You say post 2010 pep has been better than post 2010 version of jose. But yet the current jose has won many important trophies when compared to pep. People underrate Jose's work at real madrid, let us not forget it was Jose's madrid that pipped pep's greatest barca side to the la liga title. He came at chelsea and won the title and yes he had a horrendous third season but still you cannot just forget he won the title with chelsea. Yes pep also won 3 consecutive titles with Bayern but is it really that tough to do that. Then jose took over a broken manchester united while pep took over a not so broken team , yet jose managed to win trophies. So this whole theory jose is past it is becoming boring.
It's like one rule for jose and one for others aka pep and klopp