Pre Season: Manchester United v Orlando Pirates

evra is not impressive too

scholes playing very deep and more as a defensive midfielder.

Foster looks sharp.
 
That's the first game of pre-season.

You honestly expect players to be 'sharp', 'fast' and 'showing their best' ??

:lol:
 
Forster - 6 safe pair of hands
Brown - 6 solid as ever
Bardsley -5 tough as nail
O'Shea - 4 did not do much. Played 45 minutes
Evra - 3 still do not impress

Giggs - 4 still on holiday
Scholes - 5 great skills and touch
richardson - 4 apart from the goal , didn't do much
Fletcher - 4 what can i say

Ole - 5 two goals. Nice to see him back
Rossi - 6 great game. Involved in two of the goals and could have got two himself. Should play more games this season

subs :
Jones - 5 solid player with good touch
Dong - 4 raw but has potential. Nearly got a goal at the end
Evans - 4 was not tested much
Miller - 4 at least better than before
Eagles - 4 did not get the ball much

considering this is the first pre-season game, good job done.
 
Forster - 6
Brown - 6
Bardsley -5
O'Shea - s
Evra - 5

Giggs - 4 s
Scholes - 5
richardson - 4
Fletcher - 4
Ole - 5
Rossi - 6
subs :
Jones - 5
Dong - 5 rd
Evans - 4
Miller - 4
Eagles - 4
 
LLMU said:
Scholes - 5 great skills and touch


:wenger:


an example of harsh ratings - since when has a player had great skills and touch and only been given a 5 - atleast say what he did wrong - very confusing
 
Giggzinho said:
:wenger:


an example of harsh ratings - since when has a player had great skills and touch and only been given a 5 - atleast say what he did wrong - very confusing

well playing at half pace and not exerting himself much.
But typical of Scholes , still provide that bit of good touch and skills to get himself out of trouble. Created the first goal.
 
LLMU said:
Forster - 6 safe pair of hands
Brown - 6 solid as ever
Bardsley -5 tough as nail
O'Shea - 4 did not do much. Played 45 minutes
Evra - 3 still do not impress

Giggs - 4 still on holiday
Scholes - 5 great skills and touch
richardson - 4 apart from the goal , didn't do much
Fletcher - 4 what can i say

Ole - 5 two goals. Nice to see him back
Rossi - 6 great game. Involved in two of the goals and could have got two himself. Should play more games this season

subs :
Jones - 5 solid player with good touch
Dong - 4 raw but has potential. Nearly got a goal at the end
Evans - 4 was not tested much
Miller - 4 at least better than before
Eagles - 4 did not get the ball much

considering this is the first pre-season game, good job done.


Spasticism ratings. Evra done well.
 
jones is better than fletcher - no doubts since fletcher was the worst player out there. jones was directing the flow of play when he came on. even telling fletcher where to position himself at one point.

great match for ole and i thought rossi played well on a shyte pitch. no one was a 4 out there other than fletcher who even though it's preseaon showed nothing. there was a nice build up near the last quarter of the match - worked by the "kids" and fletchers final ball didn't beat the first man.
o'shea didn't do much is because he played at cb and that's a good thing innit?

my MOTM ole , rossi , giggs.
 
Good result this. At least we didn't pull a Celtic. Great to see Ole get a couple.
 
Foster - 6
Brown - 6
Bardsley -6
O'Shea - 5
Evra - 5

Giggs - 6
Scholes - 5
Richardson - 5
Fletcher - 4
Ole - 7
Rossi - 6

subs :
Jones - 7
Dong - 6
Evans - 4
Miller - 4
Eagles - 4