bosnian_red
Worst scout to ever exist
I'd say the reason he left is because Oscar is faster, younger, a great player already and is more direct, and better defensively as Mourinho said. Mata won their player of the year for the last 2 years though, which shows how good he is when he's used properly. He's obviously a world class player, and to be honest, has shown more in that position then Rooney has. Rooney's best seasons for me always came when he was up top, and he was only truly world class as a #10 in the second half of 2010/11. I'm one of his biggest fans on here, and I think he's a great player, one of the best strikers in the world in fact, but when playing in the hole, he just lacks the ability on the ball, or the touch to consistently unlock defences.I think Rooney's better there. Comfortably so even. If Mata was as amazing there as people like to think, he'd be playing there every week at the moment, for Chelsea.
I do think we need to change our system and go back to Rooney/Mata (or whoever plays there) being deeper though. Even our only half decent run of form this season coincided with Rooney dropping deeper for 5 or 6 games. The only game we've looked half decent in since then was when Kagawa played behind a main striker. It's not exactly a coincidence. Shit midfield, play playmaker ahead of them, midfield becomes less shit.
See this is wherein the point and problem lies though. Even IF Mata is better than Rooney...in fact, lets say for arguments sake that he is, buying him hasn't solved the problem at all. The problem was never that we don't have anyone good enough to play there, it's that we don't play anyone there at all. Signing Mata has actually just made that problem worse.
At the moment, the most tangable effect of playing Mata is that Januzaj doesn't, and that isn't a good thing.
This was my concern when we signed him, but everyone I spoke with was convinced he was being signed to play behind the main striker. I don't get why people presumed we'd do this. Everything about how we've set up this season suggested that was never going to happen...and it hasn't.
I agree with the rest though. Its painfully obvious what our problem has been for the last 6-7 years and its shocking that we've continuously ignored it. Even with our shit midfield, its obvious to anyone who knows the slightest bit about football how to make do with it. Put someone like Mata, Kagawa or push Rooney further back in front of the midfielders so they don't play as forwards actually, and help control the game, make us more compact but also more comfortable and fluid going forward. Moyes has gotten it all wrong though when it comes to tactics this season.
Now we're just too top heavy and have loads of world class players we can't drop, although under the current style they can't play well together, and we just have an unbalanced side. In fact nobody can play well in the current style bar Valencia, but that's a different discussion. It was the same problem last season with Shinji, he was clearly a very talented player and one of the smartest players on the ball, but we couldn't put him on the left then have somebody like Valencia on the right. I do think Kagawa, if we used him properly, would have been good enough to become a class player for us, but Moyes clearly didn't like him so signed Mata. Now since we have him, he should start all the time and he's that good IMO that we can build the team around him, have Januzaj on one of the wings, and put one of Rooney/RVP up front, and then somebody else on the other wing. For the good of us overall, we do have to get rid of one of the strikers I think. Whether that is Rooney or Van Persie, up to whatever manager is in charge come the summer, but we shouldn't be starting with both of them every game. Regardless of who we bought in January, I had a bit of a feeling that for the best of the club, as weird as it sounds, that we should have got rid of one of them. Both world class players, but for the money we can sell them for, we can replace them with world class players playing in their proper positions instead of trying to shoehorn them into the team.
I think Fergie realized this too, because of how he dealt with Rooney, and how he was integrating Kagawa into the team but since Moyes has come, Rooney pretty much made the manager his bitch who will do anything he asks, and always play him there regardless of who else is at the club.
Anyway, going forward, we should plan on playing something like:
RVP/Rooney
??? Mata Januzaj
??? ???
The left sided player can be Kagawa in the right system, unlikely though so probably a new player, and we absolutely need 2 new midfielders, and have overlapping fullbacks as we do now, but I just can't see this, or any type of fluid, successful system that gets the best out of our players unless we get a new manager in.??? Mata Januzaj
??? ???