Living up to the tagline as ever.
There are few players less likely to leave us than Welbeck. This is pure speculative bollocks.
Who are you again? Im entitled to my opinion. He doesnt cut it for me sorry
Twitter Discussion
- Thread starter Raoul
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
- Status
Who are you again? Im entitled to my opinion. He doesnt cut it for me sorry
I highly doubt its true, and where would he go anyway? He's not good enough for a top club. Can't imagine Chelsea or somebody trying to sign him
So United are not a top club?
There are many clubs who would like to sign him.
I bet you that there aren't
What does who he is have anything to do with it?
You're ridiculously wrong about Welbeck.
journos know there will be a lot of transfer activity,do they ll simply link each squad member with a transfer. If we are to believe them we ll need to replace 10-15 players next season(de gea,Rafael,evra,Río,vidic,smalling,fletcher,cleverley,nani,welbeck,rvp,hernandes,giggs were all linked with leaving the club).
There's absolutely no reason to sell him whatsoever, unless he wants to leave.
I highly doubt it is true but I was thinking about it at the start of the season that Welbeck could actually have done with or still do with another loan. He is very talented and with consistent game time as the main man up front I am sure he would be scoring 15+ goals for a Tottenham, Everton or Arsenal. If it was just about his development a move away would be best for him like Sturridge. As it is here I don't see him ever nailing down a spot up front. He'll continually be used all over the place up front and never get a long enough run to establish himself as a top striker. Something I think he is capable of. As it is though he'll always be the back-up option. If we got rid of RvP and Hernandez I don't see Welbeck being trusted to step up and another big striker would be brought in. As you say leaving would likely be good for him but awful for us. He's a big United lad though so I highly doubt he'll think about leaving.
He came through our youth academy. Only reason he's here. United wouldn't try and sign him if he'd come up through another clubs.
FFS.I'll be gutted if he goes. He's a great squad player and a local lad, it will be strange if he want's to leave.
I doubt that.
But yes, this is bollocks. And it astounds me how underrated he's here by some.
It would be another signal that the players don't want to play under Moyes. If that's the case and we choose Moyes over loyal servants of the club, I'm gonna cry.
You think he's good enough for Utd to try sign if he belonged to some other club?
That's not the point, who knows? Would we have went after Butt, P.Neville, Evans, Cleverley, Fletcher to name but a few? The point is, like Welbeck they came through the system and have had a very successful career, we didn't have to go after them, we already had them.
There has been loads of youth players who have left the club and went on to have successful careers. Welbeck has always been in or around the first team, he's still only 23 and is a very good squad player. He's a full international and will most likely be heading to the World Cup.
Against Bayern he was one of the best players over both legs, and have played well when played in his natural position this season.
Wouldn't surprise me in the least if the likes of Welbeck and Hernandez moved on.
Ive said to people on here before that the problem with moyes and the players runs far deeper than you think.
People assume hes moving on dead wood or ageing players ala vidic, Rio, etc. You will be surprised at some who will go simply down to the manager.
Woodward will not know what has hit him if he sticks with this impostor. Not only will Rio, vidic, and evra go. Add Carrick, fletcher, welbeck, rvp and Hernandez to your list.
People assume hes moving on dead wood or ageing players ala vidic, Rio, etc. You will be surprised at some who will go simply down to the manager.
Woodward will not know what has hit him if he sticks with this impostor. Not only will Rio, vidic, and evra go. Add Carrick, fletcher, welbeck, rvp and Hernandez to your list.
Hernandez I totally understand but why Welbeck?
That said, as I've said before on here, If welbeck wants to become the best player he can be, he'l need to leave us. I seriously hope its not a permanent move away but kind of a Lukaku to Everton thing for a year, 1 full season of PL football at Everton as a striker and he'l become a top player I reckon. Unfortunately, I dont see a loan deal happening at all and understandably so perhaps.
Ok.
I'd imagine both of them want to be lead players rather than bit part actors. They're both in their prime years now, so it shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone if they left - especially since we're in transition and neither look like they are going to see more action in the future with Moyes.
Yeah, I can understand that. Fact is though, Welbeck atm isnt good enough to be the lead striker at a Manchester United and I think he knows that. But he has all the tools to be one which is why I'd much rather he had a loan at Everton than leave the club. I really have high hopes from the lad, he'l be a top player
Spot on.
I've often said, Welbeck would likely always have a role at the club, but probably not as a nailed on regular.
I suspect one issue is his England place. Forwards, more than any other international position, get picked on form. Hard to hit form when you're playing sporadically and in umpteen different positions. He probably realises this and I always suspected that at some point he might want to go.
It's a shame if he leaves but the reality is he won't get in before Rooney or RVP upfront and he isn't a natural wide player. If we get a big fee it might benefit all parties.
Losing Welbeck would scar deeper than anything else so far this season.
Yeah, I can understand that. Fact is though, Welbeck atm isnt good enough to be the lead striker at a Manchester United and I think he knows that. But he has all the tools to be one which is why I'd much rather he had a loan at Everton than leave the club. I really have high hopes from the lad, he'l be a top player
I don't see why he would want to go on loan when a good side might come in and commit good money for him to show he can be a regular long term, rather than slotted in for a season.
And he's not a 19 year old - I personally think that if he were going to kick on to the level he needs to it would have happened by now or at least looked like it might.
As it is, if and when Rooney or RVP move on, the club will likely want a top class player upfront to lead the line - as most of the best sides do.
I think it's clear he isn't going to be a regular starter upfront. If he's happy with that, then great, if not then It's not fair to hold the player back.
Last edited:
The news is bs. And he is criminally underrated by almost all in football, not just fans but also pundits. And although we will never find out if he would stay with us even if we are relegated because we probably wont ever be, he is a massive fan and so I think he would stay. He is a local lad, has grown at united. There are several video clips of him where his passion for united clearly shows. Genuine passion. He would stay. I think there have been several players who stayed with their clubs even through relegation. Welbeck is one of those kind who would do so. Take this with a pinch of salt. We really cannot decide how much he loves the club and whether he would stay through relegation. This is just what I feel he would do.
Remember when Anderson said lots of players wanted to leave because of Moyes? It's getting truer and truer. Apparently we're just going to let Moyes tear the club to shreds because we're too proud to sack the lame bastard
Why?
Moyes likes Welbeck, wont be leaving
Yeah I agree.
I'm hoping its bullshit because it'd piss me off too much.
I think signing RVP has gotten in the way of his development as a striker. He was coming along nicely in the 2011-12 season. Although he played quite a number of matches last season, he played more on the wings than upfront (where could I find stats for this?). But playing him like that has aided in his overall development. He has grown into a tactical role but his development as a striker has certainly faltered.Yeah, I can understand that. Fact is though, Welbeck atm isnt good enough to be the lead striker at a Manchester United and I think he knows that. But he has all the tools to be one which is why I'd much rather he had a loan at Everton than leave the club. I really have high hopes from the lad, he'l be a top player
Yeah - let's turn this into another "lets sack Moyes" issue.
If he wants to go its because he wants more games, in his preferred position.
I suspect the vast majority of managers would pick Rooney or RVP upfront over Welbeck.
Fact is the club is in transition and players will be coming in, possibly top players in sons positions. Some players will realise they won't be regulars. It's as simple as that.
Welbeck can go, he's a squad player who falls over a lot. Not a big loss
I can’t imagine Rooney on the bench in this game. He’s ready or not, I will be surprised if he doesn’t start.
I expect a tough game. They will be on fire, we will be “trying” to get something out of this one.
I expect a tough game. They will be on fire, we will be “trying” to get something out of this one.
Surely depends on what the player wants? I think if he wanted to go and Moyes can't guarantee him first team football he'll be away. Especially if the price is right.
No sense in having unhappy players.
No white-text? Don't you think that you are being a tad too harsh?
Eventually yes, lots of players are kept for a while after they ask to leave
No
You'd have to pay £10m+ to get a squad player of Welbeck's quality and versatility who will burst a bollock for us. So I'm glad you're not in charge of the profit and loss column.
He's a local lad and we're a huge club. Am pretty sure he'd be fine with a loan spell at say Everton for a year if he can come back a much better player capable of starting for us regularly.
That cant be an excuse though. That comes with being at a top club, you'l always have top players as competition. He's done well though, whenever he's played. What he needs now is a season as striker, no fecking about and I dont see it happening here.
The news is bs. And he is criminally underrated by almost all in football, not just fans but also pundits. And although we will never find out if he would stay with us even if we are relegated because we probably wont ever be, he is a massive fan and so I think he would stay. He is a local lad, has grown at united. There are several video clips of him where his passion for united clearly shows. Genuine passion. He would stay. I think there have been several players who stayed with their clubs even through relegation. Welbeck is one of those kind who would do so. Take this with a pinch of salt. We really cannot decide how much he loves the club and whether he would stay through relegation. This is just what I feel he would do.
Yeah fair enough. Its all hypothetical so cant really say for sure either ways.
It probably is too harsh but the ridiculous over-rating of the lad forces a dichotomy of language. In truth he's a decent squad player/rotation option but around here that description isn't good enough or acceptable, so instead he's "brilliant" or "fantastic" or "hey look here's a stat that proves he's better than Messi", and I think that people who disagree with that almost feel obliged to be perhaps overly harsh as a result.
- Status