Zinedine Zidane | Resigns

If Real appoint Poch, that's the tbd of Ronaldo imo.
He's the kind of my way or high way kibd of coach.
 
Taking a thread off topic
fecking hell. Yes Lord Pep created possession style football. Plenty of teams have played this style and used a press, maybe not so effectively (because they didn't have peak Xavi, Iniesta and Messi) but to say he created it is so far removed from reality it's not even funny. The one thing I will credit him with his getting his teams to accept injecting performance enhancing drugs as the norm.

Don't know about you, but I have the whole "Pep's Era" downloaded on my disk, not any other team's. Haven't seen one team dominate and play like this.
Sometimes you just have to remove the bias and enjoy the brilliance, the world is a much better place then.
 
Taking a thread off topic
Barca hadn't won anything for 2 years when Pep arrived

In the season before he was appointed people were saying the B team was coached better than the main team

It was clear to see Guardiola wasn't just a normal manager at Barcelona B

He cleared out Deco, Ronaldinho, Zambrotta and Thuram retired

He had anything but a ready made team and brought in Busquettes from the youth team

He started the Barca era of dominance nothing was easy for him in his time there
 
Could argue Keane and Scholes were the best midfielders in Europe at certain points in their careers. Giggs, Beckham, Stam, Irwin, Cole, RvN, Veron, Giggs, Stam, Schmiechel, Kanchelskis, Ronaldo, Tevez, Rio, Vidic, Rooney...He wasn't exactly working with slim pickings now.

Not taking anything away from Fergie, wouldn't swap him for anyone, nor am I trying to blow smoke up Zidane's arse. My point wasn't really meant to be directed towards anyone here either

My point pretty much was, how come Zidane is not talked about as the 2nd coming, as Guardiola was, when they both had two seasons under their belt in their careers?
Why is Zidane not talked up more? Why is his achievements just given a nod of, "meh yeah whatever" by the same people who think Guardiola is some sort of Messiah?

Because 2 similar results don't need to have the same causation. It's perfectly possible that one coach won stuff because he did great coaching work and the other won the same stuff because of a culmination of luck and being a good motivator and not much else. Most people can see the difference. Nevermind Zidane, it's why Luis Enrique never got the recognition by Barca fans (let alone the football world) despite winning a treble and double.
 
I would be shocked if most weren’t long familiar with translating apps/extensions
Good point, but I don't think many people bother reading the horrible automated translations when they're longer than a tweet.

Personnally speaking French and a semi functional Spanish I can decipher Catalan decently but it becomes a real pain when it's longer than a small paragraph.
 
Ramos and Isco got injured apparently, things just get worse and worse for Zidane.

They went from being mediocre to winning 6 trophies in 12 months. How much could they have aged in 12 months? A year. Iniesta was 23, hardly a teenage youngster.

They weren't mediocre. They should have probably beaten United in the semis of the Champions League and the point gap in the league didn't represent the actual gap in quality since they lost a bunch of those points after they lost the league. They won 13 points in their last 13 league games.

They did improve a lot but it gets overstated how bad they were in the season before Pep arrived.
 
Barca hadn't won anything for 2 years when Pep arrived

In the season before he was appointed people were saying the B team was coached better than the main team

It was clear to see Guardiola wasn't just a normal manager at Barcelona B

He cleared out Deco, Ronaldinho, Zambrotta and Thuram retired

He had anything but a ready made team and brought in Busquettes from the youth team

He started the Barca era of dominance nothing was easy for him in his time there
There's no doubt Pep deserves credit for changing the party environment and adding structure, but this was a team that barely lost to United in the CL final. The front 3 iirc was Eto, Messi and Henry, I mean what team right now has a front 3 that compares to that? Maybe Barca of 2 years ago with Suarez, Messi and Neymar? Zidane came in to a similar situation, extremely talented team that just needed balance. Pep's a great manager when he has his type of players but as we all saw last season he's no SAF. He's not going to get you titles by improving what he has available. We will find out more about Zidane once he leaves RM.
 
Actually over 2 seasons, Zidane won 7 trophies and Pep won 8
Zidane did nothing with the Castilla side while Pep won the 4th division
Never won a treble
Never won 6 trophies over a season, translating to winning every competition they entered
Over 9 Clasicos, RM won only once against Pep - with Zidane over 4 Clasicos, they won only once as well
One created a memorable style of play that defined an era, the other will not & will most certainly be out of a job before year 3 of their tenure

Just saying...

No offence but, I rarely post anymore however, I do read this forum quite a bit.

You stick out a lot!
 
They went from being mediocre to winning 6 trophies in 12 months. How much could they have aged in 12 months? A year. Iniesta was 23, hardly a teenage youngster.
That was the end of Rijkaard's cycle. Simply put he'd lost the players

They did improve a lot but it gets overstated how bad they were in the season before Pep arrived.
They were very much mediocre as a team, not individually. Not a much different situation from us this season really(or under Benitez)

Isco's injury comes at a good time, he can play the bbc without problems now
 
I mistakenly clicked on the zidane thread expecting to read about actual zidane, only to found the same pep is god yadda yadda we get to see every 2 days in this forum

My bad.
 
Seriously. This place nowadays reeks of 'pepism'. Yes, he is the 'inventor' of beautiful football and every other manager is shit. Yes, players play for him without any renumeration. Yes, he can do no wrong. Yes, he has created the 'greatest' team in the 100 odd years of english football history.

I mean do we have to be fed these 'facts' as benitez would say, again and again? The way these barcelona players and fans talk about this guy, it feels the entire club and their fans are in the business of brainwashing people into thinking that his way is the right way. So I think it's best that we don't bring up any counter-arguments when these cules(or whatever these barca boys are called) say that he is the best ever. It's best to ignore and speak about what the topic that the thread intended.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mciahel Goodman
Seriously. This place nowadays reeks of 'pepism'. Yes, he is the 'inventor' of beautiful football and every other manager is shit. Yes, players play for him without any renumeration. Yes, he can do no wrong. Yes, he has created the 'greatest' team in the 100 odd years of english football history.

I mean do we have to be fed these 'facts' as benitez would say, again and again? The way these barcelona players and fans talk about this guy, it feels the entire club and their fans are in the business of brainwashing people into thinking that his way is the right way. So I think it's best that we don't bring up any counter-arguments when these cules(or whatever these barca boys are called) say that he is the best ever. It's best to ignore and speak about what the topic that the thread intended.

He is a very good manager to be fair. His teams also play nice football. He has pretty much had the best squad in whatever league he's been in for every season he has managed which will be a slight question mark until it is not the case.
 
Both Messi and Iniesta were too young to make a mark under Rijkarrd as they did from then on. If you believe either won't have been as good without Pep then I would disagree with that 100%.

And Rijkaard has proven to be a very poor manager ever since. In the same way Enrique proved to be pretty below par before taking over a team with the best player of all team there.
 
Spain won the Euros literally weeks before Pep took charge with Iniesta and Xavi starting in midfield.
Maybe the rumours of Pep taking charge inspired the masses to greater heights.
 
Hang on, I thought Lvg was the one responsible for Barca success (and all the other success in the football universe)
 
He should stay even if Madrid don't win the Champions League. He fecked up a lot in the league (and in the Copa Del Rey) but with Madrid going for a third CL in a row and the WC at the end of the season, this is a pretty abnormal season with players preparing their season to peak at the end of it.

He clearly knows what he's doing and the team is playing for him.
 
The greatest of all time.

Player: European Cup winner, World Cup winner, Serie A & La Liga winner, Champion's League winner, winner of multiple other domestic trophies.
Manager: La Liga winner, 3x Champion's League winner.

And he's only 45 :lol: He's already had managerial success up there with the very best (without the longevity you can argue), and has always been regarded as one of the games greats. Surely you put the two together, there's no doubt - He's the greatest. Fair play.
 
Last edited:
Make that a hat-trick. What a legend of the game, yet strangely still underrated whilst everyone creams themselves over Pep.
 
Sets his team up so well. Honestly I thought Liverpool would look a lot more deadly on the counter (at least when Salah was on the pitch), but Zidane knew how the teams would match up stylistically and did what he needed to do to combat Liverpool’s strengths.
 
His record since he took over is pretty spectacular. I hope he stays as long as fergie did with you guys.

He always gets his subs spot on too.
 
More Champions League wins than SAF. Mind blowing start to his managerial career.
 
Make that a hat-trick. What a legend of the game, yet strangely still underrated whilst everyone creams themselves over Pep.

Because Pep Guardiola is the better manager? Great achievement even with the jammy scenarios. What Zidane does so well is get the best out of his players by keeping them happy and motivated, he's no tactical genius but I suspect the aura he carries as a great player helps him a lot.
 
His goal is still the best but now he's become my favorite player/manager of all time, if he leaves us I would expect him to go and take France and make them World Champions, he's that good. :drool:

P.S. He has also won an UCL as assistant of Ancelotti so he's been part of 4 UCL in the last 5 years.
 
Because Pep Guardiola is the better manager? Great achievement even with the jammy scenarios. What Zidane does so well is get the best out of his players by keeping them happy and motivated, he's no tactical genius but I suspect the aura he carries as a great player helps him a lot.
Is he? What’s Pep done in Europe without Messi? Last time he won the CL was the year after Jose who many are quick to call yesterday’s man.
 
Is he? What’s Pep done in Europe without Messi? Last time he won the CL was the year after Jose who many are quick to call yesterday’s man.

Luckily for him he we don't judge managers solely on what they do in Europe.
 
Three in a row can’t be argued with. This early into his managerial career and he can already be spoken about as the GOAT in Europe.
 
Luckily for him he we don't judge managers solely on what they do in Europe.
True but it’s still important considering he took over a treble winning side at Bayern and a Sheikh’s plaything at City.