Yeah wouldn't be surprised if he ended up at Barca or at Arsenal's other Parent Club; City if Joe Hart has his eventual mental breakdown with England
David De Gea vs Wojciech Szczęsny
- Thread starter Commadus
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
- Status
Pretty telling this. Hart is a good keeper, but all three are over-rated I feel.
Well, he's wrong then. i must have missed it. most certainly a mistake, just not an absolute howler. many keepers would let that go in.
All 3 are young and far from how good they can be. all 3 have massive potential though, so i dont see why you'd call them overrated when its their potential thats being judged/rated.
dont you think both De Gea and chesney have it in them to be among the best in the world?
Overrated? Considering their ages I'd say all three are rated exactly as they should be, as potential world class goalkeepers.
He is the one who thinks we should have signed Craig Gordon. Ignore him
Not only signed him but he thinks Gordon is better than VDS, Reina, Hart and Cech.
Trust me, that is what everyone said when someone said this to them. Just have one little two minute conversation with Pondlife and you'll see why.
Wow. I'd rather not have the conversation then.
Aren't you guys confusing Maroon Pondlife with Frankly Vulgar?
Unless there's 2 people that believe Gordon is the best 'keeper in the Premier League.
EDIT: Never mind. I've just checked the Gordon thread and it is indeed both of them that share that opinion. I bet they're both Scottish.
FV is a Barca fan and Messi fanboi.
Frank's a decent poster even with his foibles, pondlife is about right.
Halfway through the season, how do u rate both goalkeeper's performances so far?
Haven't seen that many Arsenal games.
de gea - pretty shit
Szczęsny - pretty good
Szczęsny - pretty good
Hart>Szczesny>De Gea
Szzczhzczesney has been decent at best this season. Better than de Gea, but not by that much - he's cost them 3 points more than once this season by dropping a clanger (Spurs and Fulham for example)
Chesney was pretty good in the beginning of the season, but hasn't been that great right now.
Schezny isn't great but DDG is not even better than him "currently".
Yeah Szczesny's form has really gone down since the start of the season, where people were raving about him. His performances have been well below average for a while in the matches I've seen.
Not that de Gea has been any better, mind you, as he's been quite crap.
Not that de Gea has been any better, mind you, as he's been quite crap.
Some unfortunate mistakes, and high expectations combined with lack of experience have led to a challenging introduction to De Gea´s career at United. His obvious talent and amazing technique can however not be ignored. I am quite sure that he will make a major breakthrough soon, and that Szczesny from that point will appear as a unworthy comparison.
There level is the same. There are destined to be two of thee best on the planet in the next few years.
he heNaive, naive, naive.....
Why. Are they not among the greatest goalkeeper talents in the world?
De Gea has, however, in my view a much larger registry when it comes to ball handling, distribution and movement.
De Gea has, however, in my view a much larger registry when it comes to ball handling, distribution and movement.
Szczensey (sp) began to drop off after the League Cup final, much like Arsenal.
He had howlers late last season too (Fulham, Spurs) (wow the same teams as this season too
)Szczensey (sp) began to drop off after the League Cup final, much like Arsenal.
He had howlers late last season too (Fulham, Spurs) (wow the same teams as this season too
He was fine for us earlier this season and apart from two games he has been pretty solid on the whole for us so talk of his form dipping and what not is well off the mark, the players around him on the other hand.....
It's take the Arsenal goaile over De Gea.
Both will be among the best in the world in the future. De Gea, The best. I have very high hopes from this guy..
De Gea looks like a better keeper to me, who also has more potential, however I think Sczezsny has probably been playing better than De Gea for most of the season.
Szczesny played a blinder last night. Can DDG match his performance tonight?
Szczesny looks very promising. Seems to have a much larger frame than DDG, and seems more imposing. Both will problably become greats though.
I get that same feeling too, imo both DDG and Szczesny share really top notch shot stopping ability but the main difference between the two is DDGs distribution is very impressive while Szczesny's is indifferent but Szczesny really dominates his box something DDG lacks at times
What are the stat comparison between the two for last season?
De gea had the best stop% and Szczesny had the worst.
An example of impeccable instincts coupled with breathtaking foresight.
Lovely adjectives as usual
- Status