Lukaku vs Icardi vs Belotti vs Lacazette

Which striker would you sign


  • Total voters
    323
Belotti is the type of striker that Mourinho likes. Tall, strong and physically imposing, with a presence inside the box.
 
There aren't many world class strikers available, a lot of strikers available seem to be either young strikers with high potential like Dolberg, Dembele, and Mbappe or players like Lukaku, Belotti, and Lacazette, who you could argue about whether they would make the step up from their current clubs.

Anyway, I don't think we'll sign any of them this summer, it'll be next when Ibrahimovic has left. I know many feel that wouldn't be the correct decision, especially if we make CL football. If we do somehow end up moving for a striker this summer, I feel it'd end up being a young player who we're forced to move in for because of other clubs lurking around them.
 
Belotti is the type of striker that Mourinho likes. Tall, strong and physically imposing, with a presence inside the box.

Aye, never seen him play but from what I've read, he's a player that 'defends from the front' and works extremely hard for the team and handily enough, can score quite a-bit too. He's not the tallest though, is he?
 
Aye, never seen him play but from what I've read ,he's a player that 'defends from the front' and works extremely hard for the team and handily enough, can score quite a-bit too. He's not the tallest though, is he?

He's probably 5ft 11" at most. That's a decent height. Similar to Milito who he had at Inter.
 
Height for a striker really is irrelevant. Usually the best goal scorers are on the smaller side anyway. Acceleration and anticipation is far more important than being tall.
 
Height for a striker really is irrelevant. Usually the best goal scorers are on the smaller side anyway. Acceleration and anticipation is far more important than being tall.

It depends on the system. Having players with height and aerial prowess has its advantages.

For example, not many players would have scored the header that Ronaldo produced last night.
 
Height for a striker really is irrelevant. Usually the best goal scorers are on the smaller side anyway. Acceleration and anticipation is far more important than being tall.

Depends on the team. Especially in 1 striker systems.
 
He's probably 5ft 11" at most. That's a decent height. Similar to Milito who he had at Inter.

Ah right, not too bad. I keep reading about him being imposing, but I assume then that's all to do with his build. Sounds like he's a talented player that would be a good fit for us.
 
Ah right, not too bad. I keep reading about him being imposing, but I assume then that's all to do with his build. Sounds like he's a talented player that would be a good fit for us.

He's brave and puts himself about. He has a good leap on him. Deceptively good on the ball like Costa.
 
It depends on the system. Having players with height and aerial prowess has its advantages.

For example, not many players would have scored the header that Ronaldo produced last night.
Ronaldo's leap and movement is the main thing for scoring headers, Crouch or Zigic wouldn't score it because they wouldn't be on the move.
Depends on the team. Especially in 1 striker systems.
Sure it can help hold up play, but look at Messi/Suarez/Aguero/Icardi/Tevez/Rooney

It's more about using your body and keeping the ball away from your opponent. Being tall doesn't help you hold a ball up.
 
Ronaldo's leap and movement is the main thing for scoring headers, Crouch or Zigic wouldn't score it because they wouldn't be on the move.

Sure it can help hold up play, but look at Messi/Suarez/Aguero/Icardi/Tevez/Rooney

It's more about using your body and keeping the ball away from your opponent. Being tall doesn't help you hold a ball up.

Only that? Like I said it depends on the team.
 
Looks like Belotti has bagged himself a hat-trick today. Icardi has a goal and an assist too, and Lukaku got himself one goal.
 
Lukaku and Belotti will fit into the type of strikers that Jose signs. With Lukaku just signing a new deal, Belotti would be our best option. Chelsea will probably try to sign him this summer. With Zlatan most likely staying, I fear we will miss out on him.
 
Lukaku and Belotti will fit into the type of strikers that Jose signs. With Lukaku just signing a new deal, Belotti would be our best option. Chelsea will probably try to sign him this summer. With Zlatan most likely staying, I fear we will miss out on him.
Belotti will probably go to Inter or Milan (if they are starting to build something) if he even leaves. He'll probably not risk anything to ruin his chances of playing next year in the WC. So my guess is that he'll stay in Italy even if he leaves Torino.
 
Aye, never seen him play but from what I've read, he's a player that 'defends from the front' and works extremely hard for the team and handily enough, can score quite a-bit too. He's not the tallest though, is he?
Almost 6'1", not short or tall. Decent height. I think he is like Herrera though, because from what I have seen he runs about with his back arched a bit.
 
I voted for Icardi. His overall game seems the best but I'm sure if he's your typical Mourinho striker. How much would Icardi cost? I suspect a hell of chunk, aren't Inter in the money now?
 
Lukaku would cost a fortune after his renewal. Let's take a punt on Belotti or Lacazette.




Belotti won't come cheap either by the sound of things.
 


Belotti won't come cheap either by the sound of things.


That's why he won't move this year. He hasn't done enough to justify such a price tag, nowhere near.

He has had one good season, this one. His previous seasons were underwhelming. He scored 12 goals last season and 6 the one before. He's also not performing in Europe or at International level yet. Thus all his goals are at domestic level for a side that is 9th. He's not been judged at a higher standard. There no guarantee this is not a "unicorn" season like Vardy.

If he's worth 100m then consistent performers at the highest level, like Griezmann, Sanchez etc should be worth £250m and over. Belotti's value is about £35m atm, at a push £40m. And that's taking a massive gamble.
 
Surely Torino can't reject a Martial like deal, I mean nobody is going to pay 150 mil or even 100, they're just posing to get the best deal. Are they loaded enough to reject a £60-65 mil where we'd pay 40 odd up front and rest in bonuses ?

@RedMaestro @MaxiPaxi
 
Belotti will probably go to Inter or Milan (if they are starting to build something) if he even leaves. He'll probably not risk anything to ruin his chances of playing next year in the WC. So my guess is that he'll stay in Italy even if he leaves Torino.
Inter already have Icardi. Milan will be an option after the Chinese takeover. But it would be better for him to just stay at Torino instead if his aim is to play in the World Cup. That way, he can move to the PL or some other big club after the World Cup. If he moves to Milan now, he'll have to stay there for a few more years. Also, Belotti is one of those players that would perfectly fit into the PL style of play. He has that grit and determination similar to Tevez and Suarez. So, a move to the PL shouldn't really faze him.
 
None of the above. Sign Zlatan till 2019 and let Martial and Rashford gradually take over.

If we really had to sign one, I'd pick Lukaku.
 
9 minute hat-trick for Icardi.

20 goals and 8 assists in total.

I really hope Jose is considering him.


Yeah I mean I hope we get him. He's absolutely lethal. His link up play is great as well. Can assist too obviously which is quality to have in a striker.
 
Yeah I mean I hope we get him. He's absolutely lethal. His link up play is great as well. Can assist too obviously which is quality to have in a striker.

Totally agree. He's a great finisher (which we really need to convert all our wasted chances), physically strong, great at winning aerial duels/holding up play and his link-up play is ever improving. He suits Jose's striker requirements and I think he would adapt really well to the PL.
 
Totally agree. He's a great finisher (which we really need to convert all our wasted chances), physically strong, great at winning aerial duels/holding up play and his link-up play is ever improving. He suits Jose's striker requirements and I think he would adapt really well to the PL.

Well yeah if Gabbiadini coming from an Italian league anything to go by then Icardi will be absolutely unbelievable. Anyway, I wish it was that simple. :lol:
 
It's like the Belotti show. He's going to be amazing for whoever gets him.

It's his intensity and aggression to go with the incredible finishing ability that really sets him apart. Reminds me of Diego Costa in his Atletico days. Jose would love him.


Yeah he's cracker too, but is he worth €100 million? His chairman just said that he won't sell him for any less.
 
Seen Icardi outright dominate juventus CBs. He's scored a lot against them in general.
 
Belotti has the best all around game as well

Those key passes, and expected assists...



vs.

Icardi, who isn't dispossessed much



and Lukaku, whose passing is awful

 
Last edited: