I'd take the risk with Sarri, it would be a rollercoaster ride, that is for sure.
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
Poch would be first choice followed by Simeone or Sarri.
I hope Jose stays. That being said if he were to leave I would be interested to see if Jardim might leave Monaco. Big fan of his and who knows what he could do with more financial backing and not having to sell his stars?
Never heard of him.
Any decent manager that understands the attacking game.
Please no for Simeone. Not sure why people would want him when he's basically just like Mourinho just less proven? Wouldn't the main thing we'd want after moving on from Mourinho would be to get a manager who can play exciting football and get a team that can dominate? That's not Simeone at all.
I reckon it'll be Carlo (if Jose departs).
There's nobody worthy tbh, back in the day when managers like Pep and Klopp were approachable but can't see anyone in that standard. Anyone we go for will probably be a downgrade from Mourinho.
Maybe Zidane if he gets sacked post PSG match. I'd trust him to make good use out of Pogba.
Maybe Zidane if he gets sacked post PSG match. I'd trust him to make good use out of Pogba.
Neville.
What about Jardim? People here want an attacking brand of football and a (relatively speaking) young manager with plenty of coaching experience; he can't be far off the top of the wishlist.
He has to be at the top imo. He ticks every box of a Man United manager.
(Tin Helmet on)
I'm surprised nobody has suggested Rafa Benítez yet
I'm surprised nobody has suggested Rafa Benítez yet
Hard no on him, although it'd be interesting to see if he would still be so venerated by the scousers if he was to become our manager.
Hope not, he's not upto the task of rebuilding.
Roy Keane
It would almost be worth it just to see the reaction at Anfield when he arrived as Manager of United, RAWK would go into the Mother of all Meltdowns, they'd deny Istanbul ever happened.
silva miles ahead. Poll either needs a reset or needs to be stickied as a permanent reminder against snap decisions and why the fans don't always know bestMy hope is that the answer is at least two years away and maybe by then pochettino or jardim will have confirmed pedigree and won't have a rebuilding job on their hands
Remember when Chelsea F.C took a punt on a young Mourinho? yes he did well in the Portuguese league but still could've easily flopped. Nothing is guaranteed in football. But that's what makes it so exciting.. IF you take the risk out of football and clubs making hastily boardroom decisions/axing/appointments and football is dead as we know it.. and boring.
Why can't we take a punt on a young-up-and-coming manager to find Manchester United's Jose Mourinho? a young, flash, foreigner, up-and-coming manager who has the potential to do what Mourinho did.
Jardim seems worth it.
Why can't we take a punt on a young-up-and-coming manager to find Manchester United's Jose Mourinho? a young, flash, foreigner, up-and-coming manager who has the potential to do what Mourinho did.
Jardim seems worth it.
The feck i had to change my vote from Poch to Simeone, weird part, dont think i ever voted for Poch. But yea went for Simeone, not because i like him, or his style but because i believe its more natural next step to JM, making jumps from one end to another makes no sense like from LvG to JM.
You forget that same young Jose was already winning 2 trebles in a row in Porto, winning EL an UCL with Porto. No ones has the same feat as Jose done with lesser team today. Take a punt with young talent manager for United is a big gamble. With drama surrounding all over the club, make it even riskier.
I hope we go for a young progressive manager this time around. The best choice is Pochettino, imo. After that Tuchel & Jardim are interesting choices.
The list of ones I do not want:
(1) Simeone - Can't stand his football. That kind of defensive football is fine for Atletico, won't work here.
(2) Ancelloti - He is typical cup manager.
(3) Nagelsman - Too early for such a step up.
(4) Giggs - Are you kidding me!
The list of ones I do not want:
(1) Simeone - Can't stand his football. That kind of defensive football is fine for Atletico, won't work here.
(2) Ancelloti - He is typical cup manager.
(3) Nagelsman - Too early for such a step up.
(4) Giggs - Are you kidding me!
Surprised to see Silva as the runaway winner.
Even though I am not a Mourinho fan, but seeing that list makes me hope he doesn't leave anytime soon. I would only have Guardiola over him. Otherwise Jardim and Poch are the only decent ones. I liked LVG by the way. LVG with better players (which he was incapable of identifying) would have done good here.
Last edited:
Sheesh. Looking at that list makes me a bit more appreciative of Mourinho in all honesty.
Simeone is the only person there who I think has the balls to impose his personality on the club, but as successful as Atletico have been, their football outside of the big high pressure games is hard to enjoy. Worse than Mourinho's style for sure.
Allegri is maybe the safest bet, but hardly inspiring.
Simeone is the only person there who I think has the balls to impose his personality on the club, but as successful as Atletico have been, their football outside of the big high pressure games is hard to enjoy. Worse than Mourinho's style for sure.
Allegri is maybe the safest bet, but hardly inspiring.
Its always a bit worrying when threads like these appear especially with our current manager only half way through his term.
very decent yet flawed manager but can you really see us hiring someone as negative and pragmatic
he's a steady the ship manager
Chelsea had finished second in the Premier League the season before Mourinho arrived, so he obviously inherited a talented squad, and then he was allowed to spend like a Drunken Sailor.......
20 DF Paulo Ferreira - Porto £13.2 million 23 June 2004
1 GK Petr Čech - Rennes £7.1 million 1 July 2004
16 MF Arjen Robben - PSV £12 million 1 July 2004
9 FW Mateja Kežman - PSV £5.3 million 13 July 2004
15 FW Didier Drogba - Marseille £24 million 20 July 2004
30 MF Tiago - Benfica £10 million 21 July 2004
6 DF Ricardo Carvalho - Porto £19.85 million 28 July 2004
33 DF Nuno Morais - Penafiel Undisclosed 29 August 2004
27 MF Jiří Jarošík - CSKA Moscow £3 million 6 January 2005
3 DF Asier del Horno - Athletic Bilbao £8 million 21 June 2005
19 MF Lassana Diarra - Le Havre £1 million 16 July 2005
24 MF Shaun Wright-Phillips - Manchester City £21 million 18 July 2005
5 MF Michael Essien - Lyon £24.4 million 19 August 2005
7 MF Maniche - Dynamo Moscow Loan 4 January 2006
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004–05_Chelsea_F.C._season
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005–06_Chelsea_F.C._season
Young Jardim took an even younger Monaco side to their first L1 title in over 17 years against a side who could literally spend what they want. He also got them into the semi-finals of the CL - beating Dortmund and City in the earlier rounds. They didn’t even qualify through league spot either - they came into the competition in the qualifying rounds.
Silva wtf? Had he just won a couple on the trot at the time of this thread or something?
No point adding the likes of Pep. He won’t come here and we wouldn’t sign him.
I chose Poch.
No point adding the likes of Pep. He won’t come here and we wouldn’t sign him.
I chose Poch.
Something got mixed as Poch was the one who was miles ahead with the votes. If I had to choose really don't know, maybe Jardim, really like Nagelsmann but it's too soon.
He won Ligue 1 indeed, but still he hasnt won anything in Europe. Undermining Jose's achievement in Europe to elevate Jardim's? Klopp even got to final CL beating Madrid, thats even a bigger achievement than Jardim. He won Bundesliga twice in front of Bayern who can pick any player from other teams in Germany with ease, better eh?
My point is, looking at achievement we will never got anyone better than Jose right now. If we want someone else, make sure he's way of football align with the vision this club has going forward(if there's one tbh)
Picked Poch because he has more experience in the and Silva is somehwat unproven in my opinion. Although, I wonder how Giggs would do with a massive transfer budget given he knows the league inside out.
Strange poll results. Marco Silva seems to me like a David Moyes remake.
.It doesn’t require too much imagination
Why do so many want Silva?? In any case the baseline has to be someone who can get the team playing enjoyable footie, I'm so tired of the dull nonsense.
My hope is that the answer is at least two years away and maybe by then pochettino or jardim will have confirmed pedigree and won't have a rebuilding job on their hands
Calm your tits people, something got mixed up with the poll. All the votes changed, and the Poch votes changed to Silva (mine included).
Nice bump...
Were people accidentally hitting the Silva tab instead of Pochettino or something