[Poll Added] Hypothetical: Next manager after Jose Mourinho

Who would be your current choice for next manager after Jose Mourinho?


  • Total voters
    1,710
This thread is embarassing and lack of respect for our current manager.

Fergie would have been sacked long before his first trophy with the current sets of fans

Where do you see people calling for the sack?

This thread is purely hypothetical as mentioned in the title

There will be eventually a successor to Jose sooner than later,what's wrong with discussing that?

It's no different than discussing and speculating over transfers after a window has close

The era of managers lasting well over a decade is long over,doesn't cause any harm thinking of the future
 
This thread is embarassing and lack of respect for our current manager.

Fergie would have been sacked long before his first trophy with the current sets of fans
You need to stop using Fergie as an example. We can't just give every manager the same amount of time that Fergie had. Giving anybody that amount of time won't produce another Fergie.

That same mentality would have kept Moyes for several years.
 
Where do you see people calling for the sack?

This thread is purely hypothetical as mentioned in the title

There will be eventually a successor to Jose sooner than later,what's wrong with discussing that?

It's no different than discussing and speculating over transfers after a window has close

The era of managers lasting well over a decade is long over,doesn't cause any harm thinking of the future

Put this thread in city chelsea liverpool tottenham thread and see how long you last before you get the ban
 
This thread is embarassing and lack of respect for our current manager.

Fergie would have been sacked long before his first trophy with the current sets of fans
What’s embarassing are posts like this, especially when there have always been discussions on who would take over from Fergie when he packed it in. Makes you come across as a zealot who doesn’t agree with peoples right to have a discussion. Like we live under some sort of dictatorship.

It’s a discussion thread for who, people would like as the next manager. Not calling for Jose to be sacked right now, just who people think or would like as the next man up. Nothing wrong with it at all.
 
I would personally prefer Jardim over Pochettino, but comparing him to Moyes is doing a disservice to him. There is no comparison between the two.

- One played dull football and finished in the top 4 only once in his Everton career, the other had Spurs up there in 3 of his 4 seasons playing some excellent stuff.
- His career has been on an upwards trajectory since came to the premier league. He took over from Adkins and did well for a team who were hovering in relegation spots. In the next season he took them up to 8th and a respectable points total. At Spurs after finishing 5th in the first season, he has had them in 4th, 2nd and 3rd. Again doing very well with his limited resources. There has been a constant progression. In comparison Moyes reached a ceiling and could never break it.
- He topped last season's champions league group comprising of Real and BVB. Had Juve on the ropes in R16 & only Spurs inexperience prevented them from progressing.
- He has constantly given young players a chance and brought them through. (By young I don't mean only academy players)
- His style of football is very progressive and would go with the football this club is used to. Moyes' was never suited to us.
- He comes across as very confident and I have hardly ever heard him complain despite adversity (like this season with Spurs not buying anyone). Moyes was a bag of nerves and full of excuses.

His lack of trophies does make me a little vary of him and that is why my preference is Jardim. However I won't be disappointed with Pochettino. Cautious optimism is what I would feel if we hired him.

Whilst you have a good argument, you actually do a disservice to Moyes. Everton were relegation fodder when Moyes took over. He might have hit a ceiling, but given the resources at the time I think it was the highest ceiling Everton could realistically achieve/ sustain.

Moyes deserved a chance almost much as Poch would. The big differential is the experience of regular Champions League. The impact of that can't be underestimated. The players are constantly in the spot light and that brings a different set of skills.

Moyes still did well in many aspects. Yes he took us from 1st to 7th, but the team were massively in decline. He did relatively well in the CL.

But yes for a guy of his age and experience acting like a deer in the headlights was always going to be a recipe for failure, albeit one that would have been hard to forecast happening.
 
This thread is embarassing and lack of respect for our current manager.

Fergie would have been sacked long before his first trophy with the current sets of fans

Aye. Doesn’t feel like Manchester United at all. Guess, eventually all we fans are the same after all.
 
Whilst you have a good argument, you actually do a disservice to Moyes. Everton were relegation fodder when Moyes took over. He might have hit a ceiling, but given the resources at the time I think it was the highest ceiling Everton could realistically achieve/ sustain.

Moyes deserved a chance almost much as Poch would. The big differential is the experience of regular Champions League. The impact of that can't be underestimated. The players are constantly in the spot light and that brings a different set of skills.

Moyes still did well in many aspects. Yes he took us from 1st to 7th, but the team were massively in decline. He did relatively well in the CL.

But yes for a guy of his age and experience acting like a deer in the headlights was always going to be a recipe for failure, albeit one that would have been hard to forecast happening.
This post is a ban-able offence.
You raise some good points.
 
Ferguson wasn't given time by the fans! There were a strong vocal bunch wanted him long gone! Lets not rewrite history here. there were also a number than wanted him gone through various points in his successful period.

Ferguson being given time was the correct thing because of who he was. That doesn't mean its right to give every manager time. Moyes had to go, Van Gaal had to go. The jury is out on Mourinho but if he stays it should be based on the job he is doing not because giving managers time is always right.

Its also worth saying that the reason Ferguson was given time was because of all the work he was doing behind the scenes to restructure an entire club that hadn't won a title for 20+ years, it was a completely different set of circumstances to the ones we face right now.

I'm happily behind keeping Mourinho but I don't see that we cant discuss alternatives just for the sake of a discussion.
 
Whilst you have a good argument, you actually do a disservice to Moyes. Everton were relegation fodder when Moyes took over. He might have hit a ceiling, but given the resources at the time I think it was the highest ceiling Everton could realistically achieve/ sustain.

Moyes deserved a chance almost much as Poch would. The big differential is the experience of regular Champions League. The impact of that can't be underestimated. The players are constantly in the spot light and that brings a different set of skills.

Moyes still did well in many aspects. Yes he took us from 1st to 7th, but the team were massively in decline. He did relatively well in the CL.

But yes for a guy of his age and experience acting like a deer in the headlights was always going to be a recipe for failure, albeit one that would have been hard to forecast happening.

Moyes was a disaster in every single aspect of everything he touched at Man Utd, from dealing with the media, transfers, tactics, players, backroom staff, you name it he completely cocked it up from the day he arrived to the day he left. He took the team that, perceived decline or not, were the Champions of the country by a wide margin and turned them into a team being outplayed by relegation candidates and teams that subsequently sacked their managers in the space of 3 months.

The only aspect it could possibly be suggested he did well in would be if his remit was "screw up this football club in as short a time as possible".
 
You need to stop using Fergie as an example. We can't just give every manager the same amount of time that Fergie had. Giving anybody that amount of time won't produce another Fergie.

That same mentality would have kept Moyes for several years.

You can't surely compare Moyes with Jose. Jose is several levels above Moyes and deserves time.
Jose won 2 trophies with us in his first season. It would have taken Moyes 10 years, to achieve the same.
 
Moyes deserved a chance almost much as Poch would. The big differential is the experience of regular Champions League. The impact of that can't be underestimated. The players are constantly in the spot light and that brings a different set of skills.

Moyes still did well in many aspects. Yes he took us from 1st to 7th, but the team were massively in decline. He did relatively well in the CL.

But yes for a guy of his age and experience acting like a deer in the headlights was always going to be a recipe for failure, albeit one that would have been hard to forecast happening.

This guy started well in his reply, then lost it towards the end....

This post is a ban-able offence.
You raise some good points.

And this guy got it bang on:

Moyes was a disaster in every single aspect of everything he touched at Man Utd, from dealing with the media, transfers, tactics, players, backroom staff, you name it he completely cocked it up from the day he arrived to the day he left. He took the team that, perceived decline or not, were the Champions of the country by a wide margin and turned them into a team being outplayed by relegation candidates and teams that subsequently sacked their managers in the space of 3 months.

The only aspect it could possibly be suggested he did well in would be if his remit was "screw up this football club in as short a time as possible".

There is no sympathy I can afford Moyes. It took SAF 2 decades to build the club up and it took Moyes 10 months to tear it down.
I have no sympathy for Moyes and any abuse he gets, IMO, is not enough.
For me, Moyes is not a 5 letter word, it's a 4 letter expletive which can be used interchangeably with f*ck, sh*t.
 
So we're in need of Trump then?

Someone add Zidane to the poll? As is best available.

No. I think there should be an effort by those in control of popular United channels/forums/outlets to make fans aware of the incentive structure for these media outlets. They get paid far more to write lies about United than the truth on 90% of other sides. It's a problem that won't go away without some action.
 
There’s a lot of my mates who believe that zidane is overrated. They claim that with the squad he had, it’s a no brained that he won as much as he did. But, i say to them - 3 UCL titles back to back... to back!

That has never been done before and will likely never be bettered. To win three champions leagues in a row requires tactical nous and brilliant man-management. Even Guardiola with the GOAT in his prime couldn’t do it.

I have rebutted with claims that he isn’t as tactically sound as he’s made out to be. But do I care? No. Why? Cuz he’s Zinedine fecking Zidane. He believes in attacking football and is yet pragmatic when needed. Just imagine a man if that stature taking over the club. It’s just what we need as a club post Fergie.

I will give Mourinho half this season. If we can be solid and yet not an incredible bore to watch, I will support him. But I miss seeing a fearless, marauding United. That is our brand and why we started watching in the first place. We need it back. Zidane... that’s my man. Class, Success and Stature. We would overnight become the centre of the footballing world again.
 
No. I think there should be an effort by those in control of popular United channels/forums/outlets to make fans aware of the incentive structure for these media outlets. They get paid far more to write lies about United than the truth on 90% of other sides. It's a problem that won't go away without some action.

People are fully aware, yet they choose to buy into gossip. It’s irra but the way of the world.
 
I would personally prefer Jardim over Pochettino, but comparing him to Moyes is doing a disservice to him. There is no comparison between the two.

- One played dull football and finished in the top 4 only once in his Everton career, the other had Spurs up there in 3 of his 4 seasons playing some excellent stuff.
- His career has been on an upwards trajectory since came to the premier league. He took over from Adkins and did well for a team who were hovering in relegation spots. In the next season he took them up to 8th and a respectable points total. At Spurs after finishing 5th in the first season, he has had them in 4th, 2nd and 3rd. Again doing very well with his limited resources. There has been a constant progression. In comparison Moyes reached a ceiling and could never break it.
- He topped last season's champions league group comprising of Real and BVB. Had Juve on the ropes in R16 & only Spurs inexperience prevented them from progressing.
- He has constantly given young players a chance and brought them through. (By young I don't mean only academy players)
- His style of football is very progressive and would go with the football this club is used to. Moyes' was never suited to us.
- He comes across as very confident and I have hardly ever heard him complain despite adversity (like this season with Spurs not buying anyone). Moyes was a bag of nerves and full of excuses.
- Poch has shown he is not afraid to bench big players, like he did by benching Walker, Alderweireld and Rose when they were looking for moves. Moyes gave Rooney a five year extension when everyone knew he was done for at a top club.

His lack of trophies does make me a little vary of him and that is why my preference is Jardim. However I won't be disappointed with Pochettino. Cautious optimism is what I would feel if we hired him.
Poch is Moyes. A lot of people were arguing the same thing in favor of Moyes. People were claiming that Moyes plays decent football, same as now for Poch, who by the way, is far from a manager who plays free flowing attacking football. Poch is a pragmatist like Mourinho, but without trophies. His football at times is attractive, and at times is unwatchable. When the team is losing, they get collectively converted to Wimbledon FC and try to injure opposition players.

Yes, Poch is good at low key transfers. So was Moyes, and people were mentioning that fact how Moyes overachieved with his squad. How Moyes was so good at developing players.

Sure, Poch has done better than Moyes, but he has also had a much better team and much more financial support than Moyes' Everton. He is also a bit more progressive and in general a better manager. He is... Moyes in steroids, if you like. Still Moyes though.

Jardim is actually what a lot of Caftards thing Poch is. He plays great football (destroyed Saint Pep), won the title against a much better and financially stronger team, actually great at transfers considering that he needs to change his team every summer. He would easily be the most exciting choice, though Allegri is the most low-risk choice, and Zidane is an interesting one. But hiring a manager who has won feck all in a decade is insane. We already did it, and it didn't end well. And as bad as LVG and Mou were in 2 years here, they already won here more than Poch did on his career.
 
I was going to vote for Zidane, but he is not even in the poll.

I hope we can sign some French talents and keep Pogba if we get Zidane.
 
Why is Klopp not on the list but Pep is?
 
Christ can we not just talk about this season and back the manager for the moment

The fact that koeman got votes shows how quickly this changes

Nah, it was just some feck up with the votes, new names were added and some of the votes changed places for some reason.
 
Embarassing thread. I refuse to vote. But whoever comes one day is fecked. New manager must play youth, he must play attacking football, he must win titles, he must buy world class players at maximum age 24, he must kiss players before sleep and praise them every day in media and above all he must sign contract on at least 10 years because anything else is short term option.
 
People mentioning Pochettino remind me of people who wanted Moyes 5 years ago. Both points in favor and against Poch, were also for Moyes. If you actually get posts about Poch, change the name to Moyes, and turn the time back 5 years, those posts won't look out of place.

Now obviously, Poch is a better manager than Moyes. That is not enough though.

He wouldn't make my top 5 choices, probably not my top 10.

I agree.

I'm just not a fan of Poch. I know he's not at a club where they're expected to win, but something about Poch just irks me. I don't see him as a winner.
 
Interesting. So United is about to be turned into one of those 'change the manager every other season' clubs. Maybe I better get used to it.

The moment we sacked Van Gaal the day after winning the FA Cup, we were done. We no longer have any moral high horse on this.

I still fume about the awful way we treated him.
 
Last edited:
He HASN'T won anything! You can't just dismiss that as though it doesn't matter because if you are being handed the Man Utd job it very much does. I would like to know that the manager we have in place has the tools to get teams over the line when the pressure is on. I was against the appointment of Moyes for that reason. Now Im not putting Pochettino in the same category as Moyes but some of the same questions remain.

He has, by hook or by crook ended up with the best Spurs team of modern times. Yet big bad Jose Mourinho totally outclassed him in an FA Cup Semi Final when Spurs had the initial initiative. Juventus knocked them out of the CL when Spurs had the initiative and in the season where every so-called "big" club had an absolute nightmare Leicester City beat them to the title. When the chips are down, the pressure is on, and there is suddenly a little bit of expectation attached to his teams they have not performed well. That doesn't mean he is a poor manager or couldn't make the step up but it leaves enough questions for it not to simply be dismissed.

While he has been getting all the plaudits for this Spurs team being absolutely amazing and at the same time we have been getting criticism left right and centre the cold reality is that we have won an FA Cup, a Europa League, a League Cup, a Community Shield, been runners up in the league and runners up in the FA Cup. Thats what the terrible Man Utd team have achieved. What has he done with his great team? Once you get past the great football he isn't putting much in the trophy cabinets.
Great post.
 
We must be the only fanbase in the world, that i've noticed, that is totally convinced we must have a manager that's won it all and that any manager that hasn't, no matter the circumstances, is worth nothing to us whatsoever. When clubs like Bayern Munich, Real Madrid, Barcelona, Borussia Dortmund, Chelsea etc, are perfectly fine with hiring managers that haven't won anything significant yet, you'd think that would be enough to convince people but apparently not because we are so superior and we must have instant success, we just don't see the bigger picture.

When I look around, the argument seems to be that everyone wants to have it all, everyone wants attacking football, winning football, trophies every season, has to play youth, or, this quote said it better...

Embarassing thread. I refuse to vote. But whoever comes one day is fecked. New manager must play youth, he must play attacking football, he must win titles, he must buy world class players at maximum age 24, he must kiss players before sleep and praise them every day in media and above all he must sign contract on at least 10 years because anything else is short term option.

So the pressure must be on poor Jose Mourinho to deliver all this and it's so unfair to him to have all of this hyped up on him and how is it possible for him to deliver, except, any reasonable supporter doesn't want all of this.

I mean I really don't see how this thread is embarassing, nobody reasonable is asking Mourinho to do all these things, okay do we expect a youth product in the running to be played by the club, yes, but don't most teams? i mean big teams like Bayern Munich manage it just fine so why is it such a burden for us. People want attacking football, but apparently this isn't connected to winning football, people seem mystified that you can play attacking football AND win, perhaps people are sick to the back teeth of falling asleep during another snoozefest of a match that De Gea has kept us in and want to be entertained, people pay had earned money to support the team and take in Football as Entertainment, because first and foremost that what this is, i don't see that as an unreasonable demand given the players at our disposal, the money spent, and the fact that most other top clubs are playing this way bar 1 or 2, and even then our football looks dour in comparison to them at times.

As far as i'm concerned people would be a lot less concerned about winning titles every season, especially early on in a managers stint, if we could see some actual plan, something to get us off our seats and actually say, you know what, yes we are going somewhere with this, it may take time but it will get there. Why do you think Liverpool and Tottenham fans are happy with Klopp and Pochettino, we can poke fun that they haven't won anything but they are excited because of what they see on and off the pitch and they realise things are headed in a direction where winning something, and winning it well, is something that will highly likely be on the horizon, Spurs less so because of their financial restrictions in comparison, but regardless, its there... As opposed to what, Mourinho's slapped ass face moaning about his players and the transfers consistently, causing issues with players such as Martial and Pogba, getting excuses in early, playing shit on a stick football against teams we should of been smashing off the park and going out early in the CL because of it...

Sorry but no, i get behind the club, i don't get behind the manager just simply because he is the manager and I feel like it's not in the best interests of the club if he stays, if he ballses up or gives me reason to give him stick, i'll give him stick because he deserves it, and I personally don't feel Mourinho is a good fit for United, and i don't want to watch my team play the utterly shite football he has them playing, i make no apologies for stating that right now, the fact for me is he's sucked all joy out of watching the club I love because of whats happening on the field and because of his antics off it, and don't start giving me this tinfoil hat crap about the media having an agenda against him and United, Mourinho gives them fuel for the fire, we don't see the "nicer" side of Mourinho because it's been damn few and far between these days compared to when he first came on the scene.

"Well go and support Liverpool or Spurs then!!!1!11!1on1eonEONe" I hear people start to cry, anybody who sais this really does not get it, Mourinho was brought in for short term success whilst sacrificing other aspects that come with him, everyone knew this, but the fact is, and lets face reality, it isn't going to happen on the scale everyone wants (aka Title and CL) and the sooner people wake up and face the reality we are in the better, we are watching as teams like Liverpool, Tottenham, City, Chelsea, and even Arsenal now build foundations for long lasting competitiveness and possible future success, hell, City's strategy is already paying dividends and Liverpools nearly did last season, whilst we are hoping Mourinho pulls a title win out of his ass before he sods off in a season or two, because make no mistake, he will.

Td;lr this thread isn't embarassing and planning for a future without Mourinho is smart and healthy because I cannot stand the poisonous attitudes the fans have gotten since he's been here and he's sucked all the joy out of the game and the club I love, for me anyway.
 
Diego Simeone still my no1 choice, surprised so many people want Pochettino when the most amazing thing he’s done is come 3rd in a two horse race. If not Simeone then Jardim could be tempted to come as if he was to build a successful side it wouldn’t get dismantled in a transfer window
 
@L1nk . So every top 6 club except us has better future than us and their fans shoud be more excited than us? Every top 6 club except us building future foundation for titles? Mourinho thinking short term?
Did you noticed that we have only five or six 30y old players( only matic and valencia in first 11 and jose already has their replacements in pereira and dalot). Jose bought lindelof, bailly, dalot, fred, pogba, lukaku.. all players who are 25y max.
Jose plays with pereira, rashford, martial, shaw and lingard who are all young players. And jose is having better results than your mighty klopp or poch.
Meh, why am i even trying here? This hate towards jose among some united fans is really ridiculous
 
People mentioning Pochettino remind me of people who wanted Moyes 5 years ago. Both points in favor and against Poch, were also for Moyes. If you actually get posts about Poch, change the name to Moyes, and turn the time back 5 years, those posts won't look out of place.

Now obviously, Poch is a better manager than Moyes. That is not enough though.

He wouldn't make my top 5 choices, probably not my top 10.
Same here. He has won feck all with a very good Spurs team. Everytime the pressure is on they collapse and his players start acting like thugs. No idea where this reputation for Spurs playing good football even comes from. What's the point of good football if you don't actually produce when it matters?
 
I'm sold. Not even joking.


Well, a couple more things to consider

1- He's sent many players to the NT
2- He already speaks english
3- He's a fan of Independiente, the argentine Red Devils, so there would be a feeling.
4- He uses A LOT of technology to develop the game.
5- He works A LOT.


I mean, he will triumph. Don't know if it's at United, Sevilla or wherever. This guy is a really working person, a tactical master and has the personality.


Of course now it's when it's too risky to take him. It's easier when he's already known.
 
Poch is Moyes.

POCH IS NOT MOYES!
POCH IS POCH!


(:p Sorry, but that kind of definitive statement without any basis did deserve to be mocked. I couldn't resist)

A lot of people were arguing the same thing in favor of Moyes. People were claiming that Moyes plays decent football, same as now for Poch, who by the way, is far from a manager who plays free flowing attacking football. Poch is a pragmatist like Mourinho, but without trophies. His football at times is attractive, and at times is unwatchable. When the team is losing, they get collectively converted to Wimbledon FC and try to injure opposition players.

Yes, Poch is good at low key transfers. So was Moyes, and people were mentioning that fact how Moyes overachieved with his squad. How Moyes was so good at developing players.

Sure, Poch has done better than Moyes, but he has also had a much better team and much more financial support than Moyes' Everton. He is also a bit more progressive and in general a better manager. He is... Moyes in steroids, if you like. Still Moyes though.

Jardim is actually what a lot of Caftards thing Poch is. He plays great football (destroyed Saint Pep), won the title against a much better and financially stronger team, actually great at transfers considering that he needs to change his team every summer. He would easily be the most exciting choice, though Allegri is the most low-risk choice, and Zidane is an interesting one. But hiring a manager who has won feck all in a decade is insane. We already did it, and it didn't end well. And as bad as LVG and Mou were in 2 years here, they already won here more than Poch did on his career.

I really do not know or care about "what people were saying....". It doesn't have anything to do with the discussion on hand. I gave you points how both of them have had different careers so far, where one has showed progression and other had a pretty stagnant career. There are hardly any similarities.

Pochettino also hasn't been supported with more money in an era where all of Spurs rivals are spending 100m+. An era when even teams like West Ham, Everton & Fulham aren't shy of spending tons of money. His budget has been limited, so much so that Spurs didn't buy a single player in the current window.

Pochettino also "destroyed Saint Pep" in the season when Monaco defeated City in the champions league. (City went out on away goals against Monaco, actually) Also, Jardim doesn't decide transfers at Monaco, so giving him credit for it is disingenuous.

Spurs play an attractive brand of fearless football under Pochettino. It may be pragmatic at times but it is not Tony Pulis hoofball. Spurs defend from the front in similar fashion to how we used to under Sir Alex during our good spells. It is only after we had an aging midfield and defense that Sir Alex decided to be more pragmatic.

Winning trophies is hard when you have worked from the ground up and spent a large portion of your career so far at Espanyol and Southampton. He should have won may be a smaller cup at Spurs, but let's be honest no one gives a hoot about the two domestic cups in an era when Champions league money has become so important. Arsene Wenger sacrificed it for 10 years to keep Arsenal in the Champions League; and when he won 3 FA cups in 4 seasons, he still got canned. We United fans too used to mock them as mickey mouse cups. How times have changed that we now see them as signs of major achievement.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Sultan
Well, a couple more things to consider

1- He's sent many players to the NT
2- He already speaks english
3- He's a fan of Independiente, the argentine Red Devils, so there would be a feeling.
4- He uses A LOT of technology to develop the game.
5- He works A LOT.


I mean, he will triumph. Don't know if it's at United, Sevilla or wherever. This guy is a really working person, a tactical master and has the personality.


Of course now it's when it's too risky to take him. It's easier when he's already known.

Got to admit, you're convincing me. I think it'd probably be seen to be too much of a gamble for the club to do it (especially with Woodward in charge) but I'm sold
 
I've been hearing strong rumors of Jose daring Pogba to put in a transfer request. Not sure if that's true, but it definitely does not bode well for the club. There's no way we will win anything, let alone the league title with this unrest in the dressing room.

http://www.espn.com/soccer/blog/tra...ba-to-hand-in-transfer-request-as-rift-widens

Not sure if either Jose or Pogba will remain at the club till the end of the season.
 
I've been hearing strong rumors of Jose daring Pogba to put in a transfer request. Not sure if that's true, but it definitely does not bode well for the club. There's no way we will win anything, let alone the league title with this unrest in the dressing room.

http://www.espn.com/soccer/blog/tra...ba-to-hand-in-transfer-request-as-rift-widens

Not sure if either Jose or Pogba will remain at the club till the end of the season.
Story from The Sun? Must be true I guess. Man the lifeboats.