Manchester City v Manchester United

Giggs has been unbelievably shocking. He keeps trying stupid stupid flicks which never go to any of our players and he also missed a sitter.

Need to get Nani on. This game seems quite similar to last weekend. Have a lot of the ball and a couple of good chances but can't take them.

Valencia has been great.
 
Very good performance. We should have been 2-0
Giggs has been our poorest player
 
If Berbatov performed like Rooney did in the first half he would be crucified by now. Otherwise good performance by United.
 
VDS - Good
Neville - Ok
Evans - Ok
Vidic - Immense
Evra - God

Gibson - Poor
Scholes - Ok
Fletcher - Poor

Valencia - Ok
Rooney - Ok
Giggs - Very, Very poor.
 
Commentators are doing my head in. From the sound of it you'd think United have barely touched the ball and City are walking all over us. I must be watching a different game. We've had a few opportunities, they've had one.

Should have taken our chances. Could come back to bite us. Giggs' passes found more blue shirts than red. Hopefully we get a typical 2nd half performance from him. Rooney should have done better with his chance. At least test Given. When we get it out wide to Valencia, he's causing problems for their defense.
 
Really good half there I thought. a couple of really good chances and we should be in the lead at half time. The back four have done a good job of keeping them out and the midfield is playing some nice stuff. If we can keep this up then the 3 points should be in the bag.
 
Gibson and Giggs competing for who can throw the ball away the most.
 
This is classic Giggs. Watch how he creates a goal in the 2nd half.
 
Proud of that first half performance, couldn't have asked for much more in terms of commitment and organisation. We've had the better chances and City have barely threatened at all; what a center back Johnny Evans is, can you imagine how good he's going to be when he's 27/28?
 
Nani on for Gibson, move Giggs to the middle. If it's still not working around the '70 mark, toss Berbs on for Giggs.

Not su re what game you have been watching but Giggs has been playing largely in the middle.
 
Fact is, for all the faults, we were the better team in that half. Should at least by a goal up.

Unfortunately, the likes of Giggs and Gibson have been rubbish, and you have to wonder if they should've been on from the start ahead of the likes of Nani and Park.
 
Haven't had much success on the wings so far. Hopefully Nani comes on to add more invention in these areas. He's also been our best winger in the big matches this season so the sooner he gets on the better.
 
Frustrating half, Rooney's not himself, losing the ball and doesn't seem sharp enough at the moment.

Giggs has been poor, needs to stop trying fancy pants flicks all the time because it isn't working, keep it simple please. I'd give him 15 mins and if he's not improved bring Nani on for him.

We've been passing it around ok at time but in non threatening positions of the park. Definitely the better team so far though, fairly confident we'll find a goal or two in the second for the three points.
 
Good game from Fletcher, Vidic, Evra, Valencia and partly Scholes so far. Also Evans has done a good job I think.
Gibson should shield the ball better, he is caught in possession way too often and Giggs, please stop these flicks.
 
Wonder how fit Rooney is. Or is he just having a bad game?
 
Evans and Vidic have been good
 
Bloody hell, chance after chance down the shitter - really epitomises our season to be fair.

Giggs has drove me mad thus far by constantly giving the ball away. Should have done miles better with his chance aswell. No need for using the outside of the left boot for that what so ever.

Facing the sun 2nd half.

Come on lads, step it up.
 
Gibson and Giggs competing for who can throw the ball away the most.
This.

Apart from that, it has been an encouraging performance - Rooney should've buried that chance, to be fair.

Scholes and Valencia top performers so far.
 
If Berbatov performed like Rooney did in the first half he would be crucified by now. Otherwise good performance by United.

Eh, read the thread, Giggs is getting lambasted, and rightly so.