Luis Nani | 2012/13 Performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah it's the same with Young to be fair, Valencia gets more leeway because he just gets on with his job.

Valencia hasn't really needed any leeway up till now, he's been generally excellent.

His modest way about him, the thing about firing his agent, his hard work and selflessness have certainly bought him a fair few poor games as far as I'm concerned, though my patience is starting to run out... hopefully this won't further damage his confidence, as I know for a fact that he hangs on my every word.
 
I wouldn't read too much into him not being in the Madrid squad by the way. It was never a game in which he was going to be used. Just look at the way we set up with Rooney on the wing and Jones & Carrick in the middle. Even the substitutions were all about keeping it closed at the back, Anderson on instead of Hernandez etc. Considering he's hardly played, SAF was never gonna use him in Madrid.

You can bet your life he'll be in the squad for the home leg though, when we might just need a game changer to come off the bench.
 
all you lads telling nani to put pen to whatever contract is being offered...the next time you ask a raise from your manager or client, i hope they tell you to fookin buckle down and work hard to have a future while at the same time your co-worker is on a larger wedge providing feck all quality.

I assume most of us would do that regardless, and those focussing on what other people are earning rather than focusing on their own performance generally aren't going to be the kind of employees that are going to get big raises.
 
It's hardly an endearing quality, is it? You get your own house in order first.

It wasn't directed at Nani by the way, I think it's complete bollocks invented by the media and latched onto by strange people who hate Young.
 
I assume most of us would do that regardless, and those focussing on what other people are earning rather than focusing on their own performance generally aren't going to be the kind of employees that are going to get big raises.

those aren't mutually exclusive actions. One can work hard as well as have a keen idea of what his value is in comparison to those who produce less and have subpar quality. And on the contrary, if you never ask/make your case for big wages, rarely in many industries is it just gifted to you. why leave money on the table?

I worked two summers on a trading desk and it is very similar to football in that all-in comp is a massive topic between various traders/associates and comes up all the fecking time. And just like football it is pretty easy to assess value since your P/L is there for all to see.

Industries like football it is less about the money in your pocket as it is a signifier of value/worth. If i were nani, i would demand a minimum of 25% above young and have that extra wedge be donated to manchester children's hospital.
 
Sadly I could see Nani as the kind of player that would be tempted by the money offered in Russia. I can't see him getting a better offer from the main European leagues, so I'm not worried about him leaving for Spain, Italy or Germany. But quite a few top Portuguese players don't seem to mind going to Russia.
 
Sadly I could see Nani as the kind of player that would be tempted by the money offered in Russia. I can't see him getting a better offer from the main European leagues, so I'm not worried about him leaving for Spain, Italy or Germany. But quite a few top Portuguese players don't seem to mind going to Russia.

You think? Nani still talks about becoming one of the best in the World, often. He can't become that in Russia. For my money he'll end up at Juventus or the like if he does leave United.
 
I probably phrased that poorly and my Dad would give me a slap if he read that because it could easily apply to him! What I meant was if you've got an employee complaining about what someone else is getting paid all the time it's not going to endear you to the man in charge of the wages, if you now what I mean? I wasn't suggesting those who complain about others' wages aren't hard-working.
 
Sadly I could see Nani as the kind of player that would be tempted by the money offered in Russia. I can't see him getting a better offer from the main European leagues, so I'm not worried about him leaving for Spain, Italy or Germany. But quite a few top Portuguese players don't seem to mind going to Russia.

i'm not sure. Wasn't there a story that zenit wanted to negotiate with nani but nani turned off his mobile as he had zero interest in going to zenit? I think the story was if he had to go to zenit he wanted massive compenstation in terms of wages to offset the lower competition/prestige that a move to russia would offer and it was clearly a number that zenit would not pay and nani probably knew that zenit wouldn't pay.
 
I probably phrased that poorly and my Dad would give me a slap if he read that because it could easily apply to him! What I meant was if you've got an employee complaining about what someone else is getting paid all the time it's not going to endear you to the man in charge of the wages, if you now what I mean? I wasn't suggesting those who complain about others' wages aren't hard-working.

think it is more than just the money mate.

don't think he is happy here.
 
i'm not sure. Wasn't there a story that zenit wanted to negotiate with nani but nani turned off his mobile as he had zero interest in going to zenit? I think the story was if he had to go to zenit he wanted massive compenstation in terms of wages to offset the lower competition/prestige that a move to russia would offer and it was clearly a number that zenit would not pay and nani probably knew that zenit wouldn't pay.

I remember reading the story in the Mirror about this.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/transfer-news/nani-threatens-to-run-down-his-contract-1313620

At one point, the 25-year-old turned off his mobile phone so that he could not be contacted.

A source close to the player said: “It wasn’t an accident that Nani was incommunicado. He told his agent to ask for silly money if Zenit wanted to talk. He expected them to turn him down flat, but they still wanted to talk.

“In the end, Nani turned off his phone and told people he was with at the time not to divulge his whereabouts if anyone called them.
 
You think? Nani still talks about becoming one of the best in the World, often. He can't become that in Russia. For my money he'll end up at Juventus or the like if he does leave United.

In which case I think he'll be better off here. The fact he hasn't signed a new deal and that i can't see clubs like Juve matching he current wages, make me think he might be tempted by the money in Russia. Veloso, Neto, Alves and Danny all play in Russia and Ukraine, so it doesn't seem like it's that big of a deal to the Portuguese national set up. 4 of their national team players are in Turkey.

I'm not saying he will go there, it's just a much greater possibility than if virtually all our bigger name players were in a similar position.
 
I probably phrased that poorly and my Dad would give me a slap if he read that because it could easily apply to him! What I meant was if you've got an employee complaining about what someone else is getting paid all the time it's not going to endear you to the man in charge of the wages, if you now what I mean? I wasn't suggesting those who complain about others' wages aren't hard-working.

Oh yeah, in that context I defintely get your point.
 
In which case I think he'll be better off here. The fact he hasn't signed a new deal and that i can't see clubs like Juve matching he current wages, make me think he might be tempted by the money in Russia. Veloso, Neto, Alves and Danny all play in Russia and Ukraine, so it doesn't seem like it's that big of a deal to the Portuguese national set up. 4 of their national team players are in Turkey.

I'm not saying he will go there, it's just a much greater possibility than if virtually all our bigger name players were in a similar position.

I doubt it's just the money here that is the problem. Maybe he just wants to join a club that puts less emphasis on the defensive side of being a winger (a team that doesn't set up in 4-4-2 maybe) and where, like with his country, he'll be a nailed on starter.

I can certainly see why Nani might think he'd be better off elsewhere.
 
I doubt it's just the money here that is the problem. Maybe he just wants to join a club that puts less emphasis on the defensive side of being a winger (a team that doesn't set up in 4-4-2 maybe) and where, like with his country, he'll be a nailed on starter.

I can certainly see why Nani might think he'd be better off elsewhere.

What you say makes sense, but I'm still think it's odd he wasn't tied down to a new deal in the summer. He played plenty of games and surely it would have been in our interest to get him signed up. It's rare to let a player enter the last 2 years of their deal. I'm sure talks would have held place in the summer and before. Given he was playing a lot back then and nothing seems to have happened it makes me think money could be an issue. If it was based on this season alone, I would say he'd want to leave for football reasons. But, as I said, I think talks would have started long ago, when he playing and fit.
 
Is Nani any more inconsistent than Valencia? Or is just a case of Nani being held to a higher standard than Valencia?
 
I wouldn't read too much into him not being in the Madrid squad by the way. It was never a game in which he was going to be used. Just look at the way we set up with Rooney on the wing and Jones & Carrick in the middle. Even the substitutions were all about keeping it closed at the back, Anderson on instead of Hernandez etc. Considering he's hardly played, SAF was never gonna use him in Madrid.

You can bet your life he'll be in the squad for the home leg though, when we might just need a game changer to come off the bench.

I doubt Nani feels the same way, I'd guess he'll be completely pissed off at not featuring in the biggest game of the season.

He's never been my type of player, despite his obvious ability. His attitude often gets likened to Ronaldo, which I just don't get. Yes they both have a high opinion of themselves, but Ronaldo just had a fierce determination to win, where as Nani has always been about himself, he's always looking to create 'his' moment.

The fact is, we haven't really missed him this season, or certainly not to the extent you might expect. I think that says a lot.
 
I doubt Nani feels the same way, I'd guess he'll be completely pissed off at not featuring in the biggest game of the season.

Totally agree.

The fact is, we haven't really missed him this season, or certainly not to the extent you might expect. I think that says a lot.

Is this really true? I think we've been crying out for an in-form winger, whether it be Nani, Young, Valencia or Giggs.
 
Valencia was highly consistent up until this season. In fact, he's still consistently... unfortunately consistently shite.

But how do you measure consistency then? Since 2009 to the start of this season I am sure Nani has more assists and more goals than Valencia so why is one considered consistent and the other inconsistent?
 
.Is this really true? I think we've been crying out for an in-form winger, whether it be Nani, Young, Valencia or Giggs.

It makes you wonder about the general quality of our wingers when despite not one of them being particularly good we can still dominate a league and score plenty of goals.

It would be a boost though if just one of them could start performing, but given the reverence Nani was held in 18 months ago (plenty would say world class) I don't think his absence has left a world class hole.
 
But how do you measure consistency then? Since 2009 to the start of this season I am sure Nani has more assists and more goals than Valencia so why is one considered consistent and the other inconsistent?

Well if so then I guess he's not less consistent. It's a good question actually, I dunno, I guess you'd have to look at how they're clustered. Theoretically Nani could have more but they could all be over a couple of months in 09...

Also, I'm not just talking about goals and assists. My impression of the two - let's be generous and say when in form - is that Valencia is pretty predictable but almost always does his thing well; whereas Nani is highly unpredictable and capable of magic, but often makes the wrong choice or tries something very hard that doesn't come off.
 
It makes you wonder about the general quality of our wingers when despite not one of them being particularly good we can still dominate a league and score plenty of goals.

It would be a boost though if just one of them could start performing, but given the reverence Nani was held in 18 months ago (plenty would say world class) I don't think his absence has left a world class hole.

Giggs has been performing, on the wing as well as in CM.
 
Well if so then I guess he's not less consistent. It's a good question actually, I dunno, I guess you'd have to look at how they're clustered. Theoretically Nani could have more but they could all be over a couple of months in 09...

Also, I'm not just talking about goals and assists. My impression of the two - let's be generous and say when in form - is that Valencia is pretty predictable but almost always does his thing well; whereas Nani is highly unpredictable and capable of magic, but often makes the wrong choice or tries something very hard that doesn't come off.

I don't think it's a case of Nani making a wrong choice, it's just that the thing's he tries are harder to execute when compared to Valencia who knows his limitations and sticks to it. Take their crossing techniques for instance. Valencia's crosses are generally put into a dangerous area rather than trying to pick out someone in particular whereas Nani often tries to be precise with his crosses.

Nani is simply held to a higher standard because he is the more talented of the two. There is no other explanation as to why the player with the higher productivity is considered as inconsistent

One of my favourite Nani assists is his cross to Rooney in a game against Villa (was the game where VDS got an assist as well). Anyone have a video for that one?
 
It's not just that he tries the harder thing. That's a good explanation for the hit-and-miss nature of someone like Giggsy's play.

Nani makes the wrong choice half the time. He dribbles when he should pass, he shoots when he should dribble, etc. He just doesn't have a great football brain, he's an instinctive player.
 
It would be interesting what does he think about those fans booing him recently?

It's ridiculous how football fans can be idiots, and how easily they forget how much he meant to us over last two or three seasons(not counting this season of course).

Valencia is having mare of season, and yet they boo Nani who struggled with that injury this season and even after good game can't get start in next game, and still probably did more than Valencia did for whole season so far.
 
When was he booed? Worst I can remember is a few murmurs of discontent when he slowed down our play a couple of times.
 
He was booed a lot recently, don't know how you missed it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.