David Moyes | West Ham in talks with him for managerial job

You're overrating the Championship. It's a poor quality league.

Look at the Huddersfield, Reading and Sheffield Wednesday squads. They're piss poor. If Sunderland kept their current side together (obviously they won't) and hired a manager like Chris Hughton they'd walk promotion. The likes of Cattermole, Larsson and Rodwell would be top players in the Championship. Bear in mind that Joey Barton was Burnley's player of the year and named in the PFA team of the season last year.

Villa probably had a bit better squad than Sunderland have now last year, though still poor. Spent a lot of money, & two managers later are mid table in the Championship, so not as easy as you think. The likes of Leeds, Derby, Sheffield Wednesday, Forest, Wolves etc all say Hi. It is a graveyard of so called big sides.
 
You're overrating the Championship. It's a poor quality league.

Look at the Huddersfield, Reading and Sheffield Wednesday squads. They're piss poor. If Sunderland kept their current side together (obviously they won't) and hired a manager like Chris Hughton they'd walk promotion. The likes of Cattermole, Larsson and Rodwell would be top players in the Championship. Bear in mind that Joey Barton was Burnley's player of the year and named in the PFA team of the season last year.
It's really not that bad at all

I've no idea if you can say it's the best 2nd tier in the world. Unless you look at money and amount of supporters each game, then it really would be

But what it is, is an extremely unforgiving and unpredictable league. Fast forward 1 year from now and I would not be shocked to see Sunderland at the very bottom or at the top of the league
 
It's really not that bad at all

I've no idea if you can say it's the best 2nd tier in the world. Unless you look at money and amount of supporters each game, then it really would be

But what it is, is an extremely unforgiving and unpredictable league. Fast forward 1 year from now and I would not be shocked to see Sunderland at the very bottom or at the top of the league

Yep look at Villa.

Wigan and Blackburn in recent years. Sunderland can easily fall in that trap. Lots of players who don't wanna be there. Owner who has had enough. Useless manager. It's just a bad combination.
 
Who is to decide that?

This is a thread to discuss David Moyes.

It seems your problem is that you were one of his blind backers and now that it's undisputed that you were wrong about it, you seem bothered that people are discussing it.

Again, if it bothers you so much, you can spare yourself the trouble of reading it. You might have supposedly moved on from his reign, but I don't think you are a sufficient authority to tell others to move on instead. I really don't get the North Korea attitude some people have with threads discussing topics they seemingly don't like. It's really that simple, staying away.

You'd think the thread title decided that, but clearly not.
 
I'm not saying they're guaranteed to go up, I'm saying their current squad is very good by Championship standards.

Wigan actually reached the play-offs the season after relegation despite having a much poorer squad than the one Sunderland have.

Since the others have told you about how competitive the championship is, I will tell you about other reasons why Sunderland should be worried about next season.

Moyes has a close to non-existent scouting network currently. People always say that Man Utd ruined him. I think Everton ruined him.
He had a very small, but very stable squad at Everton. He never had to achieve much. As long as he finished in the top half of the league, his job would be considered safe. He was never competitive in Europe, and finishing anything higher than a 5th or a 6th place was considered a bonus. He never had to make an overhaul to the squad. If one guy left, he only had to buy another guy to replace him. He did not have to scout or experiment much, So he became really complacent and lazy and stopped improving his squad.

When he came to United, he pretty much did not know who to buy except for Bale and Ronaldo. He got Felliani in, who many considered as a panic buy. The other person he was interested was Leighton Baines, and there were many left backs who were better than Baines and much younger than Patrice Evra at that time.

Even now at Sunderland, he did not who to buy, except for his former Everton and Manchester United players. The number of players who were part of his team is going to run out soon. For instance, if he intends to replace Pickford if he leaves, he cannot look at his Everton or Manchester United teams anymore, like Tim Howard, because there are not many left whom he can buy and many are too old. Moreover, there are not many players who will want to follow him to the championship. Guys like Fletcher and Coleman will not want to move a division down. He can only look for the ready-to-retire players like Jagielka. So, who is he going to buy to bolster the Sunderland squad, especially when he is going to lose around 10 to 11 players after the relegation?
 
Last edited:
Since the others have told you about how competitive the championship is, I will tell you about other reasons why Sunderland should be worried about next season.

Moyes has a close to non-existent scouting network currently. People always say that Man Utd ruined him. I think Everton ruined him.
He had a very small, but very stable squad at Everton. He never had to achieve much. As long as he finished in the top half of the league, his job would be considered safe. He was never competitive in Europe, and finishing anything higher than a 5th or a 6th place was considered a bonus. He never had to make an overhaul to the squad. If one guy left, he only had to buy another guy to replace him. He did not have to scout or experiment much, So he became really complacent and lazy and stopped improving his squad.

When he came to United, he pretty much did not know who to buy except for Bale and Ronaldo. He got Felliani in, who many considered as a panic buy. The other person he was interested was Leighton Baines, and there were many left backs who were better than Baines and much younger than Patrice Evra at that time.

Even now at Sunderland, he did not who to buy, except for his former Everton and Manchester United players. The number of players who were part of his team is going to run out soon. For instance, if he intends to replace Pickford if he leaves, he cannot look at his Everton or Manchester United teams anymore, like Tim Howard, because there are not many left whom he can buy and many are too old. Moreover, there are not many players who will want to follow him to the championship. Guys like Fletcher and Coleman will not want to move a division down. He can only look for the ready-to-retire players like Jagielka. So, who is he going to buy to bolster the Sunderland squad, especially when he is going to lose around 10 to 11 players after the relegation?
The guy is a fraud. I'm not even a United fan and I cant stand him because I can see right through all his bull
 
He's always used a tactic of being really friendly to the press, he invites them to training sessions etc. That's where the 'good man' narrative came from.
He may never get another PL job again unless a team is desperate and have no alternative.

Leaving Everton was the worst thing he ever did
 
even though I'm aware of how bad he has been for last three years, at the same time it's still surprising to me.

I keep saying to myself that he was simply out of his depth at United. then I said the same thing after Sociedad. now when it's obvious he can't even manage Sunderland, you have to wonder what can he actually do at this point.

it's almost like he forgot everything he knew about football, managing and tactics or it just became useless over night.

He hasn't i think his problem is the game has moved on and he hasn't adapted to it. He's still using the same methods that worked well at Everton over a decade ago.
 
I agree which is why I thin he is not owed anything right now and no one's gonna complain if he gets sacked but I'm making a prediction that he will bounce back to a level that he's comfortable at (mid table premier league).

Besides, he'd just have to promote with Sunderland which isn't too miraculous of a deal one would think.

Fair enough mate fair play to you for still backing him. But weren't you also optimistic a few months back that he would turn Sunderland around and keep them up?
 
You're overrating the Championship. It's a poor quality league.

Look at the Huddersfield, Reading and Sheffield Wednesday squads. They're piss poor. If Sunderland kept their current side together (obviously they won't) and hired a manager like Chris Hughton they'd walk promotion. The likes of Cattermole, Larsson and Rodwell would be top players in the Championship. Bear in mind that Joey Barton was Burnley's player of the year and named in the PFA team of the season last year.

It's harder to get up here than staying up here.

Many lesser team can pull the trick surviving premier-league, but if they go down... It'll be very hard to come up.

We haven't had the same team in a long time, most promoted teams arent here last season meaning those relegated last season failed to get back.

They have a big name down there, the likes of Newcastle, blackburn, and many others with even bigger stadium and actual trophy in their history list aren't even a sure bet for promotion.

Lets not forget that the team sunderland fails to compete with isn't united/arsenal/chelsea but hull/swansea/Boro.

It's a tough hell hole to be at
 
I've just had a flashback to them celebrating City winning the league and them mocking us. Including the flashing of the scoreboard when Aguero scored, so with that said, have that you utter cnuts :D:lol:
 
Fair enough mate fair play to you for still backing him. But weren't you also optimistic a few months back that he would turn Sunderland around and keep them up?

Yeah. Been wrong about a few things so far. Him and Januzaj but I am gonna wait it out a bit more to see what happens. In both cases though I can't blame anyone for what happens to them and they deserve whatever is coming.
 

Sportsmail had access to one of Moyes’ first sessions in the French town of Evian. The new manager put on a shadow drill where his team played against no-one and, even then, you could sense his frustration. ‘False cross’ he screamed at Patrick van Aanholt following one lazy delivery. The players looked bored as they stood still for minutes on end and that was reflected in their application; they were hardly making an effort to impress.

They probably still lost.
 
There is something fundamentally wrong when someone is a repeated failure, sacked from multiple consecutive positions for being utterly and totally shit and is rewarded with millions of Ponds for his complete lack of ability
 
People scoff at the Mail but Craig Hope has strongly criticised Moyes two days running.
 
There is something fundamentally wrong when someone is a repeated failure, sacked from multiple consecutive positions for being utterly and totally shit and is rewarded with millions of Ponds for his complete lack of ability
Football is broken is many ways, this is just one of them.
 
Eh? It's the best second tier league in Europe. Better teams have gone down and failed to bound straight back.

Not that it's even relevant to the conversation but what evidence is there for it being the "best second tier league in Europe"? It's the most popular but how can one quantify if it's any better than Serie B, Bundesliga 2. or the Segunda División in terms of quality.

Villa probably had a bit better squad than Sunderland have now last year, though still poor. Spent a lot of money, & two managers later are mid table in the Championship, so not as easy as you think. The likes of Leeds, Derby, Sheffield Wednesday, Forest, Wolves etc all say Hi. It is a graveyard of so called big sides.

Being a "big side" is irrelevant to what I'm saying though. Is Sunderland's current squad better than most if not all squads in the Championship? Clearly it is.

The right manager would have no problem getting this squad up, nor would they with the relegated Villa side. It's an irrelevant discussion as very rarely do these squads stay together after relegation but to say they're average by Championship squad standards suggests that people haven't seen many Championship squads.
 
Not that it's even relevant to the conversation but what evidence is there for it being the "best second tier league in Europe"? It's the most popular but how can one quantify if it's any better than Serie B, Bundesliga 2. or the Segunda División in terms of quality.
The quality of players, it's noticeably better.
 
You can only really make that judgement if you regularly watch matches from all of those leagues. If you have then fair enough but it seems unlikely that many people do.

Equally, there would be very few people who have heard of many players playing in the second tier of any country other than their own. It's basically just saying "players I've heard of are better than players I haven't".
 
Interesting that the article touches on staff not caring for his 'demeanour'... really not as 'nice' as he made himself to be. I recall reading similar from staff at United.
 
Interesting that the article touches on staff not caring for his 'demeanour'... really not as 'nice' as he made himself to be. I recall reading similar from staff at United.

I have no idea where this 'nice, hard working man' stuff came from. He's been a miserable feck since I've first seen him at Everton.

At United it was magnified for the world to see. He's a complete tosser (and a fecking loser who can't take responsibility, just to make it even worse) and I genuinely can't help but feel baffled by those who try to spin that nonsense even today.
 
Interesting that the article touches on staff not caring for his 'demeanour'... really not as 'nice' as he made himself to be. I recall reading similar from staff at United.

And Everton.

My favourite little line about Moyes came from Louise Taylor in The Guardian, referring to his 'carefully burnished reputation'.
 
I have no idea where this 'nice, hard working man' stuff came from. He's been a miserable feck since I've first seen him at Everton.

At United it was magnified for the world to see. He's a complete tosser and I genuinely can't help but feel baffled by those who try to spin that nonsense even today.
Repeated endlessly in the media and some fans just ate it up. I admit I never thought much of him at Everton, was just indifferent to him. /however, it was pretty clear early on at United that he was far from being 'Mr Nice Guy'. LVG had his faults, but by all accounts, he treated the staff at Carrington and OT with respect. The players may not have been crazy about him, but the staff at least never had a bad word to say about him
 
And Everton.

My favourite little line about Moyes came from Louise Taylor in The Guardian, referring to his 'carefully burnished reputation'.
That's precisely what it was.. shame on those journalists that went along with this. Being insulated from criticism hasn't actually helped the guy at all. If you never see you're doing anything wrong, then you won't be pushed to improve.

All in all, it's back fired on him imo.
 
My mate was sat across from him on a train to London this afternoon. He said a women came up to him and said 'excuse me, this is my seat'. Even gets relegated on the fecking train :lol:
 
Still can't believe 4 years on this clown was appointed United manager.

Even worse than people believing that Lazio player was 17!