Stringer
Full Member
- Joined
- Sep 13, 2011
- Messages
- 2,092
I think anyone who wants Mourinho out this summer is out of their god damn minds. Football fans have become so fragile and reactionary
He’s been in charge for nearly two seasons...
I think anyone who wants Mourinho out this summer is out of their god damn minds. Football fans have become so fragile and reactionary
He’s been in charge for nearly two seasons...
Right? And in his first he won 2 pieces of silverware and got us back into Europes biggest stage? And in his second season he has us in a much improved league position behind only to a team having the best season in their entire short history and into another semi final with a good chance of winning another trophy. There is no denying our fortunes have improved since he came on board. I think it would be the biggest mistake this club has ever made getting rid of Mourinho, and our board isnt stupid either. He is going nowhere. Like every other red in the world I demand better football but I am more than happy to put my faith into Jose to bring us that sooner rather than later. There isn't a better man for the job out there in my opinion
Right? And in his first he won 2 pieces of silverware and got us back into Europes biggest stage? And in his second season he has us in a much improved league position behind only to a team having the best season in their entire short history and into another semi final with a good chance of winning another trophy. There is no denying our fortunes have improved since he came on board. I think it would be the biggest mistake this club has ever made getting rid of Mourinho, and our board isnt stupid either. He is going nowhere. Like every other red in the world I demand better football but I am more than happy to put my faith into Jose to bring us that sooner rather than later. There isn't a better man for the job out there in my opinion
I'd rather be that than this at the moment. Not that far behind us in the league and playing great football
Half the squad is garbage and has been for years - why can't people accept this? Let's have a look at the players we currently have that Mourinho inherited:
De Gea
Romero
Jones
Rojo (Played his best for us under Jose)
Smalling
Blind
Young (the fullback)
Shaw
Valencia (the fullback)
Darmian
Carrick
Fellaini
Herrera
Mata
Lingard
Martial
Rashford
Apart from the ones in a bold (Romero/Rojo due to differing circumstances) how many of these players have had just one good season since they've been here? Not a purple patch of 3 games every 2 months. Some have been with 3 different managers in that time. The truth of the matter is, half the squad has never performed here.
Let's look at the players Jose has got rid of in his time here as well:
Schweinsteiger
Schneiderlin
Depay
Valdes
Januzaj
Rooney
Mkhitaryan* (Jose signing)
It was plain for all to see Rooney was on the decline for at least 3 years before - so that one was inevitable, but the rest did nothing. Bang average players collecting big money. None of them are doing any good elsewhere (there's an argument for Januzaj).
Looking at who he has signed:
Lindelof
Bailly
Pogba
Sanchez
Lukaku
Ibrahimovic
Matic
Ones in bold have undoubtedly been good. Lindelof and Sanchez are both new - only Pogba remains as being completely underwhelming. But his signings have generally been good.
Does the football suck? Yes. Setting the team up not to lose has been a staple of Mourinho teams.
People are seriously deluding themselves though if they think Guardiola, Klopp, Carvahal (and whoever else is flavour of the month right now) could take half these players and do anything more than Jose is doing right now. Some the fans here just reek entitlement. Most of the players listed don't get into any top side in Europe, yet they're expecting to be challenging City? And when we don't it's a simple equation of getting rid of one manager for another; like we've done twice now - to very little success (our most success has come from this current manager). The cycle will just repeat itself, no matter who the manager is. Player recruitment has been shambolic for a long time now; unfortunately, now we are reaping what we sowed with bad planning, no clear direction and buying who ever was "hot" and available at the time. Wasted money, wasted potential, big wages. Farcical really. Whoever we get in (as a manager if/when Jose leaves) is going to have to still get rid of the deadwood, with no guarantee we will eventually break this cycle of buying average players on big money who look good at one team, but don't perform here. We need to build an actual good squad and then find a manager that can get them to play the good football we all want to see. It hasn't worked the other way round.
I agree with you. I marvel at anyone who claims we are making zero progress with a straight face. Especially when unlike when LVG was here the trophy room, on pitch results, league table position and individual player and overall team statistics prove it.I think anyone who wants Mourinho out this summer is out of their god damn minds. Football fans have become so fragile and reactionary
they beat watford 5-0 last night. Can we stop pretending they aren't in a better situation than us right now, even if they are at a slight disadvantage in the prmiershipI too would love reminiscing the glorious victory over Cardiff in 2012.
I assume from your response that you believe the performances where we won were all well planned and executed to perfection. I bet you were probably on the edge of your couch all excited, where many of us were just going for f*cks sake and hoping rather than expecting. You obviously think we weren't schooled at home in the league by Brighton, Spurs, Liverpool and Chelsea to name just a few.Yeah the draws at home from last season have just magically turned into wins this season.
I assume from your response that you believe the performances where we won were all well planned and executed to perfection. I bet you were probably on the edge of your couch all excited, where many of us were just going for f*cks sake and hoping rather than expecting. You obviously think we weren't schooled at home in the league by Brighton, Spurs, Liverpool and Chelsea to name just a few.
Just about everyone on here has said the results have been better, current position is better but there is a significant amount of people saying the performances have been largely dross. Not for a few games for a very long period. If you don't believe that, that is your right. There are others who don't agree and probably do not believe in magic either.
Yeah we were definitely schooled by Liverpool, Chelsea, Brighton and Spurs at OT![]()
He needs to have a go at the top sides instead of parking the bus, or we will never win the Premiership under him.
they beat watford 5-0 last night. Can we stop pretending they aren't in a better situation than us right now, even if they are at a slight disadvantage in the prmiership
They’ve been in a “better situation” than us since 2013, that's what's funny.
Whatever happened to the banner at old Trafford about city not winning for a long time?
Where are city now? They are in a position where when we play them, we are scared to have the ball and defend in banks of four.
Just because Liverpool haven't won anything doesn't mean they aren't going on the right direction.
Smacks of hypocrisy where United sit back and defend and are underwhelming, but are better than Liverpool only because Liverpool are five points behind united, but you don't even account that they are in the champion's league, scoring more goals, playing better and have a better platform to go and have better seasons.
exactlyPrev: 5th, 4th, 7th or some shit
Current: 2nd.
All I need
2. Players not up to required standard
----------XX--------------
XX--Bailly--Lindelof--XX
-----Matic----Pogba----
Mkhi------------Sanchez
-------Ibra----Rom-----
Leave aside full backs and GK, Mou has signed 8 players. He didn't need to sign a GK thanks to DDG. Leave aside Full backs, we have a side that was signed by Mou himself. In all honesty, could you say that once we sign full backs, we'd be a force again?
If signings haven't worked out as expected, who is to blame? Surely Mou is the one calling the shots on who to sign, or atleast is consulted before signing a player.
I won't go into the man management part as that would be based surely on Newspaper reports and the authenticity of the reports is arguable, but based on these points, it's tough defend him!
Mind, If he assures the fans, board and most importantly players, that he is ready to mend his ways and not deploy cowardly tactics against every decent competitive team and won't go berserk at players (like he has started indicating), I'm fine with him staying, but that's a very big IF
exactly
Prev: 6th, 5th, 4th, 7th or some shit
Current: 2nd.
All I need
Miki was lauded when signed and his limitations are clear as day with him not being able for the premier league. He has since been shipped out in 18 months and replace by Sanchez, something which United as a club haven't been doing for years so IMO this is a positive. Sanchez still has to improve.
Zlatan was never a long term signing, 2 years max, and horrific injury probably forced us to go out and buy his replacement 1 year earlier than I think we wanted to.
So based on that it leaves us with the following
----------DDG-------------
XX--Bailly--Lindelof--XX
-----Matic----Pogba----
XX------XX----Sanchez
--------Rom-----
So that leaves us space for 4 players for Jose to have bought his full 11 and they are obviously the most depressingly obvious places we need to improve because the quality IMO has gone up based on the players Jose has signed.
We have 2 aging converted full backs with average quality.
The endless debate as to who we play on the right, as we are overloaded on the left with MArtial/Lukaku and Rashford
And then do we buy another 10 or buy a midfielder that will compliment Pogbas deficiencies.
I think Jose will buy all 4 of these spots in summer and absolutely has to go close in the league at a bare minimum for me next season if he does get who he wants.
And looking at who he has shipped out
Schweinsteiger
Schneiderlin
Depay
Valdes
Januzaj
Rooney
Miki (*** straight away *** )
as well as more than likely
Shaw
Blind
Darmian
Fellaini (contract)
Our squad will be much less bloated. At a minimum we need to give Jose another season.
I didn't say we had no money, back then we were in a good position financially and yes Fergie was backed as you say, but we certainly didn't have the wealth of Chelseas current owner, or Citys or some of the other Johnny Come Latelys who but a football club, not because they love the game but to make more money, which is why the Glazers bought United of course. Also TV money was a lot less back then than it is now.Not sure I agree with that, Fergie broke the british transfer record a few times. £2.3m for Pallister rings a bell prior to first FA Cup win, Keane was later on at £3.75m - this might not sound a lot now but it was groundbreaking fees in those days.. Van Nistelrooy at £19m & Veron at £28m were pre Glazer days also, Utd always backed Fergie and Fergie (barring the horse dispute, you could argue) always put Utd first.