FC Seoul V Manchester United 20th July 2007, KO 12.00 BST

The only thing that might work against Eagles in forging a successful top flight career is his physique. Of all the academy graduates only he and Rossi seem to have the technique to play at the highest level as attackers.
 
I don't think so, it's no disrepect to Heinze who I think is a decent squad player. It's just Evra is that good imo. If he keeps on improving at this rate he's going to be in the Roberto Carlos class soon.

agreed, hes grea going forward, not the best defensively, but if we're an attacking team, i suppose itll work!
 
How can people say he's not the best defensively, really does my head in, it's like just because he's a left back who can attack he's got to be bad defensively to level it out..

He's not.
 
Evra being LEAGUES better than Heinze? C'mon. Certainly, you've seen football. Certainly you've seen Manchester United play. Certainly you've seen the recent Copa America! I will agree that Evra is better, but your exaggeration with him being WAY better is WAY off.
 
Nice effort from Ronaldo.Who as obviously been told to shoot on site.
 
How can people say he's not the best defensively, really does my head in, it's like just because as a left back who can attack he's got to be bad defensively to level it out..

He's not.

he's pretty shite in the air, doesnt win enough headers to be honest.

i didnt judge this on what i watched on tv, when i have been to old trafford this season ive seen him play and really he isnt that good in the air.

ok, we wont take that away from him, but in general for me he gets caught up the pitch far too much and it doesnt seem as though he has as much strength, hes more of an athlete if anything!

i know heinze has his faults aswell, but the difference between the players isnt that much, especially how some people make out!
 
Agreed.

Let's just watch out second match of the pre-season and enjoy the fact we are 3-0 first half instead of arguing about who is better.