But that's the thing, he would've won more if Pep didn't cheat. We can look at statistics on paper but they belie the truth. Reaching high 90s in points should win you the league.
We can't claim City have cheated and then claim Klopp hasn't done that well.
Right, but Liverpool/Klopp wouldn't have been the only team/manager to benefit from extra success if you removed City from the equation.
It's impossible to take oil-rich City out of the picture and not get all "butterfly effect", but possibly the biggest one there is Rodgers winning the league with Liverpool, potentially meaning Klopp never gets the job at all.
If you simply bump everyone up a spot (assuming City maintained their pre-lottery midtable status), United get an extra three league titles (including another threepeat for Fergie), as do Liverpool.
I also think the points thing is overblown. They were very impressive league campaigns, and I have to begrudgingly accept that they should have won the league (as City are massive cheats) but the prize is the same whether you finish on 96 points, 15+ points clear of second, or if you finish on 79 points, and clinch it on the last day.
Points totals are always relative season to season, and it's arguably just as impressive to win the league with a lower points total, indicating a more competitive league, than it is to win in a procession where you're clearly head and shoulders above everyone else (at least that time around).
One of the biggest (and perhaps only) blots on his record for me is the lack of consistency.
United were one point in 94/95 and two points in 97/98 from a clean sweep of the first nine Premier League seasons, and two points in 09/10 and one point in 11/12 from seven in a row between 06/07 and 12/13.
Klopp's Liverpool, despite their impressive points hauls in previous seasons, found themselves third, as title holders, behind Solskjaer's United, 17 points adrift of the top, and needing a late-season collapse from Leicester (and a Chelsea side preoccupied with the Champions League), as well as last minute winners by their goalkeeper, to even make the CL places.
Last season, despite 92 points (and an unsuccessful run at the quadruple) the season before, they ended up 5th, four points off the CL placed and 22 off the winners.
Ultimately, they haven't actually been a consistent second best to City, which is why people take issue with this idea that it's only their cheating that's stopped him from dominating the PL.