Summit
"do the dead, spread your seed and get out"
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2011
- Messages
- 51,054
hyperboleI would like you to list every single one please...
hyperboleI would like you to list every single one please...
No I never said you were mate. I was merely pointing out that a goal scorer would have been better for us and a defensive midfielder, simply because you can not say that Fabinho's presence would have been enough to keep a clean sheet, whereas a goal scorer with the amount of chances we created would have almost certainly got us the win.
Please no Mbappe.
There are about 3,000 better ways to spend 100m.
Freshness may have gotten us a few more points yes. Fabinho does look the part.
Finally the type we need. Proper holding midfielder who is good on the ball and intelligent. Hopefully it happens. Then get someone who is quality playing on the right (bernardo silva), a striker (belotti), fix up the defence (random left back, varane for cb) and we would be set.
He was, until he was robbed of all confidence by Mourinho. He was Italians player of the year for a reason.Though the Caf did tell me that Darmian was a marauding attacking fullback![]()
It's certainly a much safer investment though.We need a striker.... 70m on Lukaku isnt a better option
He was, until he was robbed of all confidence by Mourinho. He was Italians player of the year for a reason.
Fabinho is once again getting a bad rep on the caf. He isn't just a DM, in fact he has mainly been used as a defensive box to box more than an anchor. He is a solid passer with a good vision, he has a better technique than his potential DM counterparts, he is faster, taller, more powerful.
He started off really well for the first few games, looked the real deal. Then he had one not so good game, got critizised a little bit, and spiraled down. This season under Mourinho he is looking crestfallen all season. You have to be sensitive with those Italians. Point is, he really was a marauding full back before. So "the people in the Caf" were right.Did evil Mourinho make him shite at attacking under LvG last season too? His tentacles really do stretch far and wide.
From pretty much the best source available.
Love this. Another Herrera in the making; if we can get 2 or 3 more players who really love this club, be sure our next step is the CL trophy!
He started off really well for the first few games, looked the real deal. Then he had one not so good game, got critizised a little bit, and spiraled down. This season under Mourinho he is looking crestfallen all season. You have to be sensitive with those Italians. Point is, he really was a marauding full back before. So "the people in the Caf" were right.
Who would be your pick for United if we could only take 1 player from Monaco?
I know you're a Monaco fan as well, so please don't say nobody![]()
If you actually read you'd see I said the inverse - signing good players irrespective of having perfect team balance - i.e. Nainggolan over a 'perfect holder' that everyone is lauding over. I never said we should be content in signing mediocre players. Congratulations for completely misreading the post.
Meh. We've played half the season without a 'holder' and have been fine. True midfield balance like that is only really necessary at the very highest level, and we're not quite competing there yet.
I'd tend to agree. Wasn't totally convinced about Lukaku, but seeing how much physical strength we've been lacking in the team without Pogba and Zlatan playing, I think someone like him would be ideal now.It's certainly a much safer investment though.
Firm offers for players isn't exciting stuff? Yeah, alright.And what has "the best source available" actually said?
We bid €85m for Mbappe, the bid was the turned down, Monaco want €140m and the player wants Real Madrid. We made an initial enquiry months ago for Nainggolan but have not followed up and the player doesn't want to leave anyway. Fabinho and Kroos are alternatives.
Not exactly exciting stuff.
Also, Di Marzio is nothing like "the best source available" for non-Italian-based players.
Firm offers for players isn't exciting stuff? Yeah, alright.![]()
If we had a top class holder then Herrera and especially Pogba would have had more license to attack and less ground to cover.
I must have missed the bit where Fabinho said he wants a different club. Could you quote for me please?For one player, which was rejected and the player wants a different club. What a time to be alive!
Its so laughable that people imagine Kante is not a defensive may midfielder. I wonder where this notion that DMs are restricted, indistinguished users of a ball comes from.
I posted twice before that.This was your post:
That was in a thread about Fabinho being top of our list, immediately after a post about Fabinho being top of our list.
Not sure what I've misread to be honest? Unless you're suggesting Fabinho isn't a holding midfielder and your post was entirely about Nainggolan?
If so, you definitely could have been clearer.
Nainggolan would be interesting too. Him, Ander, and Pogba in a midfield three would be quite naughty.
Ander has played as the deepest midfielder numerous times this season. Could easily be managed, particularly against smaller teams.
I thought Fabinho is a fullback.
Fabinho is more of the controller type like Busquets or Carrick. In the EPL currently its probably only Romeu who is the young version of that type of midfielder.People are confusing DMs for holders. We specifically need a holder more than we need an overall DM. Defensive midfielders could be box-to-box (Schneiderlin/Kante) or holders (Carvalho/Fernando/Danilo Pereira).
To me, for what we need, the positional discipline and anchoring ability of the holder is more important than the player's function; whether it's strictly tackling (Casemiro) or strictly passing (Alonso).
Fabinho would be ideal for what we need.
Fabinho is more of the controller type like Busquets or Carrick. In the EPL currently its probably only Romeu who is the young version of that type of midfielder.
Who is?He's a United fan, we'd be stupid not to
Fabinho has been rumoured for months and months now. It's one of those signings that you just expect to be announced because of the coverage.
Hopefully it ends up like Pogba and not Vidal.
I must have missed the bit where Fabinho said he wants a different club. Could you quote for me please?
Yeah I get that. But this thread is chiefly about Fabinho and if you are to beleive some of the article then the rest should be beleived too.Mbappe is the player we bid for. Fabinho is apparently a midfield target along with Kroos.