Distracted Steward
Full Member
I'd love to see a reasonable and logical argument to that.I think there are plenty who would disagree that it is hyperbole.
I'd love to see a reasonable and logical argument to that.I think there are plenty who would disagree that it is hyperbole.
Really? All these videos people find and put up...and no one is talking about this? Yeah, it happened in Canada, but the officer is still out of control.
I agree. That said, she posted a video on facebook confessing depression and PTSD. The cynic in me says this will be brushed off as a suicide in the official investigation.
Suicide is the official police stance. They are not budging. I don't trust the police in the US and I certainly wouldn't trust the results the 'police investigation' delivered.
From the officer's viewpoint, they can't clearly see his right hand. They show up on scene due to poor information about it being a robbery (possibly armed, as most robberies are). They contact the people there. Ricardo runs over towards the two other men, even though officers repeatedly tell him to stay where he is. He had alcohol and meth in his system, so probably not understanding everything going on. The officers contact him and tell him to keep his hands up. He drops them, they tell him again to keep his hands up...when he drops them a second time, they have no idea where that right hand is. Suddenly he raises it forwards away from his body.
With the information they had on hand, robbery, possible weapons, someone not following commands, dropping hands out of sight, then raising them back up quickly...you have a split second decision to make. Unfortunately in this case it was the wrong one.
Could it have been handled better? Absolutely so. Having both officers from the same view point doesn't give the best angle to see everything happening. Even though they started to triangulate on him (yeah, sounds militaristic doesn't it?) everything happened before they were able to.
The family settled out of court, the DA decided not to press charges based on the information on hand to the officers at the time of the incident, plus the interaction with Ricardo.
I'm well aware the backlash I'll get for offering a varying viewpoint to the "Officers bad. Officers shoot people" rhetoric, and while some cases here I hold my hands up (don't shoot?) and say the officers should be in jail for their actions, here it seems like an extremely unfortunate incident.
@Skizzo what is the justification for that Texas cop to demand she put out her smoke and get out of her car? I thought routine traffic stops were just a ticket or a warning and that you can't actually legally arrest someone for those offences.
But why shoot him ten times, if thats true? Surely once or twice is more than enough.
Because you don't shoot once or twice because you have no idea what shots will hit, or stop the threat. What if he's pulling a gun, you shoot twice and hit him in the body and he's wearing armor? Or in the left arm but he's pulling up that gun with the right? You shoot until there's no more threat.
It just happens to unfortunately look like overkill on video.
Was she arrested for the traffic violations or something else?@Skizzo what is the justification for that Texas cop to demand she put out her smoke and get out of her car? I thought routine traffic stops were just a ticket or a warning and that you can't actually legally arrest someone for those offences.
I thought so. Once you've made an illegal arrest then you're on the hook for anything that happens after that.
Because you don't shoot once or twice because you have no idea what shots will hit, or stop the threat. What if he's pulling a gun, you shoot twice and hit him in the body and he's wearing armor? Or in the left arm but he's pulling up that gun with the right? You shoot until there's no more threat.
It just happens to unfortunately look like overkill on video.
So basically shoot until the person is either dead or close to dying? Ten shots from close range, if those shots arent hitting then they really dont deserve to be cops.
Was she arrested for the traffic violations or something else?
What about the Stockton Police and their over 600 shots during that bank robbery hostage thing a while back?
She was stopped for a traffic violation. While talking to the cop he told her to put out her cigarette. She told him she was t doing my more than giving her name. He told her to get out of the car. She refused. He grabbed her, threatened with a taser. Tossed her around on the grass. I believe his official arrest was for assaulting a public servant.
Especially if she's depressed etc. I think once they start focusing more on the original stop, he'll be in trouble. I honestly don't believe anyone else did anything to her in the cell...but she was (based on what I've seen so far) put there unjustly.
So basically shoot until the person is either dead or close to dying? Ten shots from close range, if those shots arent hitting then they really dont deserve to be cops.
Doesn't it seem even a little suspicious to you that she hung in there (no pun intended) the entire weekend, had her breakfast at 7am on the day she was supposed to be released, but decided to kill herself just as she's about to be let go?
Have you shot a gun? I don't mean that condescendingly, just curious, because when your adrenaline is pumping like it would have been then, and you start shooting to (what you think) is eliminating a deadly threat....you can fire off 10 shots in a couple of seconds. There's also a natural delay in response after your brain tells you to stop shooting, and when you actually physically can.
Have you shot a gun? I don't mean that condescendingly, just curious, because when your adrenaline is pumping like it would have been then, and you start shooting to (what you think) is eliminating a deadly threat....you can fire off 10 shots in a couple of seconds. There's also a natural delay in response after your brain tells you to stop shooting, and when you actually physically can.
That changing lanes without signalling is such a bullshit charge too. The road was probably clear and he was just looking for something to do.
Doesn't it seem even a little suspicious to you that she hung in there (no pun intended) the entire weekend, had her breakfast at 7am on the day she was supposed to be released, but decided to kill herself just as she's about to be let go?
She said he was following g her for a while too, I think.
A couple of times but never in a situation like that so wont pretend to know whats going through their minds.
I would expect that response from a layman or someone like me in that situation, not cops who are meant to be professionally trained. If they cant control their adrenaline rush, then they shouldnt be allowed to have guns anymore than a normal person would be in a sane country.
It's not a thing of not being able to control the adrenaline and just shooting over and over and over. There's an actual delay between your brain telling you to stop, and you doing it.
I've never been in a situation like that, and I hope I never am. You make a split second decision to either end a life or possibly lose yours. Either way, you come out of it a different person.
Shame about the Hayward officer today.
Definitely. No such thing as a "routine" traffic stop.
Doesn't that make you wonder how those cops who killed Tamir Rice can live with themselves? Even shooting a kid who was waving a real gun would be disturbing.
Well if for discussion sake we assume she actually did kill herself then all logic goes out the window. Not that people who suffer from depression are out of control but It makes it difficult to make sense out of her actions.Doesn't it seem even a little suspicious to you that she hung in there (no pun intended) the entire weekend, had her breakfast at 7am on the day she was supposed to be released, but decided to kill herself just as she's about to be let go?
robot cops are the answerA couple of times but never in a situation like that so wont pretend to know whats going through their minds.
I would expect that response from a layman or someone like me in that situation, not cops who are meant to be professionally trained. If they cant control their adrenaline rush, then they shouldnt be allowed to have guns anymore than a normal person would be in a sane country.
She said he was following g her for a while too, I think.
Honestly, I wouldn't even start to try and understand what kind of mental place she was in. We are coming from different perspectives too, which I think may skew us slightly. as of what I've seen and heard so far, I think she took her own life. I hope I'm not proven wrong, but I'm usually a pretty fair judge of events I think.
(Haven't been able to watch this sound on as I left my headphones, so my views are on video only.)