Should DDG start in the EL semi-finals? | José disagrees with the caf

Who should be in goal for the Europa League semi-finals?

  • De Gea

    Votes: 253 46.4%

  • Romero

    Votes: 208 38.2%

  • Rooney

    Votes: 84 15.4%
  • Total voters
    545
  • Poll closed .
Pollness added!
 
VorZakone said:
You can reverse that argument though. What if Romero has an awful game and costs United the EL? I think the key difference here with other clubs is that they usually have CL qualification secured with their league ranking so they can afford playing the backup keeper. United at this point basically needs the EL to get CL football.
Click to expand...

I understand that and yes it would suck if we lose because of Romero.

But Mourinho got himself into this situation and idk if it is a good idea to just drop Romero.
 
Mourinho will stand by his promise to Romero, and rightly so.

I recall SAF saying once his biggest regret in football was dropping Jim Leighton for the cup final.
 
Hmm, for me, its carry on with Romero. I know sentimentality isn't the way to feel, but he's been a trustworthy keeper in the EL for us and I don't think he has done anything particularly bad to warrant being dropped.

Combine this with the fact De Gea has hardly been brilliant by his standards (plus I think he has one eye on Madrid this Summer), I think we should stick it out. At the very least for the first leg of the semi final anyway.

As pointed out earlier, if you change keepers out of the blue and it goes tits up, then it looks a hundred times worse than leaving a keeper in who may have a bad game.

He did little wrong tonight, I think he became a bit more nervous due to the poor defending tonight, I still think he controls his box very well from aerial threats, as good as De Gea. There was zero he could have done about the goal.
 
I think so, yes. Romero has improved a fair bit this season but most of the opposition we've been up against in Europa aren't much better than average.

He's probably already had more game time than he would've expected at the start of the season anyway.
 
De Gea is our best keeper and therefore has to start. Romero will probably get some Premier League minutes.
 
712 said:
Mourinho will stand by his promise to Romero, and rightly so.
Click to expand...

Agreed. Would be terrible man management to drop the guy now after he's done so well for us in this competition.
 
712 said:
Mourinho will stand by his promise to Romero, and rightly so.

I recall SAF saying once his biggest regret in football was dropping Jim Leighton for the cup final.
Click to expand...
Not sure about that

Leighton played the first game and was dropped for the replay. Was widely seen as the correct call
 
Les Sealey and Jim Leighton spring to mind. But that was the final. Still think it would be harsh on Romero.
 
Well DDG hasn't exactly been solid himself. Romero hasn't been that bad, and did save our skins a few times today.
 
Romero.

I guarantee if we change big Dave will make a huge mistake. That's how these things work.
 
Good man management is surely finding a way to play your best players without irking the lesser ones, not playing lesser players for fear they get annoyed?
 
I'd play Romero. He's been quality when he's called upon and yes he looks awkward but he manages to make the saves. Also, it's not like DDG has been anywhere close to his best this year.
 
Fairly sure Jose plans to play DDG later in the comp as he explained he doesn't have an EL keeper.

He's effectively using the EL to keep Romero sharp in case DDG gets an injury. Now that we're at the business end, I expect DDG to step in.
 
Snowbear said:
Romero.

I guarantee if we change big Dave will make a huge mistake. That's how these things work.
Click to expand...
Or we actually continue with Romero and he makes mistake(s) which cost us and then we have people questioning why De Gea wasn't used?

It's gonna be a difficult decision to be honest but nothing is guaranteed like you're claiming.
 
Would be harsh on Romero but DDG is the better GK & we should play our best 11.
 
De gea hasn't even been that good this season. Romero all the way.

Some of you have some serious rose tinted goggles.
 
712 said:
Mourinho will stand by his promise to Romero, and rightly so.

I recall SAF saying once his biggest regret in football was dropping Jim Leighton for the cup final.
Click to expand...

United won that final though!
 
Miscemayl said:
Fairly sure Jose plans to play DDG later in the comp as he explained he doesn't have an EL keeper.

He's effectively using the EL to keep Romero sharp in case DDG gets an injury. Now that we're at the business end, I expect DDG to step in.
Click to expand...

Yes his comments this week were a giveaway. That'll be it for Romero in the EL I expect. No reason not to give him some Premier Leagues games though, particularly as that competition is now, realistically speaking, not the priority.
 
Gbenger said:
Or we actually continue with Romero and he makes mistake(s) which cost us and then we have people questioning why De Gea wasn't used?

It's gonna be a difficult decision to be honest but nothing is guaranteed like you're claiming.
Click to expand...

I wasn't being entirely serious to be fair.

Although I guarantee that's what will happen...
 
sullydnl said:
Good man management is surely finding a way to play your best players without irking the lesser ones, not playing lesser players for fear they get annoyed?
Click to expand...

No, good management is to stick with the player who brought you to this point. If Romero wasn't trustworthy, he shouldn't have played at all but he is trustworthy so he played.
 
Snowbear said:
Romero.

I guarantee if we change big Dave will make a huge mistake. That's how these things work.
Click to expand...
We could always compromise by playing Romero in the first leg and slapping around whoever we play before reintroducing de Gea in the second leg.
 
Absolutely not, Romero's earned his chance, and it's not like De Gea's been great this season anyway.

Rado_N said:
Didn't City do this a few years back, bring Hart in for a final after Cabalerro (however it's spelt) had played all tournament? Might have been FA Cup?
Click to expand...
The cup final they lost to Wigan.
 
Why is this even a question as though our GK selection is the reason for the nerviness in the EL matches?

Romero deserves his spot in at least the next match. Maybe even through the competiton - ddg has seemed a bit absent minded at times in comparison
 
Romero for me – and not as a token or principled gesture either. He's been the better keeper this season and I'm happy to find any excuse to play him without unsettling De Gea.
 
This is the competition we need to do well in until the end of the season. Start Dave in the EL, play Romero in the league.
 
With the possibility of Rojo now missing from our back 4, I think it's within our best interest to put our best foot forward regarding our defense. DDG, Valencia, Shaw and Bailly must start imo.
 
Yes.

We need to stop making it any more difficult for ourselves than it should be. Its fecking Lyon, Ajax and Celta Vigo. If we can't beat those teams, we have no hope in the Champions League next season. So if we don't win the Europa League, I couldn't care less.

I used to watch United winning the Premier League. I'm not gonna celebrate fourth spot like its some sort of trophy. That's what Liverpool, Arsenal and the like do.
 
Why the semi and not the quarter? It's the same logic.

The final, well that's a different question.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.