No worries, I can empathise.I’m sure he’s great. And that was a mean post by me. I’m in a shitty mood after last night. Sorry.
No worries, I can empathise.I’m sure he’s great. And that was a mean post by me. I’m in a shitty mood after last night. Sorry.
That's probably why Sir Alex was there with them too. To try to combat that, if you're right.Marcus' interview helped me understand, to some extent, why we were as bad as we were yesterday. Although that in itself was a bit worrying.
He was extremely emotional, his voice cracked and nearly broke several times. Going into a final that wound up is a big no-no. In any walk of life nobody is going to produce their best if they're that emotionally on edge. The coaching staff probably tried to take the tension down a few notches but, it was evident from Marcus after the game, they clearly failed.
You also could tell from what he said that the players are paying attention to the media. That's another big no-no. He was referencing headlines, defending Ole's record. On the one hand that's positive. The players like Ole, they want to continue with him and they want to change the narrative that he's not going to take the club forward. On the other hand the fact that they're so conscious of these headlines is a problem. You can't go into games like this worrying about what people will say after. You have to play without those kind of things weighing you down. The fact the players are aware of the 'blah, blah, blah,' to quote Rashford, and its one of the first things on his mind when the game ends is a bad thing. The players need to be able to block that stuff out and focus on the game.
Everything coming out of Marcus' mouth last night makes me think that, mentally, we're not where we need to be to compete. The best teams are powered by belief. In big moments they play as if they have ice in their veins. Our side plays with too much of a monkey on its back.
How much running did he do?
Well, I could tell you a third time, but I doubt it would make a difference, since you seem to have convinced yourself this is about who gets to decide what.
Good post. Sad postHe said something about injuries since September.
I would like to say to him,
"Listen Marcus, why have you been so selfish (playing even when injured and keeping fully fit players rooted to the bench) and a detriment to the team (giving 6/10 performances game after game, and a 4/10 performance in a major European Final), when you could have stepped aside for someone who is fully fit; and even miss a large chunk of games to fully recover?"
He was the same at the World Cup in 2018, saying the same things, 'It hurts us, we're hurting' etc etc.
He was abysmal at the World Cup, and he was abysmal last night in a Final.
I'm sick and tired of his politician like interviews.
He was even sulking on the pitch during the match yesterday, when he thought Shaw had failed to pass to him and it looked like the looping ball was going to go out of play; so he spat his dummy out and gave up - only for Shaw to stop the ball from going out of play and actually headed the ball down into Rashford's path; but guess what? Because Marcus was sulking he failed to even attempt to get back onside, and the offside was called.
It's that stinking attitude from him that I cannot stand.
Well, what a good post. I would add to this, is the issue of character. Markus - these days, anyway - is a all-consumed attention seeker. A lot of philanthropists are like that. Desparate for approval, etc etc. So the stuff with Obama interview, the headlines about him feeding the children of England etc., would all be on his mind as well as the critical importance of the match, incoming headlines, Ole's future etc. The Blah Blah Blah is the issue with Rashford, that's his primary injury, after that there is the spinal injury, the shoulder, the ankle, the whatever. All these insights explain a lot. For instance, the out-of-phase dynamic with Shaw, the inattention on the pitch, the weird lapses, the non-existent decision making. Because each decision is overthought, over self-conscious and as you say, weighed down with enough baggage to fill the hold of a small cargo ship.Marcus' interview helped me understand, to some extent, why we were as bad as we were yesterday. Although that in itself was a bit worrying.
He was extremely emotional, his voice cracked and nearly broke several times. Going into a final that wound up is a big no-no. In any walk of life nobody is going to produce their best if they're that emotionally on edge. The coaching staff probably tried to take the tension down a few notches but, it was evident from Marcus after the game, they clearly failed.
You also could tell from what he said that the players are paying attention to the media. That's another big no-no. He was referencing headlines, defending Ole's record. On the one hand that's positive. The players like Ole, they want to continue with him and they want to change the narrative that he's not going to take the club forward. On the other hand the fact that they're so conscious of these headlines is a problem. You can't go into games like this worrying about what people will say after. You have to play without those kind of things weighing you down. The fact the players are aware of the 'blah, blah, blah,' to quote Rashford, and its one of the first things on his mind when the game ends is a bad thing. The players need to be able to block that stuff out and focus on the game.
Everything coming out of Marcus' mouth last night makes me think that, mentally, we're not where we need to be to compete. The best teams are powered by belief. In big moments they play as if they have ice in their veins. Our side plays with too much of a monkey on its back.
Add McTominay and Awb to that.To me only Greenwood and Cavani looked like it meant something.
Greenwood wasn't very good, but he did run himself out of gaz. He did try. He just wasn't capable of changing the outcome.
I’m sure he meant every word of his interview but after that performance (and his general performance level this season) it felt like over compensation.
Spot on.Can’t win, if he did less in his interview people would argue he doesn’t care.
Spot on.
The guy has given his all through injury (stupidly) and is clearly burnt out. I was critical of him in the heat of the moment during the final, but he clearly loves the club.
Rest and competition for his place is needed to bring the best and more consistent performances back out of him again.Without his goals and assists this season we are nowhere.
Let me preface this by saying I think Rashford would be in trouble on current form if we signed Sancho.If we took reputation and favouritism
out of it I reckon If we started this season with James or Pogba on the left and Greenwood right with Cavani/martial up top we’d be in almost exactly the same place. Top 4, deep EL run. I’m almost certain of it. It’s just we wouldn’t have to listen to how Marcus is running himself into the ground for us after yet another tight game with no work, spark or creativity. Ole shot us in the foot how many times against average teams that sat back against us this year yet he still always played him in those games. It’s crazy. Especially since January. If we’d got him out of the team since jan we’d be about 2 goals and 2 assists down I think and that’s being kind. In about 30 games. We really think nobody else in our squad is capable of those numbers while actually adding a bit of work rate and drive to the team? Ole had Pogba and James there all season and he absolutely bottled it.
Let me preface this by saying I think Rashford would be in trouble on current form if we signed Sancho.
However If we started the season with the players you mention we’d have an even more out of form Martial (in relation to Rashfords current form), an ageing Cavani and Greenwood who only hit his stride in the past 2/3 months. Then you take into account the injuries to Pogba and Martial and we see a James/Cavani/Greenwood front three. In a 60 game season relying on those three is suicide. We aren’t securing top 4 as early (if at all).
And that’s not even starting on the quality difference between Rashford and James. Yes Pogba has had a few impressive displays at left wing but going on about work rate and using him is a bit rich.
This forum always needs a scapegoat and it appears to be Marcus now. You’ve basically said Rashford has been pointless this season and all we need is a bit of hard work from Dan fecking James to have matched what he’s brought this season. There’s absolutely no way you can convince me James would’ve helped Bruno carry us though whilst Pogba was injured in the same fashion Rashford did.
we need to work on being a less toxic fanbase.
We are a team that heavily relies on moments of individual brilliance. Replacing Rashford for James does not turn us into a team capable of creating chance after chance. So over the course of the season and how we’ve played, James would not improve us. Rashford has been given playing time despite his form because he’s a match winner, and has proven over the course of the season he is invaluable to the team.James in his limited time on the pitch since he got back in has actually been more of a threat than Rashford. He’s certainly been a lot more hard working and unpredictable. Same with Pogba on the left. That’s the kind of player Cavani needs supplying him. How anyone can say this player or that player couldn’t have done more than Rashford if they were given the same amount of minutes relative to his actual performances. I don’t buy it. Rashfords fans had his numbers in the first half of the season despite his performances lacking in dynamics and intensity and then once the numbers dried up they just blamed his injuries. If we had a more ruthless manager Rashford would have been on the bench by the end of March. Dan fecking James couldn’t have done any worse in that final than Marcus.
Can’t win, if he did less in his interview people would argue he doesn’t care.
So you have gone from desperately blaming Rashford’s poor form in the last months for basically everything to trying to convince us now that without Rashford we would have done equally well.If we took reputation and favouritism
out of it I reckon If we started this season with James or Pogba on the left and Greenwood right with Cavani/martial up top we’d be in almost exactly the same place. Top 4, deep EL run. I’m almost certain of it. It’s just we wouldn’t have to listen to how Marcus is running himself into the ground for us after yet another tight game with no work, spark or creativity. Ole shot us in the foot how many times against average teams that sat back against us this year yet he still always played him in those games. It’s crazy. Especially since January. If we’d got him out of the team since jan we’d be about 2 goals and 2 assists down I think and that’s being kind. In about 30 games. We really think nobody else in our squad is capable of those numbers while actually adding a bit of work rate and drive to the team? Ole had Pogba and James there all season and he absolutely bottled it.
If only some of the 'fans' on here would think about this before posting...
Why are you so hung up if Rashford cares or not?
Believe it or not but most people use their own eyes to assess on how a footballer has performed on the pitch and not what Rashford or others say to the press / social media.
Why are you so hung up if Rashford cares or not?
Believe it or not but most people use their own eyes to assess on how a footballer has performed on the pitch and not what Rashford or others say to the press / social media.
It doesn't stack up though - because he gives an interview like that but yet on the pitch a 34yo Cavani is out-running and out-working him.
I don't want to hear any excuses about injuries either. If you're so badly injured you can't run or you can't work hard to close players down, then you should be making it clear to the manager and the coaching staff that you're not fit to play. Don't say you are and then act like you're not for 120-minutes. I can't believe any player would be 'forced' to play in the modern game, particularly one who has hardly set the world alight. Therefore, I can only assume Rashford is telling the management he is fine.
Exactly, he was completely useless in the final but oh look he's sad... That makes it ok.I find it bizarre. Does all other criticism they have come from a belief that the players they’re digging out have deliberately conspired to be awful?
“Oh now we know Rashford wasn’t trying to be terrible I’ll take it all back”
Bonkers
It adds context. The reasons make sense, he's playing through injury whilst many posters here thinks he doesn't care.
Exactly, he was completely useless in the final but oh look he's sad... That makes it ok.
We can only judge players on how they have performed on the pitch as people can only speculate with players personal circumstances and physical conditions except for the professional physios and doctors at United. IF they and the manager regard Rashford fit enough to play then why do we continue giving excuses to a certain player but unsurprisingly no one even tried to defend Lindelof with his reported injuries?
‘Marcus is travelling and we have to make a decision tomorrow if he starts or is on the bench. I don’t think he’ll play 90 minutes.’
‘I don’t pick players when we know there is a risk,’ he added.
‘There’s always a risk when you step out on to the pitch, but if the physio says it’s too much of a risk I would never pick him.
‘Now, Marcus joined in training this morning and let’s see how he reacts.
‘If there’s any risk of making this worse, I’m not going to overplay him. His back has recovered, but he’s a tough one and he wants to play, he wants to give his all for Man United.
‘We’ll listen to what he says like we did on Saturday when he came off and said it was too sore.’
100%I’m sure the other threads in the player performances section of the site will expose some rank hypocrisy too
So you have gone from desperately blaming Rashford’s poor form in the last months for basically everything to trying to convince us now that without Rashford we would have done equally well.
Yep. If I take into account how awful Martial has been all season, how awful and out of form plus injured/covid Pogba was in the first few months of the season, how out of form Greenwood was only until a few months ago and that Cavani got match fit and started contributing regularly only after a few months, and that James is not and never will be a starter, plus Martial and Cavani’s 3 match bans, then yes I can definitely see how without Rashford’s contributions especially in the first half of the season we would exactly be where we are now.
No matter how often you write it - and boy you have really been writing the same stuff for long enough now - Rashford has been our best attacking player after Bruno if we consider the whole season.
Yes we can all make up stuff how player x would have done equally well, but I prefer to judge the players on what they actually have done.
Rashford has been overplayed and Ole should have rotated more, but to just ignore that he carried us with Bruno when all our other attacking players were injured/not fit/not playing well at all is pure delusion.
Good measured post and one that might just turn out to be true.I’m sorry to say that I think Rashford’s off field activities have distracted from his focus on football.
What he has achieved off the pitch is huge, and is more important than sport - but there’s no denying that being involved in off field activities to the level he is must distract from a career which requires 100% focus if you’re going to be the absolute best.
It’s fortunate that his off field distraction is a thoroughly wholesome one, but when I see stuff like him chatting to President Obama at only 23 I do sort of feel like we’ve already lost him to something bigger.
I’m sure he meant every word of his interview but after that performance (and his general performance level this season) it felt like over compensation.
I’m sorry to say that I think Rashford’s off field activities have distracted from his focus on football.
What he has achieved off the pitch is huge, and is more important than sport - but there’s no denying that being involved in off field activities to the level he is must distract from a career which requires 100% focus if you’re going to be the absolute best.
It’s fortunate that his off field distraction is a thoroughly wholesome one, but when I see stuff like him chatting to President Obama at only 23 I do sort of feel like we’ve already lost him to something bigger.
I’m sure he meant every word of his interview but after that performance (and his general performance level this season) it felt like over compensation.