Xander45
Know-It-All Champion May 2009
Good news that, but i hope this isn't a precursor to Welbeck leaving permanently though as i really rate him.
Bruce will do as told by Sir Alex.
Well my initial hunch (loan move to Sunderland only makes sense if Jones or Campbell is moving on) may prove correct, reports coming out of Sunderland that Stoke are in talks to buy Kenwyne Jones, if he went that'd make a lot more sense for Welbeck as he'd then be one of 3 competing for 2 places.
Local journalists are suggesting Sunderland would reinvest the money from Jones on N'Zogbia.
I think if they sell Jones they will keep Waghorn.. So make that 4 competing for 2 places plus he is versatile so will be in with a shout for the Wing slots incase Sunderland decide to play a 451/433.. Possibly even from the wings in a 442?
Probably true, but Danny would probably (tricky I know) be 2nd or 3rd choice instead of 4th. Problem with wide position is if Sunderland did move for N'Zogbia he'd presumably play left wing
Not that Tricky.. Welbeck is surely more proven for United and on a higher level than Waghorn.. Although I am not so sure if he will be above Campbell.. I know he has the potential to be better but Campbell is a hard worker and that makes him more of a safe bet..
Sorry, meant tricky to predict things - Sunderland could sign another striker, could play a 4-5-1, who knows. Also, while I think Welbeck is a more talented player than Campbell, it's obviously in Sunderland's interest to develop Campbell, less so in the case of Welbeck.
Chirag said:What you guys don't seem to get is that a player (who is on loan at another club) may be potentially better than all the other strikers at a club (E.G Rossi at Newcastle) but that doesn't mean the club who he has gone on loan to have to take the risk of developing him and giving him game time that he needs to succeed.. They are merely bringing in a player as back-up or to make up the numbers or to offer different options off the bench (and hence saving millions rather than bringing in someone and paying a transfer fee+wages for atleast 3-4 years) Do you guys really think Rossi would have played so little at Newcastle if he has been their player outright?
Its something to think about.. You guys say things like if Diouf can't get a game over the like of Jason Roberts we are fecked cause he is shit.. But the matter of fact is that Rossi could not get a game over Antoine Sibierski.. One is a young prospect for the full Italian squad, the other has never even been considered for the France squad be it the u21's or the u17's..
That will be worth a watch if Welbeck is playing.
Sunderland have gotten a few loan players in the last day - Mensah again and Onuha from City.
How many players are you allowed to take on loan?
Two from English clubs and two from abroad, if I remember correctly.