Yeah, I'm not sure he's 100% convinced by Hererra for whatever reason. IMO it's between him and Mata to play behind Rooney and wouldn't be a huge shock if Mata gets the nod. Horses for courses, though. In tough away games Van Gaal might prefer a number 10 who is fond of a tackle.
21
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 41
- Goals
- 5
- Assists
- 6
- Yellow cards
- 9
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
- Status
Yeah, I'm not sure he's 100% convinced by Hererra for whatever reason. IMO it's between him and Mata to play behind Rooney and wouldn't be a huge shock if Mata gets the nod. Horses for courses, though. In tough away games Van Gaal might prefer a number 10 who is fond of a tackle.
You mean where he was dropped for large portions of the season?
Not the last bit he wasn't. He will get plenty of time no matter what. We are United, there isn't a cat in hell chance there won't be injuries. Very likely our midfield will be last season defence. I think LvG can now tailor his side depending on the opposition.
I'd assume that would be Rooney, if we get a top striker in.
You would? Rooney's hasn't shown any defensively abilities at all last season, and he spent half of it in CM.
I think Wayne will have to be on top of his game this season. I know LvG says his captain always plays, way to get round that would be change your captain.
We know what happened against West Ham when Wayne tries to stop the opposition attacking.
I'd disagree with the former, and the latter has only served to prove that he'll start pretty much every game. If we bring in another top striker I reckon we'll see Rooney at #10 quite a bit.
I actually don't get why they want another top striker, I would be getting someone who can play anywhere across the front and is up and coming. Just not inspired by the striker names they keep coming up with. Same old names.
I agree he will get his game time and play well for us. I like him a lot but he is not the next coming of Messi that some people are making him out to be.
He's a very good player but he is not the one undropable player in the squad as has been mentioned in this thread after all he was often dropped last year.
As for the last bit of the season. It was worse than the start with only 1 win and 3 goals in 6 games.
He wasn't playing number 10 last year and if we go with a midfield 3 then he'll get plenty of game time.
He was superb at the end of last season and to be fair to him, its not unreasonable to expect a player coming to a new league to take time to settle. The suggestions that he might now be sold because we've signed two midfielder is lazy journalism ignoring the fact that we were so light in midfield last year he was often the only recognised midfielder playing in there.
For me the first choice midfield is any three from Carrick, Schweinsteiger, Schneiderlin and Herrera. I see no reason we'd sell him given that we'll potentially have 50 games next year and especially since Carrick and potentially Schweinsteiger (given recent injury issues) are likely not be fit for the whole season without interruption.
Bottom line though for me is clear - why would we move on one of our best players when he's just starting to show what he can do?
Can't be arsed getting into positional semantics but I'm talking about him playing as an advanced central midfielder. Which is something he did do last season, on a number of occasions. Where he struggled was when he had to play a bit deeper, which I don't see happening again now we've so many players capable of playing that position better than him.
Sorry, whats this? Who said anything about selling?
I'm sort of with Pogue and the others in that I think he'll end up in and out of the side this season. I think most weeks we'll play two of Schneiderlin/Schweinsteiger/Carrick in midfield with one out of Mata, Herrera and Fellaini playing ahead, in some guise. None of which even mentions the inevitable Rooney positional shift if we buy someone like Cavani.
Unrealistic imo
Why? He nearly did it last year.
Fair enough. I'd be very surprised if Van Gaal wasn't impressed with him at the end of last year so I don't see why he'd neccessarily be the one to drop out. Schneiderlin is nailed on for me to sit in front of the back four and I'm not sure where that leaves Carrick in terms of playing further forward. Herrera is a much better option for me in terms of moving the ball and getting into dangerous positions.
If Mata gets in I think it'll be on the right of a three upfront. I suppose a lot depends on who comes in, but it wasn;'t that long ago Mata was supposed to be away. Seems to me this Herrera to Athletico/Valencia stuff has come from nowhere.
As much as I don't think Rooney is a really top striker anymore and would love an upgrade there (if we can find one), I'd much rather we kept Rooney upfront if it meant him having to take Herrera's place in midfield if a new striker is signed.
Herrera will be a key player for us, and offers a different skillset to the others.
Herrera will be a key player for us, and offers a different skillset to the others.
Seems to be suggested in the Spanish press - Athletico and Valencia linked. According to the internet anyway.
He got 8 in 22 starts this season all competitions, it's not that unrealistic.
It really isnt unrealistic. He will play a big amount of the 50 or so games we have in the season. Thats pretty much 1 every 5 games (or 4) provided he plays (which he should).
Agreed he will get plenty of game time but I see those 3 all getting games if we are playing well in all competitions.
I wouldn't go out on a limb as to which of the 3 he picks as his #10 for the first game of the season against Spurs, I think that players have the 4 matches preseason and the training sessions to make their case for a starting place.
It will be very interesting to see what happens preseason.
I think Fellaini will be an impact sub tbh. I think it will be two of Schw/Schn/Carrick and either Mata/Herrera.
Sports Witness on the sales claim. Seems claims originated in Italy (and not from Di Marzio!). Wouldn't think there's anything in it.
The positive vibe going through the camp has been well noted. I get the impression ander is central to it. great player.
Fellaini was one of only 2 players that LVG named as Undroppable last season, the other being his captain.
He was most important in the games against expansive teams such as Spurs, who we play the first match of the season. I can see him being penciled in for that one.
LvG is always saying things. Fellaini was bloody awful towards to end. Seriously awful and I think you will find he can't play against anyone for 3 games after his stupidity in the last game.
I forgot that he was banned did they confirm it would be 3 games?
The whole team was shocking in the last 6 games 1 win and 3 goals is shocking for a team that is supposed to be challenging for honors.
That's what happened when Carrick is missing, in a way that is why I don't think he will risk Carrick and Schweinsteiger together. They are options for each other. Although he seems to think Schneiderlin is as well. Our luck they will both get injured and we will be back to square one. Yes it is a 3 match ban. These new players names are killing me. I will likely spell them differently everytime I mention them.
I stick to Bastian and Morgan it's easier.That's what happened when Carrick is missing, in a way that is why I don't think he will risk Carrick and Schweinsteiger together. They are options for each other. Although he seems to think Schneiderlin is as well. Our luck they will both get injured and we will be back to square one. Yes it is a 3 match ban. These new players names are killing me. I will likely spell them differently everytime I mention them.
I think I will and annoy the folk who don't like us using players first names.I stick to Bastian and Morgan it's easier.
Why would anybody care If you call him Bastian or Schweinsteiger? It's his name after all.I think I will and annoy the folk who don't like us using players first names.
Some are really funny about it. That you don't know them so don't use their first names.
And I'd be, yeah backs away and locks the padded cell on the way out.
I wouldn't care but if they were asking for their autograph they would call them by their name. You wouldn't shout out "Oi Rooney sign this". I would presume you would be phenominally polite and say "Please would you sign this Wayne".Exactly. Where I was brought up you call people by the first names or the last name with their proper title, Mr Schweinsteiger If they are older than you, never just their last name, it just seems so cold.
Exactly teachers and bosses call you by your surname.
Nah my boss is Dave.
I definitely wouldn't call a teacher by their first name. Disagree with that completely. This thread is going off at a tangent.
No I would either but then their is that age gap between teacher and pupil. Even if there isn't one 6th former's newly qualified teachers one should be manufactured for propriety's sake.
Yeah what was this thread about anyway before we took it in a whole new direction.
- Status