I dont know, could be quite the spectacle watching Maguire hang back and cover goal while Onana goes on a mazy run up the pitch.
Maguire | he stays!
- Thread starter Zoo
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
This would be quite the sight
Good on Harry for working hard on starting the season in shape. Still hoping we’re able to shift him, of course, I think at this point it’s the best move for both parties. Salary will be a big obstacle though
Yep, he's staying for another season. We can't be looking into CB's this summer as well as every other position, and we've missed out on the Kim bloke to Bayern so expect to see Maguire starting at some point.
On the plus side, maybe a better GK will bring better performances out of him? I always felt like he was trying to overcompensate for De Gea's lack of decision making, which ultimately led him to do things he shouldn't have been doing.
On the plus side, maybe a better GK will bring better performances out of him? I always felt like he was trying to overcompensate for De Gea's lack of decision making, which ultimately led him to do things he shouldn't have been doing.
Having Onana is pointless, if you have Maguire playing in front of him. He shits himself under pressure. Please just get this guy out of the club, I'd accept 20M.
Guess they think even if they sold him they'd have to cover £100k a week in his wages and would only get £10 million for him so its better to have him as a 3rd choice CB than get an upgrade whos also going to want another £150k a week. What a mess.
4th choice CB, who cost us major goals last season, is not compatible with our style of play, and has a wage well over 200k. Gets abused because of blatant tonedeaf PR spin about "working hard".
Makes sense - we're not going to say we're expecting £35/£40m because then people would bid around £25m.
Say we want £50m, but we'd probably acccept £35m
Laughable!
Who is going to pay £50 million plus £200k+ a week wages for Harry Maguire!
Who is going to pay £50 million plus £200k+ a week wages for Harry Maguire!
Have a bit of pride and take the hint 'Arry
Not as pointless when he's the 5th choice CB
I think he’ll play less this season. He started last season as first choice, before getting replaced in the starting XI by Varane. Then he lost his first backup place to Lindelof and Shaw. So he is starting the season as fifth choice.
If Varane gets injured(which he does often), Maguire/Lindelof step into that role. Maguire got significant minutes last season, significant enough to feck up our Europa campaign.
Yeah that's what I took from it. I doubt we'd actually expect to get that much.
It gives Harry an out when under pressure, and Onana's sweeping ability means Harry can be slow off the mark without too much issues. Needs to learn to read the game a whole lot better though. There are plenty of issues that aren't related to speed and agility in his defending, and he needs to sort that out if he wants to become a competent defender at the level we need - which is a tall ask at this point.
I really hope we manage the budget well enough to bring in one or two new defenders with Jones and Bailly both set to leave. Unless Harry improves massively, I just don't see why we should play him ahead of a new guy and one of the kids.
Or he trains most of the day and has 2 breaks.
Yep and especially where we’re expected to give around 10m to Maguire to cover the difference in wages as earlier reports suggested.
So it's up to the club to sell him
We can only hope that a new GK makes a massive difference to his game so he can just focus on defending.
Spot on. Offer 40, but ask for 5 back as subsidy towards his above-market rate wages. Everyone goes away happy.
People rightly decry the pathetic fees United pull in on player sales, but then moan when the club shows a bit of derring-do. It gets very tiresome.
40 + 20% sell-on in case he gets bought by the Saudis a year into his deal seems appropriate.
The Maguire PR machine is mad. I get the feeling we will find out soon Maguire is a leaker
Fair enough. Have to admit this scenario does generate a certain amount of morbid curiosity.He is going to stay with us until he runs down his contract here.
Not exciting news but I like that we're trying to get more money for him. He's OK 5th choice defender, although he will be mostly used to win headers when opposition is bombing us with crosses.
We don't expect to actually get 50m, hasn't the signing of Mount literally in the last few weeks taught you lot anything?
Classic Loss Aversion bias. After a season of barely playing, what is his value going to be?
To be fair, if he was still anywhere near the level of the player we thought we signed, we probably would have gotten £50M.
I think he's worth easily around 30m. He could do a job at a team that suits him. But with his wages and our ability to sell do I think we'll get what he's worth? No.
Meh, same way Chelsea wanted 80m for Mount. Truth is we have some really good CBs and we could do with a different profile of a player, but Maguire would do well in a different system. He just doesn't fit current United. Doesn't mean he isn't worth say 35-45m for a different party.£50M for a 5th choice
we’re likely to play a higher line with Onana. Maguire will be finished
Jesus lads still trying to convince themselves De Gea was the issue entirely and that Harry can play better without him 
not a lot he can do if the club has a stupid valuation of him to be fair.
I think people are trolling. Maguire cannot be valued over 30m and even that is stretching the limits.
His reputation is in tatters though. Anyone buying him would have to deal with fan reaction to buying him as well.
Sounds very logical and the club are looking efficient for once.
£50m will be from a negotiation stand point like we’ve done with all our business this summer.
Hopefully it will be Spurs want him for £25m +5m and we sell him for £35+5m.
Eitherway if he stays I’m happy with him as 4th choice with Onana in goal. He won’t be that bad of a choice.
£50m will be from a negotiation stand point like we’ve done with all our business this summer.
Hopefully it will be Spurs want him for £25m +5m and we sell him for £35+5m.
Eitherway if he stays I’m happy with him as 4th choice with Onana in goal. He won’t be that bad of a choice.
can he do anything else? help with the filing or answer the phones? serve in the canteen? take the bins out, even?
I'll be fecking nervous if I see him walking up to me with the tray.
That is my worry as well.