come in here and say ole didn't leave ralf the players to win these games...
Ole didn’t negotiate the cost of players and in all likelihood, wasn’t involved in budgeting either. It’s debatable how influential he was in the transfer committee at all, considering what appears to be a rather complicated setup with the likes of Woodward at the helm.