Great players lift everyone around them and make "the shit players" better. The problem with Pogba is that as great as he can be, he is too inconsistant. This is why Shaw got POTY last year. Even if you looked through the match ratings on here last year Shaw was the highest ranked. That's because for every 8 that Pogba had he also had some 3's to follow it up. Meanwhile Shaw was a steady 7. So yes, Pogba is our most talented player however he doesn't show that talent in every game which was evident when he got played off the field by Mark fecking Noble...