But he's not proven British player! When online fans are more in touch with up and coming players than professional scouts, the professional scouts deserve to be sacked.
Manchester United's Chief Scout and Head of Global Scouting have left the club
- Thread starter L1nk
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
But he's not proven British player! When online fans are more in touch with up and coming players than professional scouts, the professional scouts deserve to be sacked.
Nkunku would be mad to stall his career with us.
Hahahahahaha
Excellent news and long overdue, managers have rightly paid price for their poor performance but ridiculous taken so long for more people involved in recruitment to be held accountable.
Why? They have done such a good job since 2013. 
The main issue that Lawlor and Bout had?
That was already too late. Our scouts and Ole should have persisted before the move to Leipzig. I mean we bought Pellistri due to Forlan saying he is good and that was 15 millions. But our chief scout with suggestions from a former legend couldn't persuade the board to buy him for 5 millions? Or even later, in the summer of 2019, our manager and scouts persuaded the board to greenlight Maguire and AWB, but couldn't buy Haaland? I think the truth is that they could not understand how good he was and probably thought that Rashy is a better talent.
I'm not sure why anybody thought anything else.
It was always obvious that Rangnick's signing was designed to prepare for the long-term, and to give the powers-that-be a qualified outside opinion on what changes needed to be made. Both on and off the field, as we've failed badly at both aspects for almost a decade now.
Don't get me wrong, we still would have felt he'd give us a good chance at making the top four so we'd be disappointed it looks like it won't happen. I also did have a small worry that with things not working out on the field perhaps Murtough would second-guess that remit and not listen to Rangnick's advice as much as he should have. That worry was increased with Ralf's recent comments about needing so many changes, as I thought maybe he himself felt he wasn't being listened to enough so had to take it public to try to force action. Hopefully it's the opposite and Ralf's comments are designed to prepare everyone for a significant changes, and this news about Lawlor and Bout happening so quickly afterwards does lean towards that.
We could have bought Diaz and Bruno Guiamares for ca 10m more than we spent on Sancho. Jota was 5m more expensive than Donny. Amad another weird signing.
I don't have to mention the transfers of Maguire, AWB and Pogba. 220m wasted.
Our scouts are unbelievable poor.
I don't have to mention the transfers of Maguire, AWB and Pogba. 220m wasted.
Our scouts are unbelievable poor.
Pellestri?
I would say they probably jumped before they were fired. Maybe tipped off on purpose, so by leaving they dont get the humiliation of being given the sack. Our scouting has been appalling for a while at senior level.
People as high up in the pecking order as Lawlor and Bout apparently were aren't just judged on whether individual transfers that they recommend (either to make or to stay away from) end up being correct. So people pointing out individual things like supposedly not wanting Maguire are missing the point. A broken clock is right twice a day.
These guys are in a position where they should be responsible for the scouting network as a whole, so if that is lacking then it comes back to these guys not putting in place the proper system (or at the very least not recommending the changes needed to the people who make the final decision). There's not many people out there better suited to judge whether the scouting network is lacking than Rangnick.
These guys are in a position where they should be responsible for the scouting network as a whole, so if that is lacking then it comes back to these guys not putting in place the proper system (or at the very least not recommending the changes needed to the people who make the final decision). There's not many people out there better suited to judge whether the scouting network is lacking than Rangnick.
Jumping ship before things go really bad.
Didnt RR show astonishment last week saying he was surprised he hadnt been scouted?
That window is where we started with all those reboot shit . If you didn't know by now, that was the window where all of our signings ended up as duds despite spending 150m because we had a clueless manager at the helm thinking buying passion and local would take us back to top.
On the contrary, Bruno and Sancho are still our best players.
Right, I also recall that Ole bought Sancho and Bruno too... Unless I didn't know there was a different manager during that period.
Also, that is the only window our signings were duds? Dalot, Lindelof, Bailly say hi.
No, Mark Ogden said that and he's a known bull shitter.
Forlan sold him to us, scouts didn't do much for that one
Mark Ogden was the first to call Ten Hag. He knows his onions
Before we spend £150m on Kane and he goes to shit also
What are you complaining about re: Lawlor? He joined us in 2005 and worked with Fergie all that time. Then when Ferguson and the previous Chief Scout left he then got a promotion. He'd been with the club almost 10 years by then
"Database just says 'he good'"Even a broken clock is right twice a day, we've been linked with ten Hag since the second Solskjaer got sacked, hardly sticking his neck on the line. Only journalists regarding United that actually get info from the club are Ducker, Peach and Stone. I'll refer to @Adnan's post as to why that Ogden Nkuku article is a load of shite:
Thats the rumour and why I made the comment, but I dont think we have it confirmed. Just thought it was funny timing
Lawlor is 20/20 in FM. Will miss him.
The problem at United and Rangnick actually alluded to it before the Liverpool game is that for some boneheaded reason the manager was the one leading the scouting department among other things. In fact Rangnick confirmed what used to be media talks from admittedly reliable people. When asked about what was his opinion on why United found themselves in that situation he said that the manager can't be the one responsible for everything and that other successful clubs have smart people leading the scouting, medical and recruitment.
We have already had stories about the scouting department being ignored and I could be wrong but we also heard stories about the medical department being overruled, iirc in the case of Smalling and Rashford.
Last edited:
It was discussed on a podcast a year ago about the shambles of our scouting network. Woodward paid alot of money to a company to overhaul it and we ended up with this mess.
I will see if i can find it...
It shows how much of a mess the operation is, that Nkunku wasnt even being watched this season until RR recommended him. There was a post about this in the transfer tweets thread. If and its a big IF thats true then what the hell are we paying 58 scouts to do?
£7 million was actual fee paid for Pellistri (in 2 instalments) rest is add-ons/bonuses which only happen with certain achievements
Just like Amad Diallo (19 million) people and papers always quote united transfer fees including add-ons/bonuses
Was going to make the same post.
Also, Arnold had no say in the football side of the club before this year. Why would he be in a meeting with a footballer?
That will never happen. Which person do you know will willingly demote themselves?
You'd have to hope against hope that he's told the club that this sort of archaic structure can't continue. For the faults he's been responsible for as manager, he seems to know exactly what the issues facing the club are.
I'm saying that's where the club have gone wrong already, we have someone who's going to be learning on the job in one of the most vital jobs at the club.
They are to blame, in part, for all the shortcomings. The fact that we still need to sign 6,7,8,9 or 10 players (like Ralf said), means that we wasted hundreds of millions signing the wrong players. Scouts have to pay the price too. Hope we get better replacement
Couple of issues here. 1. Arnold and or Murtough would know what went on behind the scenes with the scouting department. Whether they were on the ball or not? Looks like they were not on the ball and when Ralf made out the call, their position became untenable. If they were on the ball and if the successive managers were ignoring their advice, then they would not have left.
Agreed. At this point, we need to resurrect Stalin and have him enact a Purge. Or a Spanish Inquisition. Or a witch hunt. Or a Roman style decimation.
Or all of the above.
I hope more will follow
Nepotism and a lack of meritocracy, quite honestly. Pick only coaches and scouts that did the business on the pitch or ten years ago, their sons and brothers, and fail to hire anyone based on their competency and you're dead.
It's the exact same problem many big companies have. Stagnation and safety at high levels leads to complacency and a lack of new modern ideas at lower levels. Pretty soon you're the blockbuster video of the football world.
Rangnick is doing us a big favour here. It's about time we joined the 21st century.