Shinji Kagawa

Status
Not open for further replies.
as promising and exciting as Kagawa has looked maybe we should wait until he has played against better opposition before we deem him as better than whoever

early days and no point in heaping unnecessary pressure

You're saying this as if he's only ever played in friendlies. He scored a double against Schalke, a goal against Leverkusen, a goal against Bayern and a goal against Arsenal, all in seasons when these teams played in the CL knockout stage. It's not like he's been doing it against no-marks in the Bundesliga and a few friendlies.
 
Nothing like building a player up! Lets wait and see eh boys, he looks a class player but lots of class players have flopped in the prem!

And to all the Bale haters, you are all crazy!! He's not in the very elite bracket but has shown more consistency than Tony V and even Nani in the last couple of years.Those that don't see that clearly have their red tinted glasses on!

Wow shit gets more and more funny
 
You could ask every football manager in the world who'd they rather have - Bale or Kawaga - and 99.99% of them would say Bale. I can say that with confidence, even having not seen much of Kawaga play.

If you believe otherwise, then it's you who is the retard.

:lol::lol::lol:
 
If you're coming in here to talk about Bale and not Kagawa, don't bother...just make a thread about Bale.
 
This thread brings all the feckwits to the yard, apparently.
 
Nothing like building a player up! Lets wait and see eh boys, he looks a class player but lots of class players have flopped in the prem!

And to all the Bale haters, you are all crazy!! He's not in the very elite bracket but has shown more consistency than Tony V and even Nani in the last couple of years.Those that don't see that clearly have their red tinted glasses on!

Bale more consistent than Valencia? Erm, no.
 
Nothing like building a player up! Lets wait and see eh boys, he looks a class player but lots of class players have flopped in the prem!

And to all the Bale haters, you are all crazy!! He's not in the very elite bracket but has shown more consistency than Tony V and even Nani in the last couple of years.Those that don't see that clearly have their red tinted glasses on!

:lol:
 
In the space of 2 hours, Kagawa has gone from being better value at 13m than Allen at 15m (see the Allen thread), to then allegedly being in the same class as Bale ... and now finally he's "a class above".

And all before he's even kicked a ball in the Prem.

Give it another 30 minutes and he'll be right up there with Messi ....

Anyhow, there I shall leave it, since he's your player and the relevant posts are no longer part of the transfers or general discussion areas.

Happy hyping fellas.

There was never a comparison to be made between Kagawa and Allen. One is a 2x league title winner and current double holder... The other is a Liverpool target

What exactly has Bale done to ensure 99% of managers would pick him? The only big difference is in their profiles in the English game. Whilst people like yourself are only just about hearing about Kagawa, Bale has been hyped up since he was 18. That doesnt mean he's not a top player or that he isnt just as good as Bale.

A couple of months ago you'd have had no idea who Jordi Alba is and would be telling us Assou Akotto is a better player
 
It's absolutely retarded what people say at times, he basically said, "I've never seen him play but there is no way he is better than Bale"
Do people even read what they say at times? How can he be so sure having never seen him play.

For what it's worth I would much rather have Kagawa than Bale, firstly because United already have 2 wingers that are better than Bale and secondly because Bale has never shown anything close to consistent form. Brilliant winger on his day but that day comes pretty rarely, and he has been shut down loads of times.

He's a complete moron. What he said wouldn't even be true if you compared Bale with Downing. It's the kind of thing that's only ever true when you compare Messi or Ronaldo to someone like Matthew Etherington.
 
There was never a comparison to be made between Kagawa and Allen. One is a 2x league title winner and current double holder... The other is a Liverpool target

What exactly has Bale done to ensure 99% of managers would pick him? The only big difference is in their profiles in the English game. Whilst people like yourself are only just about hearing about Kagawa, Bale has been hyped up since he was 18. That doesnt mean he's not a top player or that he isnt just as good as Bale.

A couple of months ago you'd have had no idea who Jordi Alba is and would be telling us Assou Akotto is a better player

To be fair to him he probably still would say Assou Akotto is a better player :lol:

It's ridiculous to even mention Allen as a comparable signing to Kagawa, because Allen is comfortably a level below Kagawa. Just wait until Kagawa shows his class this season and the press will be talking about how we turned him into such a great player, finding hidden gems in little leagues when really he has always been a quality player in one of the best leagues in the world. Like Brwned said on the last page, it's just disrespecting the other leagues when people who only watch the prem think the other leagues fall way short of it, when that is just not true. Currently I'd say the premier league is only a bit better overall than the bundesliga, and if anything the transition from the bundesliga to the Premier league would probably be the easiest transition from any of the other leagues.
 
Tony V has been the apple of the caf's eye for 6 approx months. Prior to that he had been injured and prior to that average. Bale has been pretty class for at least a couple of years with more goals and assists than Tony

That's complete nonsense.

Your name is shit as well.
 
Tony V has been the apple of the caf's eye for 6 approx months. Prior to that he had been injured and prior to that average. Bale has been pretty class for at least a couple of years with more goals and assists than Tony

:lol:

Cannot be serious.
 
:lol:

This thread should go down into the classics with some of these comments.

"Valencia only been "consistent" for 6 months?" :lol:

"Bale is a class above Kagawa because I've never seen Kagawa?" :lol:

feck off.
 
A small part of me wishes I hadn't seen our pre season. Now I have very high expectations of Kagawa. Looks a cracking player.
 
:lol:

This thread should go down into the classics with some of these comments.

"Valencia only been "consistent" for 6 months?" :lol:

"Bale is a class above Kagawa because I've never seen Kagawa?" :lol:

feck off.

:lol:

It really is mental how some threads go.

Anyway, can't wait to see Kagawa this season. He really looks like that 'spark' that we have been missing. Obviously not better than Bale though, as they are indeed 2 very similar players :rolleyes:
 
Tony V has been the apple of the caf's eye for 6 approx months. Prior to that he had been injured and prior to that average. Bale has been pretty class for at least a couple of years with more goals and assists than Tony

:lol: Not sure if serious...
 
Tony V has been the apple of the caf's eye for 6 approx months. Prior to that he had been injured and prior to that average. Bale has been pretty class for at least a couple of years with more goals and assists than Tony

This has got to be a WUM. It did take him a while to get going last season, but you can't expect anything else when he was coming back from a long term injury, being in and out of the team at the same time. He was very consistent throughout the 2009/2010 season.
 
Valencia is the definition of consistency, whenever he gets a run of games he generally ends up hitting form.
 
Tony V has been the apple of the caf's eye for 6 approx months. Prior to that he had been injured and prior to that average. Bale has been pretty class for at least a couple of years with more goals and assists than Tony

Nice try, Gareth Bale's mum.
 
Sir Alex has also said that we've been tracking him for 2yrs now but he just wanted to see if Kagawa could replicate his good performances from the 1st season. Once he did, we went in for him.
 
Re: the article Varun posted. I'm not too worried about Kagawa having to bulk-up or whatever to deal with the Premier League. I'd say that the Bundesliga is comfortably the closest match to the Premier League in terms of physicality (amongst the 'Big 5' leagues anyway). The impression I have from watching 5-10 Bundesliga games a year (obviously I'm no expert but y'know) is that making the move from German football to English football would be nowhere near as much of a culture-shock as moving from Spanish football.

If he was going to be adapted for use in a 2-man midfield domestically then I suspect he would have to bulk up, but like most people I'm of the view that domestically he'll play behind the striker in that 4-4-1-1 (or maybe on the wings if we have problems with injuries). He's already excelled in that position in the German league so I think he'll be fine doing the same here. In any case there are plenty of example of players coming into the league and excelling in those positions in their first seasons (Mata and Silva from the last 2 seasons).

I'm most interested to see what his role would be in Europe. After the shambles of last season (where we largely played 4-4-1-1) I reckon we might revert to 4-3-3 for a lot of games and he might be employed in a midfield 3 as the more offensive, link player. I think maybe that's what Fergie was alluding to when he spoke about aiming to use small, technically-adept players like Iniesta in midfield.
 
kagawa2_2287871k.jpg



goal_2287894k.jpg
 
http://www.espnstar.com/football/premier-league/news/detail/item831841/Exclusive:-Kagawa-determined-to-adapt/

Kagawa impressed by Scholesy just like everyone else :drool:

Interesting about the training sessions as he mentions how we train with the ball much more than dortmund. Think it does explain to an extent why we arent that great a team when we dont have the ball.

That's weird though, it almost sounds like he had no idea who half our players were beforehand. I know he didn't follow us but I don't follow Dortmund and I still know half their squad.
 
That's weird though, it almost sounds like he had no idea who half our players were beforehand. I know he didn't follow us but I don't follow Dortmund and I still know half their squad.

To be fair, at the moment i dont think half the utd supporters in the world know who Brady / Veseli / Lingaard etc are.

Once the main squad start turning up im sure he will recognise a few.
 
He's fitting in excactly as I thought he would, on the evidence of pre-season.

Will provide a creative spark we lacked at times last season.
 
We started very well last season with quick, directattacking play and lots of movement. It broke all down for some reason and we became too predictable and slow. Hope we will get back to where we were 1 year ago and bring some quick play and creativity in the final third
 
http://www.espnstar.com/football/premier-league/news/detail/item831841/Exclusive:-Kagawa-determined-to-adapt/

Kagawa impressed by Scholesy just like everyone else :drool:

Interesting about the training sessions as he mentions how we train with the ball much more than dortmund. Think it does explain to an extent why we arent that great a team when we dont have the ball.

I"m sure barca train tonnes with the ball as well, and they are superb without the ball also.

must try harder.
 
Having not seen him play over the pre-season at all or in Germany ever, and having only seen highlights on youtube.

He will be our player of the year this year, and I am serious! QUOTE ME ON IT!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.