But why Carrick?Hart
Clyne---Smalling---Stones---Shaw
Carrick/Dier
Alli---Barkley
Chamberlain---Kane---Sterling
Is actually a really good team. Also has potential to be one of the best IMO.

But why Carrick?Hart
Clyne---Smalling---Stones---Shaw
Carrick/Dier
Alli---Barkley
Chamberlain---Kane---Sterling
Is actually a really good team. Also has potential to be one of the best IMO.
Agree with this, but in the summer we'll end up with this dream lineup:
Hart
Clyne - Cahill - Smalling - Baines
Milner - Henderson - Barkley
Vardy - Rooney - Sterling
Because he's very good in the DM/deep lying playmaker role. With 2 dynamic midfielders in front of him, it could work, and for the summer, it'd be good to have his experience in the middle of the park. For the future, Dier might turn out to be a top class DM (so far he's done very well but we'll have to see if he can also do it at the top level).But why Carrick?he's done for a while nevermind he absolutely doesnt fit in this potentially brutal team.. Also I prefer Ox from the middle.. JWP might come in handy in a few years if he finally steps up, could be well used as deep laying playmaker, already a fantastic set piece taker
Ox is a bit shit, could do with replacing. Walcott? Welbeck? He tends to perform for the national side. The rest of that side is probably the best we could get.Hart
Clyne---Smalling---Stones---Shaw
Carrick/Dier
Alli---Barkley
Chamberlain---Kane---Sterling
Is actually a really good team. Also has potential to be one of the best IMO.
There is absolutely no reason why to call him to England squad, he's past it anyway. Would actually be pretty shocking. Dier would balance it even more, Carrick has mobility of a slowpoke and his defensive contribution is hugely overrated, he will be soon 35 and plans to retire very soon ffs, its not like we are talking about scholes who was very good even when he came out of retirement. And I wouldnt call even him, younger more tenacious players deserve chanceBecause he's very good in the DM/deep lying playmaker role. With 2 dynamic midfielders in front of him, it could work, and for the summer, it'd be good to have his experience in the middle of the park. For the future, Dier might turn out to be a top class DM (so far he's done very well but we'll have to see if he can also do it at the top level).
That is what i think. Barkley seems to be more of a playmaker and Alli is more well rounded. They won't get in each other's way like Lampard and Gerard who thrived in the same areas. I think they will compliment each other well, atleast on paper it looks that way.Barkley with a slight edge in the attacking and passing stats. But Alli offers much more defensively. Maybe they could be a Lampard and Gerrard who actually compliment each other.
That is what i think. Barkley seems to be more of a playmaker and Alli is more well rounded. They won't get in each other's way like Lampard and Gerard who thrived in the same areas. I think they will compliment each other well, atleast on paper it looks that way.
Still needs a defensive midfielder in a 3.
Don't agree, bolded part is wrong but you're entitled to your opinion.There is absolutely no reason why to call him to England squad, he's past it anyway. Would actually be pretty shocking. Dier would balance it even more, Carrick has mobility of a slowpoke and his defensive contribution is hugely overrated, he will be soon 35 and plans to retire very soon ffs, its not like we are talking about scholes who was very good even when he came out of retirement. And I wouldnt call even him, younger more tenacious players deserve chance
Dier - Alli
---Barkley
Carrick is experienced yes, but no longer has the energy and mobility. Besides, Dier and Alli already know each other's game.
I am wrong and that's my opinion, funny how you state it like it's true but try to compensate it with "but its just youre opinion and people have also wrong opinions" which also defacto says your wrong..Don't agree, bolded part is wrong but you're entitled to your opinion.
I don't agree about your overall assessment of Carrick but I recognize that you are entitled to your opinion. However the part about his defensive contribution being overrated is completely wrong imo.I am wrong and that's my opinion, funny how you state it like it's true but try to compensate it with "but its just youre opinion and people have also wrong opinions" which also defacto says your wrong..
Carrick was overall quite overrated player by United fans over years, funny how we suddenly have midfield now and we are not talking about any wordclass players... but I wont get into this argument again, it already took some part of my life and I am not wasting my time anymore on this. Bias towards some players is huge here but everyone is entitled to have an opinion as you said but that doesn't automatically mean that it is true/untrue let alone some things cant be classified as that and are simply matter of, again, opinion.
I don't agree about your overall assessment of Carrick but I recognize that you are entitled to your opinion. However the part about his defensive contribution being overrated is completely wrong imo.
To put your comment in perspectiveGreat young talent, with bags of potential, but he's a bit of a prick, isn't he?
To put your comment in perspective
To put your comment in perspective
I know but other people needed context and I had just seen it as well so that's why I knew what you were talking about.Ye, well that's what prompted me to bump the thread, although it's not the first time he's done stupid like that.
To put your comment in perspective
Great young talent, with bags of potential, but he's a bit of a prick, isn't he?
Pochettino will sort him out:
"We need to look at the video and try to teach him," he said. "He is a young player and he has a lot to learn about elite football. It is his first season in the Premier League at Tottenham. He came from League One, he needs to still learn a lot."
Pochettino will sort him out:
"We need to look at the video and try to teach him," he said. "He is a young player and he has a lot to learn about elite football. It is his first season in the Premier League at Tottenham. He came from League One, he needs to still learn a lot."
I know but other people needed context and I had just seen it as well so that's why I knew what you were talking about.
How the flying feck did every big team in the Prem let him go to Spurs?
here we goBecause, in his own words: "When I signed here I wanted to play for Tottenham and I wasn't thinking of going anywhere else at the time .... I’m really excited to be working with Pochettino."