Manchester United v Aston Villa

Can't call it a dive because there is contact but yes he threw his leg in to get the foul.



And Is Ireland a United fan?:eek:

Maybe, but he is also a grade A cnut, I hate the prick
 
Tony V With the Breaky D.

Gonna need a gif of that.
 
can someone cry me a decent river by PM

cheers, not having much luck today,
 
Rafael attempting a Rooney there.

Need to keep up this pressure now.
 
Great ball to Welbeck who should have scored....shockingly weak header.
 
Decision's get balanced out over the season don't they?

There was a couple against Wigan which we should have got.
 
No, it is a penalty and it is as clear as you think tbh, fecksake some of the Young hatred is sickening.
Who said I hate young?? You should read my posts in other threads, I've got nothing against divers or others, but that doesn't mean I can't see whether it was a dive or not.
I don't call any player a cheat but if you think he didn't dive here then well I can't help you.
 
Check the replay. He moves his foot towards the defender's foot, then throws his back leg over in a theatrical fall. It's a dive, clear as day.

And you said this because you're not a United supporter... Clear as day. There are too many hypocrites around here.
 
It's a blatant dive by Young, just because there's contact doesn't mean he hasn't gone and dived. He could've easily stayed on his feet.

He initiated the contact himself before throwing himself theatrically. I've obviously wasted a bit of time arguing it with Utd fans who are less likely to be open minded about it :D No crime, everyone does it with the club they love.

Valencia is my kind of player, direct, pace and power. He wont be going down easily, he'll just bull doze his way through!
 
Whoa...

Newcastle United defender Ryan Taylor has tweeted: "Ashley Young is an absolute DISGRACE. He's the biggest cheat in the league. His antics are a joke."
 
There's contact in that situation exclusively because of Young. It's not a dive technically, but it's heavy simulation.

The defender made contact and then pulled his leg away too.

Something you should look at as well.Young did go looking for contact and he got it.

I am probably never been more unsure if it was a penalty or not.:wenger:
 
And you said this because you're not a United supporter... Clear as day. There are too many hypocrites around here.

Not one supporter of any other club thinks it was a pen. I want you lot to win the title over City so the fact you're winning is great for me. That, however, was a disgrace, made even worse by the fact he did the same thing last weekend.
 
Who said I hate young?? You should read my posts in other threads, I've got nothing against divers or others, but that doesn't mean I can't see whether it was a dive or not.
I don't call any player a cheat but if you think he didn't dive here then well I can't help you.

Did I say you hated Young? Anywhere? I made reference to you saying it was not a clear penalty shout. then I added on the young hatred in general as an after thought