Would an all time Scotland XI beat an all time England XI

[surf]

I'd back England. With Shilton (or Banks) in goal, Rio and Moore at centreback, and midfield of Edwards, Robson, Charlton, they'd have a colossal spine. Scotland's strikers (Law, Dalglish) might be better than England's.

 

[acnumber9]

Then again an all time Englan XI with the likes of Banks, Moore, Charlton, Greaves, Edwards, Hoddle, Robson, Shearer, Linekar, Gascoigne, Beckham, Barnes and so on would give 'em a game and a half.

For Scotland, how bout McCoist, and Colin Hendry? Both great players in their day.

Barnes was truly awful at international level. He'd get nowhere near an all time England eleven.

 

[Floyd]

I am neither.
What are you, the humour police? I took you for an American. Sorry.

Now THAT is an insult when it comes to football (sorry, soccer). Especially on the Caf.

Apology accepted mind.

 

[FranklyVulgar]

I reckon the scots would do them. More steel, more flair and better strikers.

Still it would be epic and too close to call i think.