I actually think that the likes of Smith and Kay have come out of this looking very out of touch with reality and, to be honest, quite thick people. Not because of what they are arguing but because of some of the terrible reasoning and the way they've been presenting it.
And I wouldn't necessarily put that on Liverpool fans or anyone else with strong biases. It's understandable why some fans would want to continue and some want to stop and there is allowances afforded for that - not to mention allowances for online shit talking. But it's quite odd to see some of these guys invest so heavily in, and construct such intricately bad arguments.