Transfer Tweets - Summer 2017 | Keep it on topic

Pogba and De Gea are both highly-valued members of the team; Martial played a similar number of minutes to Rooney/Jones last season and was publicly criticised by the manager. I'm not sure the analogy holds much water.
So was Mhikitaryan, you want to send him out on loan as well? Martial is highly rated at the club, you can be sure of that. Inter can feck off.
 
I think it a big part of it comes down to no one respecting Woody. He's not a football guy and other owners/football suits look down on him. They really should hire someone with a football background who is aggressive but measured for the transfer dealings of the club.
Just take a look at the signings he's made. People not respecting him hasn't slowed him down. He's signed some huge names and some great players.
 
Yeah. I agree. Do you think City again failed him or he needs a couple of more players to prove what everybody else knows, that he's the best there is.
I think City failed him by not getting Messi. :smirk:
 
When have the club ever actually publicly stated that they want Perisic?
When do the club ever announce they're no longer interested in a player?
People are getting way too involved in tweets.

Hm? You are confusing the word publicly with officially. Something can be public but unofficial, like our interest in Morata was very public but unofficial. Clubs often intentionally leak stuff to the press either for point scoring or to get a reaction.

So I didn't mean we put out an official statement, but we leak it to the press that we are not interest any more and it's done. Because telling Inter to feck off is one thing, but telling the world that we told Inter to feck off is quite another.
 
After Martial's preseason form thus far and especially against Real, Inter can keep their Perisic. The only player they could have is Smalling. We already have quite a few wingers in the squad with Lingard, Rashford, Mata and Mhiki (who can also play on the wing) and Martial.

If we really need to have one more, Lucas Moura could offer a lot of depth. Good player who needs more direction in being a much better player.

I think our best formation would be the one we played against City in the first half. 4-2-3-1. Yes, I'm a huge fan of the 4-3-3 but Mhiki in the No. 10 just stretches any opposition. We would score a lot of goals with Lukaku up top and Martial/ Lingard on the left and Rashford on the right.

Matic and Pogba or a Pogba and Herrera could easily hold down the fort with Lindelof and Bailly in defence.

None of the players you listed are genuine, orthodox wingers. They're all better in more central positions, which confirms why we want Perisic.
 
None of the players you listed are genuine, orthodox wingers. They're all better in more central positions, which confirms why we want Perisic.

What is a genuine orthodox winger these days? Even mid and lower table sides often play with inside forward types.
 
What is a genuine orthodox winger these days? Even mid and lower table sides often play with inside forward types.
A winger who can do something other than drift inside? Costa, Perisic, Walcott, Navas, Sterling, Ribery, Mane...all of those could go outside and no, not all of them are any good. At least I left off Zaha though!
 
A winger who can do something other than drift inside? Costa, Perisic, Walcott, Navas, Sterling, Ribery, Mane...all of those could go outside and no, not all of them are any good. At least I left off Zaha though!

I will give you Costa, Navas and Perisic the rest nah.
 
I agree with the below posters...





... we need to publicly end interest and move on. Inter obviously want to keep the player beyond the point of accepting a reasonable bid for him.

They know there's 0 chance of us paying 50m + Martial for Perisic. They are not even trying to get an actual deal out of this. They are seeing our persistence for Perisic as interference that is unsettling their player and are responding in kind by involving Martial in the rumours.

Perisic has not slapped a transfer request or made any fuss. Unless that changes, we need to just back off and move to the next one.

The thing is, they would've been perfectly happy at 45mil before the FFP deadline. If us using the FFP deadline as leverage was so distasteful to them, then just say Perisic isn't moving for any price and stop trying to unsettle Martial to try to get back at us. Stop trying to up the ante & create more bad blood. I hope the 2 sides are adult enough to do that, but it seems the current modus operandi is to annoy teams via the press. Heck, it''s quite possible that this whole brouhaha is just a press fantasy conjured to sell papers/generate clicks.

As it stands, I'd rather just look elsewhere. As noted above, it's obvious Inter doesn't want to deal, so let's look at other options. Heck, let's all just re-evaluate the needs for the upcoming season, since a lot of the planning really hinged on Griezmann in the first place. At this point, I wouldn't be surprised to just add someone like Renato Sanches or a LB and stand pat until January.
 
I think it a big part of it comes down to no one respecting Woody. He's not a football guy and other owners/football suits look down on him. They really should hire someone with a football background who is aggressive but measured for the transfer dealings of the club.

Except football is still a business. negotiations, budgets, buying and selling etc- it needs business people.

Having a 'football guy' in charge of a business would be utterly insane.
 
Except football is still a business. negotiations, budgets, buying and selling etc- it needs business people.

Having a 'football guy' in charge of a business would be utterly insane.

This.

Ed, doesn't pick the players, and he doesn't work alone. Mourinho selects his list, a team (including football types) will sit down and discuss values, based on the player, and our need for them. Ed will then start negotiations with that club, he's the money man, that his job. He knows our limits, not just for the initial purchase, but including the wages, and potential add ons. He'll weigh that against any increase in earnings if we meet the parameters to be paying those add ons and so on and so on.

He is exactly what is needed in that role, a tough negotiator, who knows the finances of the club inside out. Not a football man, who doesn't necessarily understand the limits, or have the skills for multi million pound negotiations.
 
They are very good opposition fans on here, and the more the merrier.

But when your sole reason of being on a rival forum is to just pick silly arguments, one needs a serious look at their priorities. The only thing he does now is derail any thread he enters.

No way Glastonspur should be banned. He's got over 10,000 posts on the caf - as big a United supporter as any of us :)
 
This is madness. Get someone from other leagues for feck's sake. Why Sigurdsson?
 
Hm? You are confusing the word publicly with officially. Something can be public but unofficial, like our interest in Morata was very public but unofficial. Clubs often intentionally leak stuff to the press either for point scoring or to get a reaction.

So I didn't mean we put out an official statement, but we leak it to the press that we are not interest any more and it's done. Because telling Inter to feck off is one thing, but telling the world that we told Inter to feck off is quite another.

How many times have we been linked to certain Porto players? Is that link coming from United every summer?
We get linked a lot to players every summer, do the club have to deny every bit of speculation? seems Inter are the mouth piece with regard to Perisic, so maybe they need to shut up if they're so desperate to keep him.

Our interest in Morata was discussed by Jose at a press conference. That was both offical and very public. So maybe you're the one getting confused.
 
He's worth the world to Swansea, they scored 45 goals in PL last season and he was directly involved in 23 of them.

Can't blame PL clubs wanting 50M. for a player wanting to move to a another PL club. Man City deal for Walker has kinda set a benchmark for this window.
 
He's worth the world to Swansea, they scored 45 goals in PL last season and he was directly involved in 23 of them.

I know but it's still a crazy fee to be honest.
 
Both have been regulars for a team that's challenged for the last two titles and been the best team in England over the last 2 years combined

Sigurdsson scores a few free kicks

If you say he only scores a few free kicks then surely you know little about football.. English players are overrated, last Euro showed it when they couldn't even won Iceland!
 
If you say he only scores a few free kicks then surely you know little about football.. English players are overrated, last Euro showed it when they couldn't even won Iceland!
I mean you aren't really helping your case by sticking to the "they're English so obviously shit" stance.
 
I thought CBJ was class under Van Gaal. His crossing was impressive. Would prefer a loan with this one.


If I was him I'd leave. No better club to develop at. Mourinho doesn't seem to rate him. It'd be a shame, I think he'd be a a good player for us. He was decent when he got a chance from LvG.