Luka Modric

It's annoying how you seem to be trying to create so many different categories of someone who plays centrally between the defenders and strikers, just so that Modric becomes one of the best.

Exactly. And he annoyingly keeps hopping over mail where I suggest to him that people were saying the same thing about Modric (can't play in a 2 etc) as reasons for us not to sign him after his first year at Spurs.

Given a chance, these talented midfielders can play just fine in a 2, just as Modric showed at Spuds.
 
Oh one other thing, back in 1994, how many people on this forum (were it around) would've come out with the same "can't play in a 2" nonsense regarding the idea of Paul Scholes dropping back into midfield?
 
Wilshere has performed much better against much better opposition (see Barcelona as an example) at 18 or 19 than Modric has his entire career. I also disagree with Ozil, I certainly wouldn't say he's a Rooney. He's an attacking, creative central midfielder. It's annoying how you seem to be trying to create so many different categories of someone who plays centrally between the defenders and strikers, just so that Modric becomes one of the best. Ozil can't be counted as he plays a little too far forward, Martinez can't as he plays a little too far back. How about we just say he's the best central midfielder in the world whose first name is Luka?

If you need a few more then Busquets, Fabregas, De Rossi are better and the likes of Bender, Moutinho are of a similar level and younger, so would be preferable. As I said I don't think he's a great player when it matters, I'd have Dembele before him.

I also still stand by the fact that it would be very difficult to accommodate Modric and Carrick, without sacrificing our formation. They would recycle possession very well, but we'd be very vulnerable and would be even more heavily reliant on our wingers than we are now.

Where has Dembele done it when it matters? And why do you consistently ignore Modric's performances against quality midfields, both in the PL and International stage.

Also, if Cleverley can perform well with Carrick, I'm pretty sure Modric would have no trouble doing the same. I mean, he looked good alongside Scott fecking Parker who is half the player Carrick is. Another thing you've lied about is our reliance on wingers, that's not the case anymore as evidenced by the shite form of all of them this season, yet we should sit 7 points clear tonight.

I don't really care if we sign Modric or not, I'm happy with Cleverley and Andersons progression this season and I think we'd be better off with a different type of midfielder. But lets not start making things up to suit your agenda so soon after accusing others of doing it.
 
Where has Dembele done it when it matters? And why do you consistently ignore Modric's performances against quality midfields, both in the PL and International stage.

Also, if Cleverley can perform well with Carrick, I'm pretty sure Modric would have no trouble doing the same. I mean, he looked good alongside Scott fecking Parker who is half the player Carrick is. Another thing you've lied about is our reliance on wingers, that's not the case anymore as evidenced by the shite form of all of them this season, yet we should sit 7 points clear tonight.

I don't really care if we sign Modric or not, I'm happy with Cleverley and Andersons progression this season and I think we'd be better off with a different type of midfielder. But lets not start making things up to suit your agenda so soon after accusing others of doing it.

Maybe I'm blind to Modric's magnificent performances. I watched every game between Spurs and a top 4 team between 2009-2011 and I never thought he shone as a magnificent player. He ranged between invisible and good, usually the former. I don't think Dembele has been incredible and I don't think we should sign him, I'm just saying he is of a similar level (in my opinion) and is younger.

I said we'd be more reliant on wingers with Modric and Carrick, which in my opinion would be a bad thing, what's your point? Of course Modric looked decent next to Parker... Parker would run around like a headless chicken putting in all legwork, whilst Modric would calmly recycle possession, essentially a poor version of Scholes with a little more legs... We know how great a partnership Scholes/Carrick is.

I've never wanted Modric, as I really don't think he is very good. He is suited to being a big(ish) fish in a medium sized pond.
 
Maybe a bit old, but this confirms that Modric is not very appreciated at Real.

According to my contact man the talks has been good between the clubs and it could happen that he's leaving late in the summer if he's not showing signs of improvements.

http://www.marca.com/2012/12/31/en/football/spanish_football/1356978303.html

And

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1514971-why-luka-modric-has-struggled-to-impress-at-real-madrid

"...The truth lies in two factors: acclimatization and the need for a run of games. In the Ajax game lies the answer: Luke Modric can still be a success in Madrid. If he hangs around."
 
He was very good tonight imo. Would still love him here.
 
He's superb almost every time I watch him. Would be so much better for us then them in my opinion. Hope we put in a cheeky bid to try to tempt him, although I can't see it as he's been doing better lately.
 
He's superb almost every time I watch him. Would be so much better for us then them in my opinion. Hope we put in a cheeky bid to try to tempt him, although I can't see it as he's been doing better lately.

Seems to have won Mourinho over by stepping up at a time when lots of his more senior players have gone missing, so I don't think there's any hope of dislodging him.
 
So according to my source Modric will be tougher to get because Madrid is not sure any more if they should sell him after his late season spark.

We will see if they will work something out during this week and prepare a transfer for the summer.
 
So according to my source Modric will be tougher to get because Madrid is not sure any more if they should sell him after his late season spark.

We will see if they will work something out during this week and prepare a transfer for the summer.

What? Who?

Are we even seriously interested in him?
 
What? Who?

Are we even seriously interested in him?

I was told this by the same guy who gave me information about Scholes making a come back. He's usually correct about these stuff because he has connections with people within the club. He knows they are in Madrid talking about Modric right now. If the transfer will happen is up to Madric, Modric and United.
 
I was told this by the same guy who gave me information about Scholes making a come back. He's usually correct about these stuff because he has connections with people within the club. He knows they are in Madrid talking about Modric right now. If the transfer will happen is up to Madric, Modric and United.

That makes a lot of sense. Thank you.
 
He'd still be my first choice. Saw him on Wednesday and he was brilliant. I'd easily still take him over any of the Bayern or Dortmund CM's, though they seem to be in the in vogue choices at the moment. Madrid would be crazy to sell him. Other than Ronaldo, he's their best player.
 
He'd still be my first choice. Saw him on Wednesday and he was brilliant. I'd easily still take him over any of the Bayern or Dortmund CM's, though they seem to be in the in vogue choices at the moment. Madrid would be crazy to sell him. Other than Ronaldo, he's their best player.

We are talking about Real :lol: anyway they fired the best manager they could get (Mourinho was already fired when they lost la liga and confirmed when they lost to Dortmund), they are going to sale a bunch of players and buy another bunch.
 
He's not amazing or world class but he's still a very good player. It's not easy for him to thrive in Madrid with a lot of competition from Khedira and Alonso but he should find his way into form eventually. There aren't many midfielders around that Real could replace him with so I think they'll just ignore his poor spell at one point this season and give him more time to settle and be as good as he can be. They could try for someone like Gundogan but there's no guarantee that he would come in and do better than him instantly. There are some promising young Spanish midfielders like Camacho and Herrera but none of them seem as talented as Modric.
 
I'd sort of forgotten about him as an option. I've wanted us to get him for a very long time now, he'd be superb alongside Carrick.

If Mourinho was staying, I'd say Modric would definitely stay too. He's been excellent recently and seems to have really won Mourinho's trust by showing up when lots of the more senior players have struggled for form.

But maybe with Mourinho going, that newly-earned trust won't count for much with the club itself.
 
He had a very bad start for his first half a season but since he scored that stunner against us, he's done the same a bunch of times and looks a lot more at home at Madrid now. I'd expect them to keep him one more reason at least depending on the new manager
 
It's been a quiet day for muppets I suppose, so this my gift to you:

1044519_354925624634753_1963836376_n.jpg
 
His son with a United ball? Too bad his kid can't read yet, otherwise we would send Big Dave to do business.
 
He's improved at Madrid but I'm not sure if I'd want him unless it was for a fairly cheap price.

He's very good on the ball, is a good passer and is undoubtedly a very good midfielder but one thing I always thought was that he had a tendency to sometimes struggle against top teams when he wasn't getting a lot of the ball. He was the type of player who always seemed to do very well when given plenty of time on it, but not so much when being pressurised on it. Our problems have sometimes been the same when we notoriously struggled against teams who played a high pressure game and I don't think he'd really fix that at all. As I say, he's a very good player but I wouldn't really break the bank for him.
 
He was supposed to be Mourinho's weapon in Europe. Look how it turned out.

He's the type of player we need in our midfield. But the the ship has sailed.
 
My opinion of him has never changed. He's great, and would be a fecking terrific player for us.
 
Has always been stupidly overrated, and his season at Madrid shows that.

He's a good player. Nothing more nothing less.
 
He really wasn't that bad at Madrid chaps. Did anyone watch many of their games?
 
Has always been stupidly overrated, and his season at Madrid shows that.

He's a good player. Nothing more nothing less.

So we're judging players based on just one season at a new club in a new country now? Not to mention the club in question is that circus is Madrid. OK....

He's a brilliant player who would drastically improve our midfield.
 
He had a quiet first half of the season but he played more in the second half of the season Mourinho saw what he could bring to the side. He is a an intelligent player, deceptively strong, composed and an organiser in midfielder he makes the game easier for those around him would help the likes of Valencia and Young. I would not mind having him here at all 25 milllion.
 
Has always been stupidly overrated, and his season at Madrid shows that.

He's a good player. Nothing more nothing less.


He was excellent in the latter part of last season. I disagree that he's overrated, I think he's a fantastic player and at times makes the game look so effortless. I'd absolutely love him to join us, probably just as much as I'd like to see us sign the elusive Thiago.
 
Has always been stupidly overrated, and his season at Madrid shows that.

He's a good player. Nothing more nothing less.

A season where he finished as arguably their best player bar Cristiano?

I'm sure if you ask Jose Mourinho he would explain he doesn't sign merely good players for £30 million. He is a super little footballer and always has been. All I ever notice from Modric critics (general point) is how he's got skills but never controlled "the big games" yada yada. Do these people actually understand how hard it is for one single central midfielder to dominate the biggest games? There are very few who could do it consistently perhaps Zidane at his peak, Keane and Scholes, Pirlo and Xavi in recent years. All exceptional players who are a rarity in the game.

Modric would be a fantastic addition for United, someone who can play well into his 30's but I suspect he will feature regularly under Ancellotti.
 
For some reason Mourinho played him mostly as AM, Ozil's position, instead of his natural CM position.
 
For some reason Mourinho played him mostly as AM, Ozil's position, instead of his natural CM position.


Di Maria and Ozil are inconsistent Modric was more reliable. Plus he loves the Alonso-Khedira axis.